Matthew Campbell, Istanbul
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes

THE sculptor Necati Inci has spent his life making statues of General Mustafa Kemal, or Ataturk, father of the Turkish nation. There is hardly a square or a school in the land without one, so effectively has Inci, 67, cornered the market.
He works at a factory in a dusty suburb of Istanbul where he was drawing up plans last week for his most ambitious project: a likeness of Ataturk higher than America’s Statue of Liberty.
“We’ll have a lift going up through the leg,” he enthused, jabbing at the design on his desk. “Inside there’ll be a conference centre, a library. Up here,” he added, pointing to Ataturk’s military hat, “we’ll put a walkway so that people can admire the view.”
Time has done little to dampen the Turks’ enthusiasm for the founder of the republic, whose cult pervades every aspect of life.
Children must learn his utterances by heart. Insulting his memory is punishable with prison; last week he was at the heart of an increasingly bitter political struggle whose outcome in today’s parliamentary elections could shape the vast Muslim country’s future for decades to come.
The hard-drinking, chain-smoking Ataturk famously decreed that Turkey, the bridge between Europe and Asia, should be a secular state in which religion was strictly a private affair.
He abolished the caliphate and forbade the fez. Women were banned from wearing the headscarf in government offices. Today, however, that legacy is perceived to have come under threat. Although the ruling Justice and Development party (AKP), which has its roots in Islam, denies that it plans to transform Turkey into an Islamic state, it is widely disbelieved by opponents who suspect it of a secret agenda and are - odd as it may seem to outsiders - appealing for arbitration to a national hero who died of cirrhosis of the liver seven decades ago.
His sacred legacy, they argue, is being eroded more quickly than Inci’s statues.
“Ataturk would be horrified,” said Nur Serter, a designer-clad professor of economics and “secularist” parliamentary candidate for the opposition Republican People’s party (CHP). She reeled off a long list of Islamist violations of the Ataturk code.
“Women are being advised to check with the imam if it is all right for them to have cosmetic surgery or get a divorce,” she said. “The education ministry is filled with people from religious backgrounds.”
According to Necla Arat, a retired philosophy professor and another female champion of the CHP, young girls are even being left to drown at sea because male lifeguards are forbidden by the Islamic code from handling them in any rescue attempt.
“In some municipalities run by the AKP,” she complained, “we have started to see ‘women only’ parks and ‘women only’ swimming pools.”
Oner Pehlivanoglu, a silver-haired army brigadier, grimly concurred. “I’ve come out of retirement to join this battle,” he said at the headquarters of an organisation committed to “the defence of the ideals of Ataturk” in an affluent Istanbul district.
“We don’t want an Islamic state,” he declared, in an office whose walls were covered in yellowing photographs of the blue-eyed leader from Macedonia. “The military is committed to preventing it.” He added: “By democratic means, of course.”
The Turkish military, the fiercest guardian of “Kemalism” as the cult of Ataturk is known, has used the threat to secularism as the pretext over the decades for many an intervention in politics. The latest came in April, when it stepped in to block the AKP’s choice for president in what some commentators described as a “soft coup” to stop too much power falling into the hands of the Islamists.
Recep Tayyip Erdogan, the prime minister, was forced to call early parliamentary elections but the crisis is far from over. He enjoys a big lead over secular parties such as the CHP which fell from favour years ago over corruption and economic mismanagement and will certainly try again to install as president Abdullah Gul, the foreign minister whose wife wears a headscarf.
Will the army stay in its barracks?
In Turkey, things are never quite what they seem. For all the worries about creeping Islamisation, the AKP has stolen the modernisation mantle from the secularists and despite a few mistakes - Erdogan’s thwarted attempt to criminalise adultery was one - has opened up the economy and made the country more prosperous.
Forget about Turkish delight and carpets. Signs of a sophisticated market economy are visible everywhere from the glitzy shopping arcades to the throbbing city nightspots. The annual growth rate of 7% would be the envy of Europe.
At the same time, efforts to impress Europe into granting Turkey membership of the European Union have resulted in advances for “Islamic feminists”: the practice of reducing sentences for so-called honour killings has been outlawed. So has rape in marriage, and the AKP has ended legal discrimination against nonvirgin and unmarried women.
“Ataturk and secularism are all very well,” said Sinan Yerebakan, 35, an AKP supporter and entrepreneur who runs a camera rental business. “But he is not going to improve our balance of payments. Does it really matter whether women wear veils or not in universities? We need a new idea for a new epoch. Kemalism has run its course.”
Even some secularists acknowledge that Ataturk’s 1923 blueprint for a sophisticated state may be in need of an update at a time when Turkey’s demographics are changing so quickly: last year 2m people moved from the countryside into Turkish cities. This has unsettled the old urban, secularist elite who look down their noses at the unsophisticated newcomers whose women often cover their heads with scarves and whose men tend to wear moustaches. Ilber Ortayli, the historian and director of Istanbul’s Topkapi palace, calls them “peasants”.
