David Blunkett: Commentary
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
Those who see Nicolas Sarkozy as some kind of miniature Margaret Thatcher or a hardline right-winger, would be very wide of the mark.
His instincts are those of international capital but his understanding is, crucially, that globalisation means that France, like Britain, has to face the world as it really is. In other words he is a modernist, a pragmatist and, yes, a committed progressive. He is progressive in terms of wanting to modernise the social model that has brought so much to France but has also resulted in it having twice the British level of unemployment, and created a state of affairs where those who have jobs (substantially those in the public sector) are safe, while those who don’t (substantially young people) find themselves alienated and outside the well-protected and cosy structure of a bygone era. That is why Mr Sarkozy refers so often to Tony Blair and Britain. He understands the formula for ensuring low unemployment, economic stability, growth and the ability to invest in public services over the long term.
His stance in relation to the economy and public spending is that in order to be able to afford substantial public provision and, in particular, income in retirement you have to earn it.
So, what about this “hard man”? I believe that he is an individual who offers a clear way forward, strong leadership and clarity of thought.
Whatever the strengths of Ségolène Royal, and they are many, Mr Sarkozy knows how to take decisions.
He and I reached agreement on the refugee camp known as Sangatte. But, more importantly, we reached agreement about intelligence and immigration services from Britain being placed on French soil. This was a brave act from a patriot. Mr Sarkozy is an anglophile who knew just how far to go and who recognised the benefits that would be gained from sending a strong message to those organised criminals who were trafficking people across Europe to Calais and the French coast.
But to understand Mr Sarkozy it is necessary to understand the impatience that this man has for change, to help people to cope with change but to face it bravely. Here is a man who is able not only to take decisions but is also not frightened to take difficult ones.
He has the strength to face the French nation with questions that they were in the past reluctant to address – the nature of France in the 21st century, its international position, its need to acknowledge globalisation and its impact. And here’s the rub. With Mr Sarkozy as President it may be possible to have an Anglo-French dialogue that will take us back more than 100 years to the Entente Cordiale but in a much more realistic fashion.
And, who knows, if he is able to influence Angela Merkel, a new and better approach to the European Union may emerge rather than a Franco-German hegemony. And, above all, we may begin to create a Europe for decent people that does not tolerate the mind-blowing, energy-sapping bureaucracy that currently bedevils Brussels.
For in my dealings with Mr Sarkozy, privately and publicly, he, like me, was intolerant of time-wasting, irrelevance, the inability to take decisions and, above all, the inability to implement those decisions once made. I believe that, whatever our politics, we can do business with Mr Sarkozy. And I believe from the experience that I have had with him that it will be possible for Britain and France to develop a new understanding that will be significant not only for international relations and foreign policy but also for the future of Europe itself.
— David Blunkett was Work and Pensions Secretary in 2005, Home Secretary between 2001 and 2004, and Secretary of State for Education and Employment between 1997 and 2001. He is the MP for Sheffield, Brightside.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
France must take action to resurrect its economy. I read in the USA press that violent demonstrations have taken place in France since the election. It is a shame because those demonstrating against his election could be the very ones who profit from it. How can a country reach out to its poor without economic vitality?
Mary, Pittsburgh, Pa/USA
The closure of Sangatte achieved nothing apart from Labour spin, as usual, claiming success. Maybe this country can do business with Sarkozy but endorsement from a sacked Blair minister is hardly the acclaim any politician needs.
Rick, London, England
Mr.Blunkett, like Blair, Brown, Prescott and the rest is starting to think everything he has or has not done has been right for the Country.
Ernest, Southport, England
As an Englishman living in France, I am encouraged by Mr Blunkett's article, despite his many mistakes before. I have seen the change in Britain on my visits, and it has come at a huge cost to individuals lives. Yes it is richer, well, some are, but there is indeed a mess although i don't understand your Tel Aviv commentator's point of view.
