Richard Lloyd Parry in Hirakata
Win luxury hampers plus Waitrose vouchers & guidebooks
For 62 years Akira Makino spoke not a word of what he had done. But to those who knew him well it must have been obvious that he was a man with a tortured conscience. Why else would he have returned so often to the obscure, mosquito-blown town in the southern Philippines where he experienced such misery during the Second World War? He set up war memorials, gave clothes to poor children, and bought an entire set of uniforms for a local baseball team.
Last year, at the age of 83, he embarked on a gruelling pilgrimage to 88 Buddhist temples in Japan. After number 40 he collapsed from heat exhaustion, having permanently injured his knees. “My wife didn’t like me going back to the Philippines — she called me ‘war crazy’,” said Mr Makino, a frail old man who lives alone in Hirakata, near Osaka. “But she let me go anyway. Right up until she died three years ago, I never told her. But over time I think she realised.”
Only in the twilight of his life has Mr Makino begun to talk about the secret he carried for more than 60 years. In 1944, as a medical auxiliary in the Imperial Navy, he was stationed on the island of Mindanao in the southern Philippines. There he was party to one of the most notorious and poorly chronicled cruelties of the Japanese war effort — the medical dissection of living prisoners of war.
Over four months before the defeat of the Japanese forces in March 1945, Mr Makino cut open ten Filipino prisoners, including two teenage girls. He amputated their limbs and cut up and removed their livers, kidneys, wombs and still beating hearts for no better reason than to improve his knowledge of anatomy.
“It was educational,” he said. “Even today when I go to see doctors they are impressed by my knowledge of the human body. But if I’m really honest, the reason we did it was to take revenge on these people who were spying for the Americans. Now, of course I feel terrible about the cruel thing that I did, and I think of it so often. But at the time what I felt for these people was closer to hatred than to pity.”
There have been other accounts of medical vivisection, most notoriously by Unit 731, a top-secret arm of the Imperial Army which killed thousands of Chinese and Russian prisoners in Manchuria in the name of scientific research. But Mr Makino’s is the first such testimony to have emerged from the Philippines — and from the Navy, which was regarded as the less cruel and fanatical of the Imperial Armed Forces.
Apart from the extraordinary climax of his wartime story, Mr Makino comes across as a typical Japanese of his generation — a polite, well-meaning man who lacked the courage and daring that would have been needed to stand up to the Imperial war machine. It was in such an atmosphere that he found himself in Zamboanga, a Muslim town in the far southwest of the Philippines.
The population were the Moro people, an assortment of jungle tribes legendary as ferocious head hunters. The Japanese feared and hated them; as the US forces drew closer they arrested many of them as spies and threw them into a hellish pit where they were left to rot. “I don’t know whether they really were spies or not,” Mr Makino said. “All that was needed was for someone to say that they were. We knew that we’d lost the war. Our psychological state was very strange by then. In those conditions, we could do anything, absolutely anything.” It began with a practice that has been described by a number of former Japanese soldiers — the “testing” of traditional Japanese swords on live prisoners.
One day towards the end of 1944, Mr Makino was summoned by his commanding officer, a navy doctor. “He told me that if anything happened to him I had to take over from him. He told me to come and see a vivisection. The first time it was one prisoner, a middle-aged man. He’d already given up — there was no struggle. He was tied to the bed and anaesthetised with ether, so that he was completely unconscious. The lieutenant showed me what to do. He cut him open, and pointed out, ‘Here’s the liver, here’s the kidneys, here’s the heart’. The heart was still beating, then he cut the heart open and showed me the inside. That was when he died.
“I didn’t want to do it, but it was an order, you see. At that time, if a commander gave you an order it was understood that it was the order of the Emperor, and the Emperor was a god. I had no choice — if I had disobeyed I would have been killed.”
The “operation” took about an hour; when it was over the body was sewn up and thrown into a hole in the earth. Eight more vivisections followed, Mr Makino said. “We removed some of the organs and amputated legs and arms. Two of the victims were women, young women, 18 or 19 years old. I hesitate to say it, but we opened up their wombs to show the younger soldiers. They knew very little about women — it was sex education.
When the Americans landed in March 1945, the Japanese scattered into the jungle. Mr Makino spent seven months living like an animal, alone. When he returned to Japan the feelings of remorse began.
He said: “I was under orders, you see. But I know that I did a terrible thing.”
Atrocities remembered
— Up to 300,000 Chinese were killed by biological weapons between 1938 and 1945
— 200,000 women are thought to have been made to work in Japanese military brothels during the war
— The construction of the Railway of Death, linking Thailand and Burma and including the bridge over the River Kwai, cost the lives of 13,000 prisoners of war and up to 100,000 civilians Between December 1937 and March 1938 Japanese troops occupying the Chinese city of Nanjing killed an estimated 275,000 people, many of them women and children
— In 2000 a Japanese company paid $4.6 million compensation to 1,000 foreign labourers forced to work as slaves to support Japan's war effort
Sources: Times archive; the Hoover Institute
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Times Online's new TV show helps you make the right decisions for your pet
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles


Overseas contacts and local business information

A treasure trove of baubles, booty and stylish quests

2007
£47,995
2008
£42,945
06/2006
£40,850
Great car insurance deals online
£33,000
Macmillan Cancer Support
Central/South West
£50k
NHS
Nationwide
£
£30k OTE
Meltwater News
Nationwide
circa £70k
Central Office of Information
London
5% below developer pre-launch price!
Luxury Appts, beautiful gardens w/ Thames views
Great Homes Available on a shared Ownership Basis
Great Investment, River Views
Visit the ‘entertainment capital of the world’
at great sale prices!
Christmas Cruises
From only £995pp
APTs East Coast now from only
£2425pp.
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - find property for sale and rent in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
In my opinion, IF what he says is correct, he should be hanged by the Japanese at least in a moral sense. However, I think this "IF" is really big. According to this article, the only eye-witness to his act of crime is "a navy doctor," his supervisor, who has been long dead in the war. Those two conspired the heinous acts, so there should be no document showing the chain of command. hope the author of this article has the responsibility to double check his stories with other witness from the same regimen.
I know some old soldiers entering their senile moments have beautifully grotesque hallucinations. For example, Azuma Shiro, who wrote how he elegantly massacred civilians with his grenade in Nanjing was sued by the captain of the platoon and lost the case. This is what is strange: Red China praises him and treats him as if he were a hero: to me, if what he says in his "diary" written post war is correct, then he is an abhorrent murderer, duly despised for what he has done.
buvery, NY, US
Oh Ryan,
It is Hong Kong, China now. It is no longer a colony!
Julian, San Francisco, US
Do not broadbrush this as "war is awful". 90% of old-Japan do not feel they did wrong and 90% of new-Japan does not know of any of this. Do we continue to be Chimpanzees or should we address it so that we can all move forward.
Julian, San Francisco, US
Thank you Richard Lloyd Parry for bringing this to our attention.
I have two comments.
I certainly agree that it is important to find solidarity and to recognize the human in our enemy but the degree to which history has been and is being erased in Japan is an affront. I wonder to what degree Mr. Makino's punishment, a life of torment, can atone for his acts.
I also wonder to what extent the cruel savagery of Mr. Makino and his colleagues is being mirrored or extended in our world today?
C.J. Creighton, Okayama, Japan
Ⅰjust found out none of the death sentences in the Kyushu vivisection case were carried out.
Ryan, I agree with your sentiments. But as a matter of fact, human empathy for the other is on avverage very shallow. After all, we are chimpanzees. (Here, I'm tempted to go into my mental litany of wrongs perpetrated by what nation and on whom. But I'm not interested in the shouting match that will ensue.) We can only hope to keep expanding the extent of those whom we wish to consider our own.
Jun Okumura, Tokyo, Japan
not sure i like the quiet racism of many of these posts. don voss, would you prefer we didn't remember the holocaust? and are you sugesting we only remember because of "jews in the movie business"?
dave from london- "and we're now supposed to accept them as equals?" if by "they" you mean the japanese, then yes, as the 99.9% of today's japanese would find this as horrifying as we do.
surely chaps, the point is solidarity with all human suffering? not bickering over if those who suffered were american, filipino, japnese or jewish...
Ryan, Hong Kong, hong kong
Man's inhmanity to man. Yes, there is a Hell.
In the U.S., the singular atrocity that everyone is aware of is the Holocaust. Since there are many Jews in the movie business, directors and producers are expected to do an obligory Holocaust movie. The Poles killed, as well as the Gypsies (Roma) and metnally ill killed in the Holcaust, are not mentioned.
Few people here are aware of the 20 million killed by Stalin in the former Soviet Union, The millions in the "killing fields" of Cambodia, and more recently, the half-million that were slaughtered on Bill Clinton's watch in Rwanda. We did not lift a hand. No oil there. As Bush Sr, commented, "We did not have a dog in that fight".
Don Voss, Saint Charles, Missouri. USA
It was kind of the American Occupation forces to spare the Japanese the purging process that Germans underwent, but ultimately it has made Germany the far better society and Japan still has the stony road ahead of coming to terms with barbarity and bestiality.
The Germans had the good fortune to banish the ghosts of yesteryear probably because they wee occupied by Four Powers and not just One.
TomTom, Leeds, England
And we're supposed to now accept them as equals?
Dave, London, England
nothing new
not really news is it?
If you are going to report this stuff, do it properly. Loads of Chinese and Koreans were tortured and killed this way, as were a number of allied prisoners, which is usually forgotten. After the war many of the Jap. doctors were not prosecuted as war criminals in exchange for what they had learned (like the german rocket scientists)
by the way, the Japanese Navy was regarded as less fanatical (brave and patriotic) by whom? What about the Yamato? What about the battles against the US Navy when they had no chance of winning?
Kevin Lax, Shanghai, China
Hey David Hicks been held the GW BUSH Holiday Inn Cuba for 5 years on suspicion of being a terrorist, no allegation by prosecution he actually killed or injured anyone just he was anti-American.
This man self confessed japanese war criminal no action being taken by anyone.
If crimes against humanity or war crimes to mean anything then we should prosecute the people involved no matter when it happens. Its only by making the ordinary man realise that war crimes wrong and orders from their leaders shouldn't be followed that this sort of behaviour will ever be stopped
Mark Carter, Perth, Australia
HAVE YOUR SAY
What can a 'normal' human being say about Japanese or any other war atrocities?
Fred, Fredsville, USA,
To John Stafford of Virginia. Unfortunately none of the known Japanese war crimes of a medical nature were ever prosecuted. This seems mainly due to the results and data being aquired and used by the Allies after the war. Lobbying by the jewish survivors of the Third Reich prevented the release of that body of information thus it was not hypocritical of the Allies to prosecute the crimes.
It is interesting to note that those accused of attrocities against the Allied forces in the death camps in SE Asia were prosecuted.
Rohan, Brisbane, Australia
Why is this man not being tried for war crimes? If he had been a Nazi and cut open concentration camp victims, you would expect him to be tried for his crimes. But because he's sorry, that absolves him of responsibility?
John, Stafford, Virginia, USA