Erdogan, a former mayor of Istanbul, emerged from such a suburb. His party’s pledges to ease restrictions on wearing headscarves - secularists fear this could lead to enforced religious observance - have played well to the recently urbanised, socially conservative constituency.
“My wife wears a veil,” said Yerebakan, “and I don’t see why she shouldn’t be able to. She should also be able to swim in a women-only pool if she wants to. In our religion, she should not show her body to any man other than her husband.”
Erdogan is reputed to have said once that democracy was “like a train which you get off when you reach your destination” - an utterance often trotted out by opponents who suspect him of wanting to impose an Islamic state.
Yet Turkey seemed to have little appetite for such an outcome even in the unlikely event that Erdogan did: opposition to the imposition of sharia (Islamic law) rose from 68% in 1999 to 76% in 2006, while support for it fell from 21% to 9%. At the same time the proportion of people who describe themselves first as “citizens of Turkey” as opposed to ethnic Turks or Muslims rose from 30% seven years ago to 34% in 2006.
Many are worried, however, particularly the “Kemalists” who view the preAtaturk Ottoman and Islamic past as an age of ignorant savagery to which they do not want to return. The enlightenment, in their view, occurred when Ataturk brought in the Swiss civil code, Mussolini’s penal code and the Latin alphabet.
Turkan Erkin, an 83-year-old former English literature professor, remembers it clearly.
“I picked up the new alphabet quickly enough,” she recalled last week in the offices of the Ataturk organisation. “It took my parents much longer, though, to change from the Arabic script. I remember as a child translating the subtitles at the cinema for them.”
She also remembered, at the age of four, seeing her father donning a bowler hat - besides western headgear, Ataturk also advocated waltzing - and her mother uncovering her hair for the first time. “After all this time as a modern country, I am very afraid of Turkey going backwards,” she said.
It will not happen without more struggle over the memory of the great statesman. Most towns in Turkey have museums where his belongings are proudly displayed: the son of one of Ataturk’s cronies even claims to have the butt of the great leader’s last cigarette.
For better or worse, times are changing. Inci frets about not finding the £50m he reckons he needs to make his mega-monument: Mehmed, his son, explained that the market for Ataturk sculptures was dwindling.
Hoping to branch out, he has been letting his imagination run riot and last week unveiled a bas relief of Uma Thurman, the actress, wielding a samurai sword in character with her role in the film Kill Bill.
“There’s nothing wrong with Ataturk,” he explained, “but we have to move on if we’re to survive as a company.” The same thing could apply to the country.
Why this is a historic choice
Why are the elections important? The ruling Justice and Development party (AKP), which has its roots in Islam, wants a bigger majority so that it can change the constitution. Opponents say this would allow it to dismantle the blueprint for a modern secularist state established by Kemal Ataturk in 1923.
What’s wrong with reform? Opponents accuse the AKP of having a secret agenda to establish an Islamic state. In April the prime minister nominated an ally as president, which would have meant that the parliament, government and presidency were all controlled by the Islamic party.
The military, which has overthrown four governments in 50 years, intervened. The generals described themselves as the “absolute defenders of secularism” - a clear warning that the army was prepared to stage a coup - and the government backed down.
Will elections solve the crisis? Probably not. Recep Tayyip Erdogan, the prime minister, insists that Abdullah Gul, his foreign minister, will remain a candidate for the presidency. This raises the question of whether the military would act again, risking Turkey’s credentials as a democracy just as it was pressing to join the European Union.
Will the AKP get the majority it wants? It enjoys a big lead over secularist and nationalist parties discredited by corruption and economic mismanagement. A poll last week gave the AKP 43% of the vote, ahead of the Republican People’s party at 17% and the Nationalist Movement party at 12.5%.
What are the other issues? All Turkish parties are critical of US policy in neighbouring Iraq, which they believe is leading towards the creation of an independent Kurdish state that could fan separatism among Turkey’s own large Kurdish population.
Turkey has chilly relations with Baghdad owing to Iraq’s failure to crack down on the outlawed Kurdistan Workers party. The KWP has stepped up attacks on military and civilian targets, sparking calls for a Turkish army incursion into Iraq.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Aminah raises a good point. Perhaps it is time that we removed such nonscence from British universities as well and stop indulging such ludicrous behavior.
Craig Franklin, Kingsbridge, Devon
fractal mentions that people would want to Leave Turkey well let them leave Turkey does not need narrow minded graduates
.
Ignorance is he or she who is againist Islam without studying and learning what Islam promotes (peace).
why are peole so scared of Islam in Turkey it is a peaceful religion.
moreover i am living in England, when i was at college i was allowed to wear my hijab i was even given a room to pray.
university is the same we are given the right to wear our islamic dress code and there are pray rooms. why is this allowed in european countries and its not allowed in Turkey?
we should take good examples from the european countries not just the bad.
