Insight: Chris Gourlay and Jonathan Calvert
Enter our Snapshots of Summer photography competition
IN a small windowless cell lit by a single light bulb, Louai al-Sakka sits isolated from the world and fellow inmates for 24 hours a day.
His concrete box is in the bowels of Kandira, a high-security F-type prison 60 miles east of Istanbul, which was built to house Turkey’s most dangerous criminals.
The prison has been criticised by human rights groups such as Amnesty International. The guards control everything, including the cell’s light switch.
Sakka’s only visitor is Osman Karahan, a lawyer who shares his fervent support for militant Islamic jihad.
Since being convicted as an Al-Qaeda bomb plotter last year, Sakka has decided to reveal his alleged role in some of the key plots of recent years, providing a potential insight into the unanswered questions surrounding them. His story is also one of a globetrotting terrorist in an organisation that is truly multinational.
He is an enigma and, despite his involvement in three terrorist outrages involving British citizens, he is virtually unknown in this country.
By his own account he is a senior Al-Qaeda operative who was at the forefront of the insurgency in Iraq, took part in the beheading of Briton Kenneth Bigley and helped train the 9/11 bombers. He has been jailed in connection with the bombing of the British consulate in Istanbul.
Certainly, the intelligence services have shown a keen interest in the 34-year-old Syrian who says he was in Iraq alongside Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, the notorious insurgent who was killed last year in a United States air-strike.
But, as with many things in the world of Al-Qaeda, there might be smoke and mirrors. Some experts believe that Sakka could be overstating his importance to the group, possibly to lay a false track for western agencies investigating his terrorist colleagues.
Over the past three weeks The Sunday Times has conducted a series of interviews with Sakka through his lawyer. We were given a number of documents including a memoir in Arabic of his life.
So who is the mysterious Al-Qaeda operative in the concrete cell and what do his claims tell us about the terrorist network and his role within it?
He was travelling under the Turkish name Erkan Ozer – one of his 16 false identities – when he was arrested in the southeastern town of Diyarbakir in August 2005. His downfall was as a result of a nighttime explosion that caused a fire in his apartment a week earlier. When fire-fighters reached the blaze they found a do-it-yourself bomb factory with vats of hydrogen, bags of aluminium powder and 6kg of plastic explosives.
Sakka had been planning to sink Israeli cruise ships off the Turkish coast using motorised dinghies. Despite having plastic surgery to disguise his face, he was easily identified by the Turkish authorities.
Police later discovered documents linking him to the Istanbul suicide bombings that killed at least 27 people after trucks exploded outside the British consulate, the HSBC bank and two synagogues. The court indictment described him as “a senior member of the Al-Qaeda terrorist organisation tasked with special high-level missions”. It said he had met Osama Bin Laden, who had told him to organise attacks in Turkey.
But was this all? Last week his lawyer claimed his scope was much wider. “He was the nnumber one networker for Al-Qaeda in Europe, Iran, Turkey and Syria,” Karahan said.
According to the documents provided by Karahan, Sakka grew up in the ancient city of Aleppo, Syria, the son of a wealthy factory owner, and followed in his father’s footsteps by becoming the general manager of a company that sold one of Syria’s most popular washing-up liquids. But he was drawn to the Islamic cause from a young age, according to his memoir.
His politics were shaped by the conflict between President Hafez al-Assad, the former Syrian dictator, and the Muslim Brotherhood, an underground Islamic group. When Sakka was nine, Assad quelled an uprising by the brotherhood in the town of Hama by killing an estimated 10,000 people.
“Like any other Muslim boy he was deeply affected by these events,” says his memoir.
When the Bosnian war opened a new front for jihadists in the early 1990s, Sakka left his job and headed for the conflict. He stayed in Turkey initially and established the “mujaheddin service office”, which provided medical support for Bosnia and later the two Chechen wars.
It soon became clear that more than medical help was needed. Sakka set up intensive physical training programmes in the Yalova mountain resort area, near Istanbul, to prepare the scores of young men heading for the conflicts. The memoir claims the volunteers came from Europe, Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, the Gulf, North Africa and South America.
The Chechens needed trained fighters. Sakka was telephoned by Ibn al-Khattab, the late militia leader controlling the foreign fighters against the Russians. Khattab requested that Sakka’s trainees should be sent on to Afghanistan for military training because “conditions are tough”.
This brought Sakka into contact with Abu Zubaydah, a high-ranking Al-Qaeda member, who ran a large terrorist training camp near the border between Afghanistan and Pakistan. Sakka was later to be sentenced in ab-sentia for involvement in the foiled Jordanian millennium bomb attacks in 2000 along with Zubaydah.
One of Sakka’s chief roles was to organise passports and visas for the volunteers to make their way to Afghanistan through Pakistan. His ability to keep providing high-quality forged papers made Turkey a main hub for Al-Qaeda movements, his lawyer says. The young men came to Turkey pretending to be on holiday and Sakka’s false papers allowed them to “disappear” overseas.