There is a very real fear, amongst my adult children's friends, most of whom, are of mixed cultures, and they see no way out. These people apply for jobs for which they are qualified, but when a photo or certain name spelling is seen on the c.v., forget it. These people are disenfranchised, disillusioned French. And it is Sarkozy who tarred them all with the same brush when he had the chance to offer an olive branch. Racism is alive in French schools, and from the teachers ! If Sarkozy can deal with this properly at roots level, France may have a chance. This is a wonderful country in which to live for some, but shop open hours 24/7 is not it.
HUBBLE, Evian-les-Bains, France
I sincerely hope you're right, David, but Sarkozy as president will be an entirely different politician from the one you dealt with. For a start, his policy on Turkey's non-entry into the EU, with which I agree wholeheartedly, is the complete antithesis to current British (and American) policy.
He also wishes to bypass the French electorate with a new EU treaty. Will that not prove to be the last straw - pardon the pun - for Gordon Brown faced with a David Cameron who is likely to go into the next British general election on an EU renegotiation ticket? Finally, will Sarkozy surrender
France's veto on the abandonment of the Common Agricultural Policy in 2013? I believe it is more likely that France will win the Rugby World Cup in October this year than the new president - who will no doubt hand over the cup to the winning team - will change France's stance on the latter. Still, vive la France!
Dr David Green, Athens, Greece
And Mrs Thatcher wasn't a hardline right-winger?
From what strange perspective do you write?
John Chuckman, Toronto, Toronto
Good article Mr Blukett. I hope you are right because UK working well with France and Germany is crucial to our future.
Max, Manchester, UK
Sarkozy might make a great UK Prime Minister when he's finished in France - his policies of (1) making overtime pay tax-free to encourage people to work more. (2) putting in place tougher sentencing for repeat offenders, and (3) toughening the criteria for immigrants trying to bring their families to UK - would be real winners for us.
Bob, Shrewsbury, UK
In French, the expression ``Mieux vaut tard que jamais'' more or less means ``Better late than never.''
Am I to understand that the French in May, 2007, are about to set foot into modern times ?
In French, the expression ``Voir, c'est droire'' more or less means ``Seeing is believing.''
mark nolan, schuylerville ,
Blunkett cites the deal he made with Sarkozy over Sangatte as evidence that Sarkozy is "someone we can work with", as if in the belief that the Sangatte agreement was in some way of benefit to Britain.
In order to seal the Sangatte deal, Blunkett agreed to accept into Britain thousands of illegal immigrants that otherwise might not have succeded in entering Britain at all. Furthermore, since the so called 'agreement' following which Sangatte was supposed to have been permanently closed down, Sangatte 2 has arisen to take it's place and the flow of illegal immigrants through France to Britain has continued unabated. Some deal! The kind of deal that shows we in Britain should be very wary of ever doing business with Sarkozy again!
Larry Nunn, Northampton, UK
Written by a Blairite is all that needs to be said.
Steve Wynn, London,
As if someone in Tel Aviv can have any loyalty to Britain.
rock_on, paris, france
Mr Blunkett is hoping against hope that Mr Sarkozy would not go with the traditional Franco-German alliance which served the two governments well. My bet he will work closely with Ms Merkel as his predecessors did with a German Chancellor.
Also, Mr Blunkett forgets that Blair himself was a creature born out of Mrs Thatcher's policies. Without her policies for example,he would have not been able to keep the unions at a distance, not been able to accept the existence of nuclear weapons ( he was a CND member), not been able to accept the EU ( he was like other labour comrades anti-EU).
With all the above as evidence, I admire Mr Blunkett's spin!!
Gary Reid, LONDON, UK
If indeed, he is anything like David Blunkett, then God help France. Personally, even if he isn't like Blunkett, then I still believe France will rue the day they ever elected him.
