Her bizarre story is the proof that she is heavily involved. A person who has nothing to hide gives a logical clear account of events, without serious ^¨I don,t remember¨^ holes, just three days after the events.
She tried to frame Lumumba and Sollecito because they probably have nothing on her. I think she knows that if she tries to frame Guede who has admitted being there, He will berry her with him, because he probably has a lot on her.
It is indeed strange that Sollecito and Amanda don,t remember what they did that day in town till 9pm., and are vague on each others alibi. It looks like this story could be far more horrible than we think and be premeditated by AMANDA and Sollecito and maybe involving Guede to let him take the fall. The police is going for pre meditated murder.

sten, almere , holl.

The witness had already informed the Police within days of the murder. The fact was known already by the Police

Rob, London, uk

Agreed that Amanda's story is bizarre. But what proof do we have that she participated in the killng? A man with a knife doesn't need any help.

In any case she would have faced serious jail time if caught with drugs, so that has to have been a factor in her panic that night.

I

isabella saxon, Portland, USA Oregon

Shouldn't Amanda Knox at least be facing charges for falsely accusing Patrick Lumumba?

Tom, Seattle,

If Amanda went to meet her drug dealer who was demanding payment, and took a knife along for protection in case things got out of hand, then she would have just taken the position that Guede killed Meredith and she, Amanda, barely escaped with her life. Instead, she keeps mum about Guede, bleaches the heck out of her home, phones Guede several times, and makes sure the knife goes back to her boyfriend's. And while she has the presence of mind to do all of this, she was so "confused" that she named her boss as the killer and remembers hearing the attack AND sleeping peacefully all night at the boyfriend's place. Drugs do strange things to people....

melissa, Arlington, USA

This has got to be one of the most interesting "who-done-it's" in quite some time. I can't wait for the book to come out.

Rob, Round Lake, IL, USA

to Rudy G. Stuttgart: If only Amanda and Rudy Guede killed Meredith without Raffaele's knowledge, why Raffaele goes on saying he was in his flat all the time and only doesn't know if Amanda was sleeping with him or not?
Amanda says she doesn't remember if Raffaele was with her or not.
Is it really possible Raffaele doesn't remember if Amanda was him or not? Amanda told she was in the house when Patrick (black) abused and killed Meredith. If Amanda was in the house she saw Guede, not Patrick, and in this case why Raffaele goes on with his version? Does Raffaele wish to protect Amanda and himself?
On Italian television Patrick said Meredith was killed to steal some her money. How is possible Patrick knows this?

lis, orvieto, italy

How is Rudy's last name actually pronounced? On television, I've heard it pronounced "GWAY-DAY" and also "GOO-DEE". Can someone tell me? His alibi never fails to make me smile, it just reveals his naivete. It's simply amazing that he could think that would work. I stand by my original theory, that Amanda and Rudy did it without Raffaele's knowledge.

Rudy G., Stuttgart, DE,

Why didn't the woman who heard the screams and the two people fleeing phone the police right away??? What the heck?

Chira Endress, Pittsburgh, USA