Catherine Philp in Upper Gereshk Valley
Star musicians and your favourite Times writers at the Albert Hall
Click here
to see a gallery of Peter Nicholls' photographs
Lit by the fireworks of an artillery barrage, the Gurkhas crouched in the
desert chill, waiting for the command to move. In silence they crept across
a bridge slung over the canal into enemy territory. Dawn came and went
without a sighting. And then the Taleban attacked.
Barely 12 hours into Operation Palk Wahel, or Sledgehammer Hit, the biggest
British military offensive in Afghanistan since the spring, the Gurkhas had
met their enemy. Rifle cracks filled the air, bullets pinging in the dust as
rocket-propelled grenades skimmed overhead.
“Get down,” a commander screamed, and the men scurried to a ditch beside the
poppy field, firing towards the trees where the Taleban were hiding.
Overhead the eerie grunting of fighter jet cannon could be heard strafing
the enemy.
It was the resistance that the Gurkhas had been expecting since they crept out
from the desert under a fingernail moon and into the notorious “green zone”,
the dense sliver of fertile land alongside the Helmand river that the
Taleban have made their domain.
Pushed out by British troops from the towns of Gereshk and Sangin at either
end of the valley, it was here that the Taleban retreated, taking refuge in
the fortress-like mud compounds set in a maze of towering corn criss-crossed
with streams and irrigation ditches.
“It is nothing like the rest of Helmand, it is more like the Normandy bocage,”
Lieutenant-Colonel Jonny Bourne, the commanding officer of the Gurkhas,
said, evoking the beautiful but treacherous terrain that Allied forces had
to fight through after the 1944 Normandy landings. “The Taleban know that in
the desert we can beat them every time. But in the green zone they have the
upper hand.”
British troops have battled through the green zone several times in the past
six months and driven the Taleban out, but each time that they have moved
on, the Taleban have come back, wreaking vengeance on villagers who
cooperated with the foreigners.
This time it is meant be different. Military commanders and civilians have
planned the offensive together. The idea is to hold territory so that
reconstruction can begin, wooing locals away from the Taleban.
“If you drive out the Taleban, you’ve got to endure,” said David Slinn, the
civilian head of the provincial reconstruction team for Helmand. “There have
been lessons learnt.”
So, on their first day on the Helmand front line, the Gurkhas crept across a
metal footbridge into the Taleban stronghold. To the south soldiers from the
Mercian Regiment, nearing the end of their tour, would move northwards to
join them.
The Gurkhas, the legendary Nepalese warriors, were chosen for this role. No
other regiment could be better suited, their commanding officer said, for
this combination of ferocious fighting and winning of local hearts and
minds. “The Gurkhas have a natural advantage here,” Colonel Bourne said.
“They have an affinity with the people here. It’s in that interaction with
the people where we want to make a real difference.”
Before that, however, would come the fighting. “They are the loveliest people
in the world,” Colonel Bourne added. “But when the switch is flicked, it
gets very nasty.”
Pinned down in the poppy field, the switch flicked. “Excuse me,” a Gurkha
machinegunner whispered politely before squeezing past to take his position
and blast towards the enemy.
Before battle Sergeant Tarjan Gurung, a smiling veteran of ten years with “Do
or Die” stencilled on the back of his helmet, had explained the mood.
“Everybody finds it quite exciting,” he said. “You’re going to face a real
enemy who will stand and fight.”
As the battle raged, Captain Jit Bahadur appeared panting in the ditch.
“Nobody here injured?” he asked. “That’s good luck. It is a very heavy
ambush from the enemy.” Minutes before the ambush, C Company had stopped to
rest from an all-night trek, ripping open rations for a quick lunch. “If
they had attacked when we were resting, it would have been a disaster,”
Captain Bahadur said.
The company commander was considering withdrawing. “The resistance is very
heavy,” Captain Bahadur said, shaking his head. Everyone knew, though, that
retreat was not an option.
In the village of Hyderabad the summer fighting had driven out the entire
civilian population, leaving their homes to the Taleban, who used them for
their defences. The Gurkhas found empty compound after empty compound, walls
smashed from heavy bombing and littered with the old rations wrappers of
troops that had gone before them. “I remember this place,” muttered Sergeant
Don Jenkins, a Royal Marine who had taken part in an operation in July. “We
lost Atherton here.”
In another compound they laid a bar mine to blast through the mud wall for
fear of another ambush on the other side.
Captain David Stanhope looked anxious. He had come with the Gurkhas to assess
what reconstruction could be done as soon as the fighting was over. In his
rucksack he carried bundles of dollars ready to be doled out for quick-fix
projects. “But there’s no one here,” he said. “I don’t know what we can do
with no civilians.”