Jennifer Hynes, Plymouth, England
Oui, it's time the French joined the global bandwagon in the new millennium. Perhaps, they could begin by swallowing their pride first -- especially in their perception of their 'superior' culture that regards everyone else's as inferior -- and learn a few words of the local languages wherever they may be doing business eg. the French flagship hypermarket, Carrefour, established overseas. Fancy, having to greet their French staff doing their stint in Malaysia, "Bonjour, monsieur, comment 'allez vous?" I have yet to hear them greet the locals here "Selamat pagi, encik, apa khabar?" And if there are those who can appreciate the delicious but quite smelly Roquefort or Swedish Surstromming (admittedly, an acquired taste for many) then I find it inconceivable that others ie. mad dogs, Englishmen and, well, Frenchmen are averse to our equally delicious but quite smelly Belachan (dried shrimp paste, an essential condiment in some of the glorious foods here)!
SD Goh, PJ, MALAYSIA
I thought M. Sarkozy regarded his greatest economic triumph as persuading the EC not to fine France for using state money to bail out Alstom against the rules on state aid.
I seems hard to believe of such a man that "His instincts are those of international capital". What evidence does Mr Blunkett have to back up such a claim?
Ian Kemmish, Biggleswade, UK
Blunkett, get a proper job.
Tony Blair, Houston, TA
Not in a thousand years could I`ve written such a fine article embracing such good observations about N. Sarkozy as the future of a potentially great country as France.
Because I am lucky to have a dual citizenship French & the U.S.,my husband & kids surprised me with a round trip ticket to France as an early Mother`s Day gift so I could vote in the 2 elections., which I did.
There`s only 1 thing I`m scared of, & that is the reaction of the French Street & those who favor the old debilitating cushy polcy of birth to grave so long as they themseves are safe in their positions. And there are millions of them. Add to it those opposing Sarkozy`s stand on free for all immigration.
I wish him well & trust that he will find a way(s) to stand up for France`s future instead of a continuous stagnation, what the French know as "reculade".
rochelle n., lake forest , il.u.s.a
David you must be joking if you think the new french
president is going to help us on immigration every time
an immigrant is though the tunnel or on the ferry its
one less for the french to worry about come on get real
SHUT THE GATES AND LOCK THE DOORS
george william taylor, hull, uk
What mess, Josh? This government has raised Britain from bottom of the G7 to second only to the US in standard of living and employment. We have ridden out two world recessions without a pause in our growth, the longest run of uninterrupted growth we have had in the last 200 years.
The contribution made by immigrants has assisted that growth and is viewed by most economists as favourable.
Blair's mistake was Iraq, he shouldn't have listened to Bush who in turn shouldn't have listened to Israel.
Israel is the root cause of the trouble in the Middle East. Blair's mistake pales beside that of Balfour, his declaration was the biggest mistake that Britain ever made, it led to decades of suffering for the Palestinian people and was the direct cause of the Moslem terrorism we see today.
Israelis should be the last people to criticise another countries economy, you would be bankrupt tomorrow without American subsidies.
John Palmer, Chippenham, Wiltshire
Good article. Who expected Sarko to be a Thatcher?
David Kay, St Legier, Switzerland
David Blunkett is spouting the usual drivel. Unemployed youths (and many employed ones) are every bit as disaffected in the UK as in France. And unemployment is just as high as in the UK as in France. The difference is that the art of concealing unemployment is much more highly developed over here.
Addis, Lancaster, UK
De Gaulle to Sarkozy does suggest change, but is this nominal? The French cant feasibly adopt the British service economy and I dont think either a Dome or supercasinos would do much for French life or prosperity. Sarkozy should surely join with the Germans to assist in the growth and development of Eastern Europe and the Russian states, which is more likely to create jobs and employment than just talking about some mythical new dynamic.
Henry Percy, London, UK
Sorry David. From the way you put it, it sounds as the Labour government actually did something about the immigration crisis. Well it doesn't seem so judging by the mess the UK is in now.
We have huge admiration for you Mr Blunkett, but to compare the get-things-done Sarkozy to spin Blair is wrong.
Josh, Tel Aviv, Israel
As a french I completely agree with you my british friends!
I love this optimistic vision that you have on our new president. And I'm convinced too that he will be able to dialog with you and that we can hope more for the EU.
mymy, Paris, France