Turkish intelligence were aware of unusual militant Islamic activity in the Yalova mountains, where Sakka had set up his camps. But they posed no threat to Turkey at the time.
But a bigger plot was developing. In late 1999, Karahan says,a group of four young Saudi students went to Turkey to prepare for fighting in Chechnya. “They wanted to be good Muslims and join the jihad during their holidays,” he said.
They had begun a path that was to end with the September 11 attacks on America in 2001. They were: Ahmed and Hamza al-Ghamdi who hijacked the plane that crashed into the south tower of the World Trade Center; their companion Saeed al-Ghamdi whose plane crashed in a Pennsylvanian field; and Nawaf al-Hazmi who died in the Pentagon crash.
They undertook Sakka’s physical training programme in the mountains and later were joined by two of the other would-be hijackers: Majed Moqed, who also perished in the Pentagon crash, and Satam al-Suqami, who was in the first plane that hit the north tower.
Moqed and Suqami had been hand-picked by Al-Qaeda leaders in Saudi Arabia specifically for the twin towers operation, Sakka says, and were en route to Afghanistan. Sakka persuaded the other four to go to Afghanistan after plans to travel to Chechnya were aborted because of problems crossing the border. “Sakka [told Zubaydah] he liked the four men and recommended them,” said Karahan.
Before leaving, all six received intensive training together, forming a cell led by Suqami, which was similar to the Hamburg group run by Mohammed Atta, another ringleader in the 9/11 attacks.
At one point, Sakka claims the entire group were arrested by police in Yalova after their presence raised suspicions. They were interrogated for a day but eventually released because there was no evidence of wrongdoing.
Some of Sakka’s account is corroborated by the US government’s 9/11 Commission. It
found evidence that four of the hijackers – whom Sakka says he trained – had initially intended to go to Chechnya from Turkey but the border into Georgia was closed. Sakka had prepared fake visas for the group’s travel to Pakistan and arranged their flights from Istanbul’s Ataturk airport. The group of four went to the al-Farouq camp near Kandahar and the other two to Khaldan, near Kabul, an elite camp for Al-Qaeda fighters.
When Moqed and Suqami returned to Turkey, Sakka employed his skills as a forger to scrub out the Pakistani visa stamps from their passports. This would help the Arab men enter the United States without attracting suspicion that they had been to a training camp.
Sakka’s lawyer said: “Just like there is money laundering, there is also terrorist laundering and Turkey was the centre of this.”
According to Sakka, Nawaf al-Hazmi was a veteran operative who went on to pilot the plane that hit the Pentagon. Although this is at odds with the official account, which says the plane was flown by another hijacker, it is plausible and might answer one of the mysteries of 9/11.
The Pentagon plane performed a complex spiral dive into its target. Yet the pilot attributed with flying the plane “could not fly at all” according to his flight instructors in America. Hazmi, on the other hand, had mixed reviews from his instructors but they did remark on how “adept” he was on his first flight.
Paul Thompson, author and 9/11 researcher, said Sakka’s account was credible. “I think there is a lot more about the history of the hijackers that needs to be found out and Sakka’s claim may resume the debate about just how much was known about them before 9/11,” he said.
Sakka’s mountain trainees, meanwhile, had spread out to a number of countries where they carried out terrorist attacks. He claims this is why he was charged with a string of crimes committed by his associates. He was given a 15-year sentence in Jordan for the millennium bomb attacks, the death penalty for an an assassination attempt on Syria’s military intelligence chief and has been charged in Saudi Arabia for an explosives plot.
In effect, he had become a free-lance operative aiding a series of groups without necessarily agreeing with their targets. His links with Al-Qaeda, however, remained strong after the 9/11 attacks.
His lawyer says the Al-Qaeda leadership valued a number of his skills. “But most important,” he added, “was that Sakka was incredibly secretive. Al-Qaeda tested him many times, but he never once revealed a secret.”
The US invasion of Afghani-stan in late 2001 threw many of the Al-Qaeda camps into disarray. Many of the group’s fighters are thought to have fled across the border to seek safety in Iran.
According to Sakka’s account, one of those fighters was Zar-qawi. The precise movements of the Jordanian, who is thought to have been wounded fighting alongside the Taliban in Afghani-stan, have always been a matter of speculation.
Sakka’s initial role in the insurgency was to help foreign fighters enter Iraq. He took his family to live in Falluja, which was emerging as the hub of the foreign fighters’ resistance to the occupying forces.
He later told a court: “We held out for 70 days. They destroyed vast quarters of the city. It wouldn’t have been possible for them to enter before doing so. We ran out of ammunition and had to pull out.”