One such deserted compound became home for the night. Running low on water,
the troops filled bottles from a foul-smelling well, dropping purification
tablets inside. Later an order came round to ignore the water and hope for a
supply the next day – the risk that the Taleban might have poisoned the well
was too high. Second Lieutenant Emile Simpson, 24, on his first day of
operations, nursed a painful rib, probably broken, from what he believed was
a bullet that glanced off his body armour.
Major Charlie Crowe, the commander of C Company, examined a map. By Day 3 the
company needed to reach the “Witch’s Hat”, where the Taleban had turned a
medical clinic into a fortress overlooking a lush marijuana field, digging
deep defensive ditches around it. British troops had stormed the surrounding
settlement, known as “Waterloo”, in April, freeing from the Taleban a local
official scheduled for beheading the next day because of his ties to the
Government. But the troops had not stayed, and the Taleban had returned,
bringing punishment to those seen to cooperate with the foreigners and the
Government.
A second dawn came and the company was moving through another bombed-out
compound when it came under fire again. Gunfire erupted for several minutes
until a cry came of “Stop, stop!” Their attackers, it turned out, were from
the Afghan National Army, which, after one of its sentries was hit by
gunfire, began firing immediately on a known Taleban position - the one the
Gurkhas were now clearing.
A similar confusion a day earlier had thrown the second Gurkha company into a
battle with the brigade reconnaissance force for ten minutes before both
sides realised their mistake. That same night A Company had become lost for
four hours on its way to a resupply point.
Two days in and the fatigue was showing - at least for the commanders and
British officers, medics and specialists attached to the company. A third
night would bring little more sleep. As the soldiers dozed, Major Crowe
pleaded over the radio for his troops to be allowed a night’s sleep before
the assault. He was overruled: the company must be in position by the time
dawn came. “I think this is where the battle will really begin,” Captain
Bahadur whispered.
This time, however, the Taleban had already fled. When the company arrived
through the marijuana field at the Witch’s Hat, they found it deserted. The
artillery barrage that lit their passage into the Helmand bocage three
nights before had pounded the building almost to dust. The Gurkhas looked
around, wondering at the desertion. If they were disappointed, they did not
show it. “Seems they knew we were coming,” Major Crowe remarked.
On the other side of the canal Captain Stanhope was talking to a farmer who
had returned to the village that morning. Naimatullah Agha Lala had left
five months earlier because of the fighting and was living with other
villages in the pacified town of Gereshk. He had returned to collect animal
feed after hearing that British troops were retaking the area.
It was not the first time that he had seen the British here: a few months ago
he had even been given a compensation form for the damage that the fighting
had done to his house. “But then you went away and the Taleban came back. We
are caught in the middle here. The Government thinks we have links to the
Taleban and the Taleban think we are with the Government.”
Captain Stanhope handed him leaflets promising reconstruction. The farmer
responded: “It’s not good to take this. If the Taleban see me with it, they
will say we are cooperating.”
This time, Captain Stanhope said, the British would be staying. Mr Lala said
he hoped so. “If you go from this place again, the Taleban will
automatically come back again,” he said, looking doubtfully at his leaflet.
“Can I throw this away now?”
Over the radio the commanders assessed the enemy withdrawal. The Taleban had
either fled south to consolidate or retreated north towards their stronghold
of Musa Qala. The next days would begin to tell.
The Taleban had suffered a bad summer, and the retreat suggested that they
were struggling to replace their fighters, forcing them to sacrifice
territory, instead. Perhaps they, like the civilians, did not believe that
the British would stay this time either, and that if they bided their time
they could soon be back.
“This is our chance now to show we are going to dominate, that we are not
going to allow this place to fall back into Taleban hands,” Major Crowe
said.
Fighters on familiar terrain
— The Hindu warrior saint Guru Gorakhnath named his disciple Bappa Rawal’s
people “Gurkhas” in the 8th century and ordered them to liberate
Afghanistan, then a Hindu-Buddhist nation, from the advancing Muslims.
— In 1879 Gurkha regiments served in the British Army during the Second Afghan
War, clashing with Afghan tribesmen.
— Afghanistan gained its independence from Britain in 1919 after the war for
independence in which Gurkha troops fought for the British. Nepal’s
independence was recognised by the British four years later.
— Nepali and the Afghan language Dari belong to the Indo-Iranian family.
— Gurkhas, traditionally recruited from the lower foothills of the Annapurna
mountains, are able to acclimatise quickly to high altitudes across much of
Afghanistan.
— The Afghan climate swings between extremes. Winters are cold and snowy while
summers are hot and dry. The climate of Nepal ranges from subzero
temperatures in high-altitude regions to subtropical in the lowlands.