Aminah, London,
There is much more to democracy than simply giving people the vote. For a democracy to run well, there need to be many other systems in place: a civil society in which checks and balances lead to justice for everyone, a balanced legal system, a separation between church and state, and so on. An Islamist party may have come to power, but it will always be tempted to reintroduce shari'a law and to diminish the role of non-religious elements within the state. Of course, it would be wrong to prevent people electing whatever party they wish; but the Turks have to take stock of where they are now. If they don't act to prevent any kind of religious legislation or whatever, they will live to regret it, and so will the rest of Europe.
Denis MacEoin, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK
that's only a lie when western people say democracy is everything while at the same time they can't accept that democracy itself that's choosen islamist to govern turkey
Rahmat Hasbullah, Karawang, Indonesia
This election is the solid proof of what may go wrong in democracies, Platon was right then.
and europeans/americans have a saying:
"Ignorance is a bliss."
It's a shame that Islamists become more powerful in Turkey. And a lot of universty studying people says: "I'm gonna leave this country, I don't want to be ruled by Islamists." We hope things will change in 5 years till next election.
Fractal, Istanbul,
Radical Islam nations must be stopped. Though a corrupt government is not that much better, another islam nation will only drive Turkey economically and politically back a century. Stamp out corruption but avoid an islam state. The future in in your hands....
g.williams, London,
AK Party will win. and even though no one from eu does not want us to join eu, we will join. someday turkey will be part of eu. i just don't understand that, people who live in europa don't love turks.
they can't see anything, they don't know anything, and are just speaking. now i am asking if we were not muslim then would you love us?
murat, bandırma/balıkesir, turkey
I am glad AKP won ... I do not want Turkey as part of EU, ever!!
David Brown, london, UK
Neither AK Party nor most of the people claims Islamic state.Any person from the party hasn't said any words like that.
Only thing we want is to live as we believe. In a country like UK or US or any other Eurupian countries we can live free.AK Party wants to form a country like this. So it wants to join EU.
DO WE WANT TOO MUCH?
In a county that has the 90 % muslim population:
wOMEN WHO WEARS HEAD SCARF (BECAUSE OF THEİR BELİEF) CAN'T GO TO UNIVERSITIES AND WORKS STATE OFFICES
In your countries?
y:turker, Sivas, Turkiye
If you live in Turkey, you know that things are never never what they seem. We all know! And we are having fun all the time.
If you live in the Middle-East , you know that things are always what they seem. We all know! And we are suffering all the time.
sevil, mersin, turkey
what makes u think that islam=fascism and radicalism? especially not in Turkey. whay r u so afraid of AKP? if this is what the turkish ppl want- let them be! and if u r so afraid, don't sit down and send feedbacks go to street, demonstrate and help a secularist party winning. yr sobbing makes me think u r just complaining but maybe not too kin to do anything abt it. maybe it is that AKP is not that bad...??
Sarah, Athens, Greece
i don't think ak party is wrong choice, we will right decision that night, some people jeolous of ak party's democracy and devolepment actions that couldn't been done over years.
bahadır, izmit, kocaeli
i haven't heard about that young girls are even being left to drown at sea because male lifeguards are forbidden by the Islamic code from handling them in any rescue attempt. it is not true.
bahadır, izmit, kocaeli
Parties do not have mission teaching the religion and nationalism to citizens. I know my religion and also i know my nation. There is only two alternatives for the democrats: Fascism or a country that is govern by moslem religious law. Prefering one of them to be wanted from the democrats. I am Turkish but i am not fascist and i am sunni but i don't want to live in a country that is govern by moslem religious law. I want neither fascism nor moslem religious law.There is no choice to live humanly so I do not vote today.
AHU COSKUN, Istanbul, Turkey
If the Allah didn't want men to see women's hair, he would have made them bald but he didn't. Wearing the veil is a man made law.
Delphi Oracle, Melbourne,
justice and development party (akp) is the worst thing for Turkey. real and one party.Ataturk's party Republic and Public Party CHP.
turkey-izmir
turkey, izmir,
On one side the west is trying to bring democracy in to the region whereas on the other, the same west is supporting the AKP, which tries to bring sheria law to the republic, becasue of raising levels of foreign investment in Turkey. But they don't relaise that this short term benefit will be more than off set by the threat of a islam-governed Turkey. The extremisim would be spread amongst its 50 million young population. The threat to west would be greater than the one posed by Iran. To sum it up, the west should have a second thought about their backing of AKP.
Samet , London,
The problem is not only the veil and threat of secularism in Turkey. The present government has failed in economy, foreign policy and education. Turkey's external debt has reached the highest level and, corruption and crime has increased sharply last four years. As other modern countries, Turkey needs a government who respect democracy and secularism, follow decent foreign and economic policies, has confidence to reduce corruption and crime in the country.
Kenan Turgut, Antalya, Turkey
I live in Morocco. I think it is vital that Turkey find a compromise between the corruption of the secularists and the implied promise of an Islamic state of the AKP. I would like to see Turkey in the EU acting as a bridge between East and West. I don't see that happening if Turkey falls backward into the trappings and suppression of an Islamic State.
crickett carlisle, rabat, Morocco
hello ı m turk.today turkey very exciting
Åeyma, istanbul, turkey