A month before the fall of Falluja, Sakka claims that he was part of the group that killed Kenneth Bigley, the British hostage. He describes himself as the “diplomat” who negotiated on behalf of the insurgents and says he presided over the court that resolved to execute him. He says Bigley’s body is buried in Falluja with his passport and confession video.
Today Sakka remains a controversial figure. The British Foreign Office says it has interviewed Sakka in jail about the Bigley murder. He provided a map of where Bigley was buried but the Foreign Office says they could not find the body. In Turkey, police sources claim Sakka may have become clinically insane or perhaps be an egoma-niac who has overstated his role.
The Sunday Times has spoken to a number of Al-Qaeda experts who say that many elements of his story ring true, but they are impossible to verify conclusively. Evan Kohlmann, an investigator for the 9/11 Finding Answers Foundation, said: “When [Sakka] was in Falluja there were several high-ranking Turkish guys there. It is also true that for a number of conflicts that Al-Qaeda has been involved in, Turkey is a very important through stop and a lot of fighters have travelled through there with the assistance of local people.”
Swift justice
Gordon Brown’s plans to double the detention period for terror suspects face further opposition with a report showing that America needs just 48 hours to file charges in Al-Qaeda cases.
The report by Justice, the human rights group, will say this week that Brown’s plans to extend precharge detention to 56 days are untenable.
It says: “No western democracy faces a greater threat of terrorism than the US. Despite this, the proven ability of US law enforcement to charge suspects in complex terror plots within 48 hours of arrest without resort to exceptional measures shows that UK proposals to extend precharge detention are both unjustified and unnecessary.”
The report emphasises the importance of FBI phone tap evidence and Brown is considering whether such intercept evidence should be allowed in Britain.
Eric Metcalfe, the Justice report’s author, said: “From Guantanamo Bay to rendition to torture, the US has done a lot of things badly wrong in the fight against terrorism.
“But in the rush to extend precharge detention here in the UK, we sometimes overlook what they are doing right.”
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the collective power of smart thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Flip MinoHD Camcorder
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
42,945
2008
71,450
Car Insurance
Not Specified
MI6
UK-based
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Save up to £1,000 per couple with Elite Vacations at the five-star Constance Lemuria Resort
and do the British Isles this Summer.
Save up to 60% with Oxford Hotels and Inns
Try our inspiring luxury holidays to the Indian Subcontinent and South East Asia.
Great offers available
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Why does not Prime Minister Brown arrange for the man's release from jail so that he can live in London? Is not that the humanitarian thing to do?
greg starr, Oslo, Norway
You omitted to mention that this guy's a CIA asset. Most remiss of you.
Andrew Milner, Yokohama, Japan
Personally, I stopped reading at "vats of hydrogen".
Roger, London,
Says Chuckman...
"...This ridiculous. The man likely isn't even who the US thinks he is."...
Brilliant stuff, as usual, J.C.
Evidently, you know more about this business than Kassan, his lawyer, and all the authorities involved!
Keep up the un-biased, fact-based, good work.
Mal, Toronto, Canada
In March 2001, Mohamed Atta applies together with a Pakistani Air Force pilot for a security job with Lufthansa Airlines (see February 15, 2001). This pilot is a member of the same Islamic study group as Mansour, but itâs not clear if this is Mansour and he did come back to or stay in Germany, or if Atta was associating with a second Pakistani Air Force pilot. [Roth, 2001, pp. 9f; Newsday, 1/24/2002] The FBI later notes that Alshehhi arrived âalmost as a replacementâ for Mansour. After 9/11, the FBI asks Pakistan if the flight lieutenant and squad leader Mansour can be found and questioned about any possible role he may have had in the 9/11 plot, but thereâs no indication Pakistan as to whether has ever agreed to this request. [Rediff, 7/17/2002] In late 2002, the German Federal Bureau of Criminal Investigations will say that Mansour remains âa very interesting figure.â [Los Angeles Times, 9/1/2002]
Ronnie, PARIS, FRANCE
Such claims of childish bravado by wanna-be Jihaadees or juvenile delinquents should not precipitate such over the top sensationalism and paranoid reporting by our media. Is it not bad enough, Indeed quite embarrassing, that after flushing trillions of dollars and thousands of US lives and countless Muslim lives, irreparably sullying American reputation and standing with all the exposure on US torture and murder of civilians in Iraq and Afghanistan and outright theft of funds and Iraqi oil by US contractors, earmarked for expenditure on Iraqi civil services, we are still left groping in the dark and making wild knee-jerk assumptions about the identity of the enemy and what prompts all his madness? As long as we continue to depend on Hollywood and Fox News to think for us, let our fear, ignorance, hypocrisy, holier-than-thou elitist Judeo-Christian beliefs colour our attitudes and policies towards Muslim and other non-white countries - we shall all plod on blindly and suffer.