Sources: NOAA Satellite and Information
Service ; explorenepal.com ; army.mod.uk
; khukurihouseonline.com
See a gallery of Peter Nicholls's pictures at timesonline.co.uk/world
Follow our three athletes' progress in their preparations for the London Triathlon, and pick up training tips and more
Enjoy screenings of all the classic films you love, plus take advantage of two-for-one tickets
We explore leisure activities that are safe and suitable for all of the family
Times Online's new TV show helps you make the right decisions for your pet
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles


Overseas contacts and local business information

A treasure trove of baubles, booty and stylish quests


£129,500
Bentley Edinburgh
£79,850
Mercedes-Benz of Northampton
£26,995
Unit 1, Woodfield Business Unit, Kidderminster Road, Ombersley, Worcester.
Great car insurance deals online
90k + Bonus + Options
Confidential
London
£23,716 +
Highways Agency
National
£
£43,405 - £48,228 pa
Notting Hill Housing
London
£30,000 base, £100,000 OTE
Riches Consulting
London/South
with annexe accommodation and 5.25 acres
£1,100,000
Beautiful Gardens w/ stunning Thames Views
Studios £33K, 1 Beds £60K, 2 beds £79K
Mortgages, bank acc & money transfers to help you buy abroad
Explore mystical Jordan
From £1030 for 7nts 4*
to USA's Most Cosmopolitan City; San Francisco!
£POA
Book Now for Winter 08/09 and Get 10% off!
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Search globrix.com to buy or rent UK property. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
people have probably said the same thing as i am about to say but i will say it anyway.
its a disgrace how the british government treats these hero's.
if they want to stay in britain then they should be allowed to simple as that, they should also get the same pension as a british solider because when it comes down to it these people have gave and done more for britain than what most british people have.
hopefully if i pass the royal marine course i could be working along side the Gurkhas.
ROBIN, GLASGOW, SCOTLAND
i am a son of british gurkha ...and right now i am residing in britain....of course i am proud of what my ancestors have done but sometimes when i look at people of other nationality in britain ..i think we haven't been treated rightly...britain is not the only nation in the world but the way some people behaves ..it is really outrageous ...especially when the gurkhas have done some much for this nation....
the more i think about these things i feel that gurkhas were merely made as a scapegoat to die in the battle field ....the time has indeed come for the british government to recognise the individuality of a gurkha and give them what they deserve...unless britain will still be called as a hypocrite nation..
cheers
kiran kc , london, great britain
The Royal Gurkha Rifles have never claimed that their nepali soldiers speak pushtu or farsi the native languages of Afghanistan. Most however speak fluent Hindi. This is a very similar language to urdu. The Gurkhas grow up watching bollywood films. Many Afghanis speak urdu, and grow up watching Hindi bollywood films. This enables the Gurkhas to communicate and to learn the languages of Afghanistan a lot quicker than your average Glaswegian soldier whose closest link to the cultures and languages of the sub continent and central asia are a lamb madras on a saturday night. Having lived in both Nepal, the Afghan border and studied middle eastern, and central asian languages, their cultures are a lot closer (but still distinctly different) than said Glaswegian soldier. So I ask you now, of all the Regiments in the British army whichis best suited if not perfect to win the hearts and minds of the Afghan people?
ac, pokhara, nepal
"War is an ugly thing, but not the ugliest of things: .... A war to protect other human beings against tyrannical injustice; a war to give victory to their own ideas of right and good, and which is their own war, carried on for an honest purpose by their own free choice-is often the means of their regeneration." John Stuart Mill
I give thanks that there are those willing to place their lives on the line. I also feel for the loved ones of these soldiers who must read this report with gut wrenching dread.
Stephen Digby, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia
That last comment must now be changed as 24 hours after it was posted Major Lex Roberts of the Royal Gurkha Rifles became the first Gurkha to be killed in Afghanistan. I m sure that the newspapers will report his death.
ac, pokhara, nepal
No soldiers from the Brigade of Gurkhas have been killed in Iraq or Afgahanistan so far. Definitely not from the 2 battalions of the Royal Gurkha Rifles. This would probably explain why Gurkha deaths have not been reported not because of your pre conceptions. That said the work of D Coy 2 RGR was overshadowed by that of 3 PARA. Also the Gurkhas 'rivalry nickname' as its has been referred to is actually 'the bravest of the brave' but they seem quite proud that they can be referred to as 'The Gurkhas' and this sums up more than enough respect and kudos. Royal marine commandos are referred to as booties and cabbage heads, i m not sure how this is an advantage? And your reader is correct pre 1997 Gurkhas are not entitled to UK citizenship, but all since 1997 now are, and are given equal terms and condition of service including pensions since 1997. More needs to be done for ex WW2, Borneo and Malaya veterans though.
ac, pokhara, nepal
Once trekking near Annapurna, at times above the snowline, I found that the hut I intended to sleep in was locked up for the winter - the locals wouldn't use that route again until the spring. I had to continue in the dark to try to reach a village, on the hills facing the south face of Annapurna, the highest of all mountainsides. Eventually, I saw lights and shortly thereafter was greeted in excellent English by a former Ghurka soldier. Most of the men in the village were ex-British Army, their earnings reflected iin the quality of the housing.
