David Charter, Europe Correspondent
Star musicians and your favourite Times writers at the Albert Hall

It was only the photograph of her granddaughter that kept Snezhana Dimitrova going.
The picture of the little girl were her comfort through eight terrifying years in a Libyan jail, three of them under sentence of death by firing squad.
The 54-year-old nurse had gone to the North African country to pursue her vocation as a childcare specialist.
But after forced confessions arising from alleged torture, including beatings and electric shocks, she was convicted, along with five colleagues, of deliberately infecting 438 Libyan children with the Aids virus.
Yesterday morning on the tarmac at Sofia airport, Mrs Dimitrova tearfully hugged her two children and the seven-year-old granddaughter she thought she would never live to see.
“I waited so long for this moment,” she said as the Bulgarian capital came to a standstill to savour the news.
Within an hour she and her colleagues — four other Bulgarian nurses and an Egyptian-born trainee doctor — had received a presidential pardon.
“I still cannot believe that I am standing on Bulgarian soil,” said Kristiana Valcheva, the nurse accused of being the ringleader of a Mossad plot to undermine Libya.
“We were told the news at 4am and we left the jail at 5.45am to board the plane,” she said. “Now I will try to get my previous life back.”
It will not be easy. All six claim to have been tortured. Mrs Valcheva suffered electric shocks at least ten times, she says, during attempts to wring a signed confession from her. All have missed children growing up and parents growing old.
Nasya Nenova, at 41 the youngest nurse, and said to be the most sensitive of the group, tried to commit suicide by slashing her wrists with a broken bottle to avoid interrogations.
Bulgarians have asked repeatedly why their citizens were singled out for prosecution. There were other foreign nationals working at Benghazi’s al-Fateh paediatric hospital, which employed nurses from as far afield as France and the Philippines. But when the infection of hundreds of children with HIV was discovered in the 1990s, Bulgarians believe that their country was vulnerable to Libya’s search for a scapegoat to cover up poor hygiene and the re-use of needles.
Georgi Milkov, a journalist who has followed the case, said: “Bulgaria at this time had become a big friend of the US. The Libyans wanted to find somebody from abroad to blame because it much easier to explain in such a society that the problem was coming from Mossad or the CIA.”
In all, 19 foreign medics were arrested in 1999 but only five Bulgarian nurses, a Bulgarian doctor married to one of them and the trainee doctor were put on trial along with eight Libyans. During 2000, as the trial dragged on, the first allegations of torture were made by the nurses’ families.
In court, evidence was presented by Luc Montagnier, the French doctor who first isolated the HIV virus in the Benghazi hospital, that the infections had taken place before most of the Bulgarians had arrived. But it cut no ice with the Libyan judges and the five nurses and trainee doctor were found guilty in May 2004.
On the day his wife was sentenced to death, Zdravko Georgiev, the husband of Mrs Valcheva, was convicted of currency smuggling but freed because he had already spent four years in prison, much of it in a cell measuring 9¾ft (3m) by 5½ft with up to eight people at a time.
“I could not lie down to sleep for two years — I could only sit. You cannot imagine it. In the summer it got so hot, people were passing out,” he said yesterday after travelling back to Sofia with the freed nurses.
He said that he had four teeth knocked out by interrogators but added that it was nothing compared with the electric shocks given to the nurses. “They tortured and treated them like animals — in fact, you would not treat animals like that,” he said. Charges of torture were brought against nine policemen and a Libyan doctor in 2005. They were acquitted.
Even though Dr Georgiev was released, he was banned from leaving the country. He has spent the past three years living in the Bulgarian embassy in Tripoli, visiting his wife on Thursdays.
By late 2004 Colonel Gaddafi began to see the medics as an opportunity. The prisoners became a bargaining chip in Libya’s emergence from years of international isolation.
The nurses’ detention in 1999 came months after Libya, under huge international pressure, had handed over Abdul Baset Ali al-Megrahi, the man convicted over the Lockerbie bombing. They were convicted more than a year after his first appeal was rejected.
Libya developed three main demands for the medics’ release: financial compensation, international recognition and another review of the al-Megrahi case.