David Stern, New York, NY, USA
This article is a classic example of Disinformation designed
to keep the Masses in the "Cloud of 911" Lies.It implies they
DID train of TINY Prop planes...to fly Giant Airliners is 7 easy lessons! RIDICULUS.!! Also,can the Mythical "Al Qaeda"
Kingpin...please explain WHY at least 5 of the so-called Hijackers are ALIVE!.........I didnt think so.......
After 6 years of 911 research,I Highly doubt there were ANY people even on those planes. And what about the early eye-witness who stated he saw NO WINDOWS on the planes!
Do your Research people........and Read between the lines.
Darryl, Cleveland,
All this talk about the non-existant war on terror reminds me of the saying> firs they came for the Jews, then they came for the catholics and so on until the only one left was the one who kept trying to appease those coming and in the end he too was grabbed. History will show one day the war started way before 9/11 and all the nations that could have stood together and stopped it, did nothing, including our illustrious Bill Clinton. For that we will now pay dearly and unless the free nations of this world step up to the plate and tackle the issue and admit the world is at war, it will be a long battle. For those not citizens of the US, I am glad you like your country so much, as a matter of fact, why not convince your governments to make it illegal for anyone from there to immigrate to the US.
denis, any city, US
For angry unemployed Muslim youth disenfranchised with their own governments and society, eager to do something about the daily carnage of innocent Muslim men, women and children, a fact to which the seemingly civilised world's institutions of justice and social equity such as the UN, EU and NATO appear callously indifferent and powerful superpowers directly and savagely complicit, any statements, no matter how absurd and impossible, through a known media outlet, to express and vent their rage is a fair game plan, especially for those incarcerated as they have noting to loose. I would take any such grandiose fairy tales with a grain of salt as these statements and claims are only designed to give media piranhas the bait for the feeding frenzy they so predictably fall in to, giving their stories a veneer of credibility.
M. Povich, New York, NY, US/NY
Typical Times gibberish.... As if having a Pakistani visa stamp in your passport implies that you have been to a terrorist training camp.
Can anyone explain how mug-shots of ALL hijackers were plastered across every newspaper and news channel within a day of the atrocity ? Surely sometime was needed to identify the people involved and presumably they were not flying under an alias. So who had knowledge of them and why were they not stopped ?
A. Khan, London,
This ridiculous.
The man likely isn't even who the US thinks he is.
American intelligence has made countless blunders in its war on terror arresting and torturing the wrong people.
Anyway, he will have been generously tortured in Turkey.
God knows, the cowards Blair and Bush would say anything after a few minutes on the rack.
Anyway, the man knows he's doomed. Might as well claim some credit facing death.
JOHN CHUCKMAN, TORONTO, Canada
I knew they'd find a way to stop Turkey from joining the E.U.
911 was not an inside job, but their (U.S) government let it happen. It could have been easily stopped. And nope, this is not an arab conspiracy...American intellectuals and scientists have published the facts to back up their claims, it's all over the net...just google it.
Mohammed, London, UK
The al Qaeda leadership valued his ability 'to keep a secret'? Yet, here he is babbling like a brook in his lovely Turkish prison...Which 9-11 hijackers besides Hamzi did he allegedly train? There is more evidence that the patsies were trained at US facilities--including the AFB in Montgomery, Alabama and the Defense Language Institute in Monterey, as noted by the dean of students, a light colonel who was silenced. A baker's dozen of intel agencies had advance warning and passed the info regarding a prospective attack on the US prior to 9-11. al Qaeda was obviously a sieve when it came to information security...
If the ability of Georgia to close its borders kept these 'terrorists' out and utterly dashed their hopes of martyrdom in Chechnya, Perhaps, the US could learn something from Georgia in fighting terrorism and apply it along its undefended southern border in this faux-war on terrorism...
Prinzowhales, North Carolina, US
The lawyer of this terrorist lunatic should be thrown in to the same jail and let them rot in there until the end of theyr miserable life
nostradamus, swindon, england
The Register describes Kohlman (cited in the article) like this:
"the role of globetrotting professional witness Evan Kohlmann. Defenders in the US and UK have come to recognize him as a figure brought in to furnish opinions which are only of use to prosecutions in the frightening of juries. .. For the past couple of years, Kohlmann has been reasonably ubiquitous in US news reports on terrorism... after the alleged London ricin gang was found not to be an al-Qaeda gang by jury, Kohlmann told Newsweek magazine, "These are dangerous people who are followers of [Hook] Hamza." Donald Findlay QC, defending for Siddique, said at trial: "Instead of being brought from the US to be put in the witness box, [Kohlmann] should have been put in the dock." This was in apparent reference to Kohlmann's website" which contained the same materials as Siidique was convicted for possessing. If Kohlman comments, the guy in Turkey is just a stooge.
RW, London, UK