Coincidentally, just before I left London (in 1972) I'd seen the King of Afghanistan in a head-of-state procession with the Gurkha Regiment providing the guard of honour. The terrain in most of Afghanistan is much harsher than the Gurhka area of Nepal, but both groups of necessity know how to cope in adverse circumstances, and will surely relate well.
Faustino, Brisbane, Australia
Your reader Hatti is absolutely correct. I have worked in Afghanistan and had 'Gurkhas' nepalese guards on my project security force along with Afghans. There is NO AFFINITY between Afghans and Nepalese. Their differences caused no end of problems for me out in the desert. The only thing they have in common with the Afghans is that they are from the same continent. Afghans know Afghans and it is Afghans that the international community should be empowering to provide security in Afghanistan. Embedded trainers/ advisers from western armies are the real solution in the short to medium term. Great PR article for the Gurkha Battalion, but in reality they are no better at the job of fighting and engaging the local community than the Afghan Army.
Tony, Baghdad, Iraq
The gurkhas are no better equipped for such operations than anyone else. The idea that they have some special rapport with Afghans is ludicrous, as is the idea that similar weather conditions (impossible to prove, anyway) make them more suitable. Their language is not similar to Dari, or to Pashto or Urdu.
Absurd generalisations along the line of "These dark-skinned johnnies were made for carrying heavy loads under a tropical sun for 15 hours at a stretch. Damn tough brutes. Like a bit of the whip too."
Hatti, Pottington Green,
You make us all proud. Carry on the great job you are doing.
www.supportingourtroops.co.uk
Richard, Stamford, Lincolnshire
bilbo: Perhaps it's just that the Gurkhas, and some others, are highly cognizant of, and respectful towards, their traditions.
Knowing that there's a reputation to uphold, and predecessors to admire, can go a long way in bolstering one's actions.
Eric, Ottawa, Canada
I cannot say I have seen reports of killed Gurkhas in Iraq and Afganistan,,,do British newspapers report them when killed.
I think they are not reported somehow
I noted the term::
wreaking vengeance on villagers who cooperated with the foreigners
Seems we Brits are repeating what we have done in Iraq,,leaving the locals who help us to be killed,,(remember the interpreters in Iraq, I still have not heard of them being pulled out yet)
Nicholas Iles, Oswestry, Shropshire
And these are the same courageous and loyal soldiers that the British government treat so shamefully and who in official terms "have no ties with the United Kingdom and can therefore not be granted a right to long term or permanent residence". [Home Secretary as reported in Hansard].
If any clue were needed as to how the military regard the Gurkha it is that unlike other regiments they are never described with a humerous or friendly rivalry nickname. They are simply 'The Gurkhas'.
Jonathan Mills, Brighton,
I agree with the comments about them being guaranteed citizenship - perhaps we could open the doors for them and close the doors for less desirable immigrants, but somehow I doubt it will happen.
tony, birmingham, uk
Thank you not only to the Gurkas, but to the entire British military as well. Only one nation has stood alongside the US since day one in both Afghanistan and the debacle known as Iraq: the UK. For this, we Americans are very grateful. Only 481 days left in the Bush presidency!
BobRob, Little Rock, Arkansas
Thank you for the article Catherine and a very warm and heartfelt thank you to all the Ghurkas whose service to Great Britain has been second to none and a real honour to the nation. They should all be granted automatic and full citizenship at the end of their terms!.
Not to be forgotten of course; many, many thanks to our excellent Army and RM whose daily work we only need look at to be reminded that as hazy as modern values may be, we can still produce men of character and resolve. May God's protection and blessing be with you all.
Richard, Dallas, USA
it's almost like the author of this article and the military officers interviewed believe in some Jungian collective racial memory, as if the Gurkhas are naturals due to the experiences of their ancestors in Afghanistan. While both Farsi/Persian and Nepali are Indo-Iranian languages, they are not mutually intelligible. Seems like you guys really bought into the theory of "Martial Races" created during the Raj.
bilbo, london,