By last weekend, all three had come together. A compensation package was arranged of $1 million (£485 million) for the families of every HIV-infected child, a review of Libya’s relations with the EU and a review of the Lockerbie conviction, although the British Government denied any link.
As the nurses stepped off the French presidential aircraft they returned to a country that market reforms and privatisations has changed beyond recognition. But the biggest changes are in the shattered families. Snezhana Dimitrova’s father, Ivan Klisurski, suffered a stroke after the confirmation of the death sentence on his daughter in 2006 and was not sure he would live to see her again.
Georgi Parvanov, the Bulgarian President, pledged that Bulgaria would continue to support the Aids-stricken children despite the ordeal. In a moving address to the medics, he said: “I know that you lived through monstrous moments. More than eight years of your lives passed in suffering. But you survived. You are the real winners in this battle for freedom.”
From sedition to statecraft
— Colonel Gaddafi came to power in a 1969 coup, swept away the monarchy, nationalised industry and expelled foreign troops. A later “people’s revolution” solidified his control, accelerating Libya’s economic decline
— He dreamt of a unified Arab state as a counterweight to perceived Western enemies. Attempts to merge Libya with Egypt, Syria and Tunisia in different combinations all failed
— Libyan security forces were linked to the 1988 Lockerbie disaster and an attack on a French airliner in 1989. US air strikes and UN sanctions followed Britain broke off relations after a policewoman was shot dead in London during anti-Gaddafi protests
— In 2003 Libya admitted the Lockerbie bombing. UN sanctions were lifted and UK diplomatic relations restored
— Tony Blair welcomed Gaddafi back to the international fold in 2003, with first visit by a British leader since 1943. Relations with US normalised last year
Sources: Global Security; UK Foreign and Commonwealth Office
Set free
Valia Cherveniashka 52, mother of two daughters, from Biala Slatina, a small town in northwest Bulgaria. Worked in a hospital in the Libyan city of Tarbouha between 1984 and 1997, before moving to the al-Fateh hospital in Benghazi. Her husband, Emil Uzunov, was the first to bring the arrest of the medics to public attention in Bulgaria.
Snezhana Dimitrova 54, worked as a nurse in Sofia and arrested six months after her arrival at the al-Fateh hospital in 1998. A diabetic who suffered a nervous breakdown in 2005 and broke her leg last year. She has a daughter, a son and a seven-year-old granddaughter whom she knew only through photographs.
Nasya Nenova 41, worked at a hospital in the eastern Bulgarian city of Sliven before moving to Libya in 1998. After complaining of torture, she withdrew her confession and tried to commit suicide. Married with a son, who was a schoolboy when she left Bulgaria and is now at university in France.
Valentina Siropoulo 48, worked in the intensive care unit of Pazardjik hospital, Bulgaria, before arriving in Libya in February 1998 to earn more money to send her son to university. She last saw him in 2003 and he now has a master’s degree from Sofia Technical University. Her face has been left partially paralysed, allegedly by torture.
Kristiana Valcheva 48, went to Libya with her husband, Dr Zdravko Georgiev, 58, in 1991. Accused of being the Mossad-inspired organiser of the HIV plot. Husband released on the day she received the death penalty in 2004. He stayed in the Bulgarian Embassy in Tripoli and visited her every Thursday.
Ashraf Alhajouj 38, born in Egypt. Was a trainee doctor at the al-Fateh hospital. It took his family ten months to find the jail where he was being held. His sister and Palestinian father fled Libya in 2005 and were granted refugee status in the Netherlands. He became a Bulgarian citizen last month.
Follow our three athletes' progress in their preparations for the London Triathlon, and pick up training tips and more
Enjoy screenings of all the classic films you love, plus take advantage of two-for-one tickets
We explore leisure activities that are safe and suitable for all of the family
Times Online's new TV show helps you make the right decisions for your pet
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles


Overseas contacts and local business information

A treasure trove of baubles, booty and stylish quests


£129,500
Bentley Edinburgh
£79,850
Mercedes-Benz of Northampton
£26,995
Unit 1, Woodfield Business Unit, Kidderminster Road, Ombersley, Worcester.
