Tony Allen Mills, New York
Win Sky+HD for a year and a trip to Barcelona
The world’s great shipbuilders are poring over designs for ice-breaking supertankers. Canada is spending billions on gunboats. Last week Russia planted its flag on the seabed beneath the North Pole.
The next cold war has already started and this one will be frozen. The battle for the mineral treasures of the Arctic will not only last for decades, it will be fought in temperatures below -40C, amid bone-chilling blizzards and unrelieved winter darkness.
The submarine stunt by Russian explorers intent on staking Moscow’s Arctic claim has provided a jolt of urgency to international efforts to protect and administer what one American admiral described as “the last great unexplored bastion on earth”.
The political powers of the northern hemisphere are suddenly facing tense negotiations over who gets what in an oil and gas-rich polar territory twice the size of France. Two miles under the Pole, Artur Chilingarov, a Russian explorer and politician, dropped a rustproof titanium flag from the hold of a mini-submarine to prove that while Moscow lost the space race, it is determined to win the ice race.
At stake in this outbreak of polar posturing is not just patriotic pride, but access to what geologists believe are a quarter of the globe’s oil and gas reserves - in short, the solution to the crippling energy shortages that will begin throttling western economies within the next two decades.
A potent combination of global warming - causing the Arctic ice-cap to melt - and developing extraction technologies is unlocking the door to hydrocarbon deposits that had long seemed inaccessible. Scientists believe climate change may open up a key Arctic shipping route - the fabled Northwest passage linking the Pacific and Atlantic oceans - to routine maritime traffic by 2050.
“Experts say after 2016, oil production will drop tremendously,” said Anatoly Opekunov, deputy director of Russia’s Research Institute for Ocean Geology and Mineral Resources. “Every country, including Russia and the US, is thinking about this.”
In Washington last month, a group of US civilian and military agencies held a three-day meeting to discuss the economic, ecologi-cal and political consequences of increasing Arctic exploration.
“This is an ocean explorers have sought routes through for 500 years,” said Mead Treadwell, head of the US Arctic Research Commission. “If there is to be an international regime in the Arctic, it’s time to think about that.”
Oil companies are already pondering the technical challenges of industrialising one of the world’s great wildernesses. Recent geological studies indicate that up to 80% of the energy reserves may be natural gas.
“The cost of getting the gas out of the ground is high, but the cost of getting it to anywhere useful is even higher,” said Andrew Kendrick of BMT Fleet Technology, a firm that specialises in Arctic exploration.
A recent article in Professional Engineering magazine noted that Arctic pipelines were “out of the question” because they would be prohibitively expensive to lay. “The only viable way of transporting is going to be over the sea, using gigantic tankers full of liquefied natural gas,” the magazine said.
The prospect of giant ice-breaking tankers carrying highly explosive gas and roaming the iceberg-filled Arctic at speed is unlikely to reassure environmentalists opposed to any exploitation of pristine polar territory.
Yet President Vladimir Putin’s commitment to establishing Russia’s Arctic primacy - he personally telephoned Chilingarov and his crew to congratulate them last week - leaves other countries little option but to join the race or be left in the cold.
Russia already controls the world’s largest reserves of natural gas and is second only to Saudi Arabia in oil production. Both European and American officials are concerned that the West may be forced into politically damaging dependence on Russian energy production if Moscow’s claim to 463,000 square miles of Arctic is not challenged.
International lawyers agree that Russia’s claims have no more legal basis than Canada’s claim to the Northwest passage, which is regarded by most other countries as international waters.
Stephen Harper, the Canadian prime minister, last month announced plans to spend £3.4 billion on at least six ice-breaking patrol ships to maintain Canada’s claim to the passage. Last week Peter MacKay, Harper’s foreign minister, denounced the Russian stunt. “This isn’t the 15th century,” he said. “You can’t go around the world and just plant flags and say, ‘we’re claiming this territory’.”
Yet Eric Posner, professor of law at the University of Chicago, concluded that the small print of international maritime agreements was likely to prove irrelevant in the Arctic. “Power, not international law, will settle the issue,” he said. “Russia’s expression of power is credible; Canada’s is not.”
At stake are an estimated 500 billion barrels of oil, incalculable volumes of natural gas and potential deposits of diamonds, platinum, nickel, tin and gold.
US scientists have long been aware of the Arctic’s mineral potential, but fierce opposition in Washington to drilling in Alaskan wildlife refuges has hampered exploitation. The Americans have also been slow to grasp the implications of climate change and several officials complained last week that Putin had seized the strategic initiative.
A recent report by the US Centre for Naval Analyses described global warming as a “serious threat” to US security that should become a military priority.
Additional reporting: Felix von Geyer, Montreal, and Kevin O’Flynn, Moscow
WORLD WATCH
Who owns the North Pole? No one does. But five countries have territory inside the Arctic Circle: Russia, America (through Alaska), Canada, Denmark and Norway control economic rights within 200 miles of their borders. The question under international law is whether there might be geographical, geological or political reasons why one country’s rights should be extended.
So what’s the basis of Russia’s claim? Whatever you think of President Vladimir Putin, he has played a cool Arctic hand. Moscow is attempting to prove that an underwater Arctic formation known as the Lomonosov Ridge is actually a continuation of a Siberian peninsula. Last week’s submarine expedition was searching for geological samples that would extend Russia’s claim to vast swathes of oil and gas-rich territory.
Why doesn’t America step in? Washington has made a polar bear’s
breakfast of its own Arctic claims. The Americans are unhappy with both
Russia and Canada, which has claimed rights over the Northwest Passage, the
mostly icebound but fast-melting link between the Atlantic and Pacific. Yet
conservative Republican distaste for any United Nations agreements has
prevented the US from ratifying the Law of the Sea Treaty, the most logical
international forum for settling Arctic disputes.