Great car insurance deals online
90k + Bonus + Options
Confidential
London
£23,716 +
Highways Agency
National
£
£43,405 - £48,228 pa
Notting Hill Housing
London
£30,000 base, £100,000 OTE
Riches Consulting
London/South
with annexe accommodation and 5.25 acres
£1,100,000
Beautiful Gardens w/ stunning Thames Views
Studios £33K, 1 Beds £60K, 2 beds £79K
Mortgages, bank acc & money transfers to help you buy abroad
Explore mystical Jordan
From £1030 for 7nts 4*
to USA's Most Cosmopolitan City; San Francisco!
£POA
Book Now for Winter 08/09 and Get 10% off!
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Search globrix.com to buy or rent UK property. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Once more the western authorities have given in to the whims of a dictator and a terrorist. Alas! business is business! Where there is oil, there is money. I really beleive that this will be a good example for the terrorists and the extremists, now they will have more confidence again in their endevour to blackmail the western countries.
S. Chandoo, Hannover, Germany
Perhaps Bulgaria had to be punished for throwing off the Muslim yoke years ago. I guess in the mind of Momar and his intelligence goons a couple of hundred HIV infected children are a small price to pay for another Arab conpiracy theory. The Jews are behind the mess in Darfur now, don't you know?
Veritas, CA, USA
Joachim Kappert, I would like to write to you something which would never be allowed to be reproduced here, but, in the absence of that opportunity, i ask, do you have proof?
Marco, Birmingham, uk
I am delighted the innocent Bulgarians nurses and Palestinian doctor are free after eight years of inhumane detention, frequent assaults, rape and countless acts of humiliation. I have to ask, however, what are the lessons the worlds thugs will have learned from Ghaddafi's thugs? Simply that blackmail works, crime pays and the West is weak.
David Allen, Marietta, USA
I am indeed happy for the release of the nurses by Libya. How sad that they had to be released in exchange for a deal on the Lockerbie bombing. And what a horrendous charge! They went to find treatment for the ill and became incarcerated for a false accusation.
I really feel they should not have been accused in the first place let alone be tortured for 8 years.
Hasan, Reading, United Kingdom
Where was England when all of this was happening - oh yes, signing a deal for more oils and intelligence.
I am happy for the families of all the freed parties and feel sorry for the country that still has ancient customs.
Compensate them and let them move on. No doubt there will be a press release and further interviews to follow.
Live long - live strong!
Fernando Rose , Basingstoke,
8 years in prison for 400+ poisonings. They were so lucky!
Joachim Kappert, Vila Nova de Gaia, Portugal
Triumph of humanity over tyrannny!!!
I rejoice with the liberated nurses,the doctor and their families!!!
Attila Stersky, Budapest, Hungary
Typically freeckin English. Not even a word on the role of the French in this business...
Jadawin, Geneva, Switzerland
Obviously Tony Blair thought that these were people we could do business with. And when I say business I mean that black stuff that flows out of holes in the ground.
We can only reform from within "Blah Blah Blah". If Lockerbie had been Bulgaria who would have been bothered. The West has the usual hypocritical stance when dealing with despots and Oil.
David Roberts, Hampton, London
Shame on Blair for normalising relations with a brutal murder who didn't think twice for blowing people up in nightclubs or out of the sky. It stinks of oil for peoples lifes again. We wont forget Lockerbie or the other atrocities committed by Gaddafi. Just compare the treatment of the Lockerbie bomber to the treatment of these poor nurses and doctor. Raped, beaten and forced to confess while someone who killed over 200 people has a nice cosy cell and we pay for his wife to live nearby. Sham on you Blair!
Keith, London, UK
Do you think they'll ever change?
A dictator is a dictator forever...