Talking of polar bears, what does all this mean for them? The main
threat is still global warming, which is shearing off sections of the ice
cap at a rate of about 9% each decade. Compared with the threat of shrinking
habitat, a few dozen drilling platforms shouldn’t affect the local wildlife
too much. But any oil spills would spell trouble for the animals. And if a
gas-filled supertanker runs into an iceberg, you might feel the explosion in
Chelsea.
Is it worth the superpower angst? Look at it this way. Oil is currently around $70 a barrel. There may be 500 billion barrels of oil hidden under the Arctic. So is it worth another cold war? That’s a $35,000 billion question.
When do I need to start worrying? Arctic exploration can’t happen in a hurry. The environment is too hostile, the economics too daunting and the pace of development too slow for serious exploitation before, say, 2050.
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
In our new series, Tony Hawks takes a dry, wry look at modern life - junk mail, interminable meetings and snooty sales assistants
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
2007
£30,000
2006
£14,337
2008
£39,937
Great car insurance deals online
c.£75,000
GlosFirstmeansbusiness
Gloucestershire
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
£
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
Competitive Package
Npower
West Midlands
1 & 2 Bed apartments
From £249,995
Great Investment, River Views
Great Dubai Investment Opportunities
from £89,950
low-cost ownership homes in London
Las Vegas SALE!
£POA
With Ramblers Worldwide Holidays!
£POA
List your property with two leading travel websites
£POA
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - find property for sale and rent in the UK. Milkround Job Search - for graduate careers in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
I agree with you Distell, it's just like Quebec in Canada...
Amstell, EU,
Is the Russian position "Why fight a land war in Asia when you could fight an oceanic war at the north pole"? I am certainly no expert in what countries have claims to the region, or whose claim is the best. However, the illogical conclusion that the power behind a nation automatically makes its claim correct is ridiculous. Might does not make right.
Why are these governments acting like it's colonial expansion time all over again -- planting flags like they're on the moon.
I can't even begin to understand the frustration so-called "Eastern" countries feel at the west. However, I hope they know that if they stand up and take a global leadership role, there are those of us in the "West" who would applaud them.
We need some new thinking at a global level. The future isn't going to be about these kind of resource grabs; this isn't a video game.
The future has to be about scalable solutions and co-operation. It has to be, because the alternative is too horrible to imagine.
Alex Mitchell, Kars, Ontario, Canada
Russia does not care about the animals,the people or anything else.Just look at there nuck plants safety records.Just sit back and watch the damage they may do.Why should they,it's Canada's problem any oil spill will affect them.
W.Golightly, warwick, usa
'politically damaging dependence on Russian energy production'.
Funny that dependence on a Christian, democratic (whatever you pretend) and European country frightens you no end, while dependence on Saudi Arabia (Muslim, unstable and medieval) is welcome. Something is fishy here. Something tells me that you just don't want Russia to exist at all, irrespective of its political structure.
Pavel, Rostov, Russia
A 4.3-km dive to the bottom of the Arctic Ocean is hardly a "stunt". Russians just showed that they are serious about their territorial claims and that they money, resources, and science to back up their position. And if scientific evidence does not make the expected impact, then Russia will have to deploy other class of submarines.
Veniamin Nikolayev, Philadelphia, US
In 1934, Edgar Cayce was asked what areas of our world would be "hot spots" in the buildup to World War III. He named a long list of places, including the Persian Gulf, which would surprise no one. But included in his list was the Davis Straits. This area between Canada and Greenland would be a critical part of the Northwest Passage.
Maybe it would be good to reconsider other things that Cayce predicted in 1934: He said that China would be opposing the Western group of nations, but he was emphatic that Russia would not be partnered with China.
He said that Russian would become the lynchpin in our world because of its location, between the East and the West, and that the Russians would ultimately carry the torch for humanity, not on the basis of material power, though that would seem a given, but because of their spiritual strength.
Meg Thompson, Raleigh, North Carolina
Well, let's see, EVERYTHING that Russia does for its own interests (JUST like every other nation, INCLUDING the US and Canada) is scrutinized under a microscope. Noone has the guts to say anything to the lord of the world, North America, but when Russia does one thing or another that are part of ITS INTERNAL AFFAIRS, such as Chechnya and polar exploration, the Westerners get nervous or nosy. Stay out of this, it's our business if we want more to explore OUR natrual resources, on OUR Lomonosov Ridge
Feliks, Lancaster, CA, USA (Formerly Odessa, USSR)
This belongs to Russia there is very little anyone can say or do short of starting a war, to dispute it. Americans and Canadians can fret and complain all they want, The Russians had the initiative, the will and the know how to do this when no other country would or could.
Congratulations President Putin for a job well done.
Andy, Raleigh, NC
Why is the west wetting its pants before the claims are estabilished. And once its done, they can always come in as investors/Techical advisers, like everywhere else. Did anyone say anything when the gold of Africa and the Oil of South America/Aboriginal Australia was appropiated by the Colonialists!
vencor, Delhi, Mumbai, pune, kolkata, ,
Best thing for the Russians to do at this time with a war going on in Chechnya.
Their own overconfidence in themselves will be their ultimate weakness and in time their permenant defeat.
Right now there are many regions in the Russian Federation seeking a right time to break away from Moscow's control and that time is not far...
Distell, Toronto,
Even so , Come Lord Jesus , Amen and Amen !!!!
Warren Dunley, Alice Springs, Australia \ NT