Bai Vlado, Sofia , Bulgaria
Actually, Nikolai, I wouldn't call getting a million dollars being forgotter! Every family with an infected child is getting that - I don't think that would have come to them from the Libyan government who haven't even accepted the responsibility for the infections they allowed to cause. The evidence at the trial o pre-existing infection was ignored by the Libyans. The bulgarians were purely scapegoats - and hostages. the comment that 8 years is enough is ludicrous: it is 8 years too much, along with torture and denial of human rights. Libya have got away with their scam but thank God the doctor and nurses are now safe although the families of the Lockerbie dead will be the next victims of this charade.
Davinia, Montreal,
Why reward Libya?
The kangooroo courts in Libya convicted Bulgarian nurses and a doctor and then pardoned them for a ransom of 500 million dollars.
It is bad precedent to now to acept them into the fold of nations as if nothing had happened and normalize relations with European Union as declared.
Libya shoud be banished not rewarded for their criminal behaviour.
Pay them, because you promised but nothing else.
Moshe haviv, Tel Aviv, Israel
Hey, hey. Did PM Tony Blair ignore these hostages when he decided to pump the hands of the hostage taker, El Ghaddafi? The statements made about him being an honest citizen depends on what he buys from Britain with his oil money, right?
Now that is something for Brits to reflect upon. Is money and commerce worth trading your soul for?
From the French point of veiw, they are making giant strides towards being spotlessly clean. Sarkosy said that he would visit old Maumar only after the hostages were released.
Vous avez compris?
Peter Casie Chetty, Liverpool, England
Libya a rich country gained money for these children, they have more than enough to pay anyone. Muslims unfortunately see these payments as admission of guilt!!! They do not seek the truth and blame, blame and just more blame. What is it in the Muslim mind to blames everyone but the obvious? These is nothing more evil in the world today than a belief that in more interested in pride and saving face than seeking the truth.
Tim, Liverpool,
So basically the EU has paid, what was it, £225m?, for 8 years accommodation for six in some kind of torture camp?! I, personally, find this inexplicable and think we should send in the SAS to capture all the Libyan politicians and policemen directly involved, render them to a 'black' jail in the EU and give them 8 years of their own medicine before executing them.
Marco, Birmingham, uk
What has happened to the eight Libyans arrested with the Bulgarians? You mention their arrest in your article above but you do not offer any information on their situation now. Lets hope that the same influence can be brought to bear to obtain their freedom or have they already been executed?
Michael Julien, Weybridge, UK
I'am so happy to know that they are free,at home ...I'am happy for them....thay were just the part of the big political game ,but who will bi the winner of this game ?
Angel Vasilev Spasov, Albufeira , Portugal
Good comments! But it is strange that nobody remembers 400 infected children from which 56 died. OK, 8 years seems to be enough but the medics are not saints in fact.
Nikolay, Novosibirsk, Russia
Hooray! I'm so pleased their free at last.
Tina, Duesseldorf, Germany
Libya holds hostage people from Bulgaria and a chap from Australia decides to have a dig at the US & UK?????
Andy, Birmingham, England
Retain the fund for the HIV children, but administered from Malta (an EU nation that retains relations with Libya). Everything else should be cancelled on the basis that it was obtained by duress. Then stregthen the emabrgo on Libya, not relax it. This embargo would cover all economic, financial, technical and personnel assistance. If that nations social, cultural and legal sytems wish to remain in the middle ages, then we should respect that and stay away.
jonathan Mills, Plovdiv, Bulgaria
Hooray! I'm so pleased they're free at last.
Tina, Duesseldorf, Germany
How can the world stand by and let people suffer like this?
Human nature sure needs to be brought to a much higher standard at the rate things go unchallenged there will be no present company going to Paradise!
God bless all the wronged people,Known and un known
We all need to make the best effort in all our daily duties and not be selfish in helping others less fortunate than ourselves.
garry, bunbury, west australia
Great, they kidnap and torture people for 8 years, then achieve fabulous rewards and admiration for letting them go. How nice to be a country rather than an individual.
Tramp Linda, Shenzhen, China
The next batch of foreign citizens that Gaddafi kidnaps and holds to ransom will be from the US or the UK. And why wouldn't he? Neither the US or the UK exerted any pressure this time, to force Gaddafi to release his medical hostages. As ye sow, so shall ye reap.
Paul Francis, Brisbane, Australia