Mark Franchetti, Mukachevo, Ukraine
Enter our Snapshots of Summer photography competition
CHEWING slices of pork fat at his house less than two miles from the border with Slovakia, a Ukrainian people smuggler broke into a grin studded with gold teeth as he predicted a sharp increase in trade this year.
On December 21 border controls in much of eastern Europe were abolished as nine new European Union members implemented the Schengen agreement, which allows people to move between most EU countries without a passport check.
From Poland in the north through Slovakia and Hungary to Bulgaria in the south, the porous 1,800-mile Ukrainian border is now the EU’s final barrier against illegal immigrants.
For the smuggler, who claims to have helped hundreds of illegal immigrants into Slovakia, the end of passport controls on EU borders heralds a bonanza.
Migrants typically pay £5,000 to £10,000 to be guided across to the EU. In future, they will do so knowing they can reach France without an official check. Britain, which has not signed the Schengen agreement, represents a challenge but many of those arriving in northern France find a way to cross the Channel.
“More will try to cross from here in Ukraine,” the smuggler said. “First we’ve got a good track record as about 70% don’t get caught, and second because they will be able to travel across the EU without having to show their passports. I expect business to boom.”
Many of those entering the eastern EU countries are thought to be heading for Britain. Although the UK and Ireland have kept border controls, well-guarded frontier posts in Germany and Austria, where many illegals used to be stopped, have closed down. German police say the number of illegal immigrants found in random checks has more than doubled in three weeks.
The people smuggler, who spoke on condition that his identity was withheld, claimed to be part of an international criminal network that routinely pays off guards on Ukraine’s borders.
“Senior border guard officers are bribed,” he said. “I’m given a so-called ‘window’ - a time and a place when a particular stretch of the border won’t be patrolled, say 400 yards for a few hours. With that kind of deal, crossing with a group of illegals is easy.
“Not all border guards are corrupt, of course, but we have no problem finding enough who are willing to turn a blind eye.”
His claims raise fears that no matter how much security is reinforced with extra equipment and personnel, a surge of illegal immigrants will always be able to breach EU borders unless endemic corruption is curbed.
Last year Ukrainian border guards detained some 3,000 illegal immigrants from as far afield as China, Afghanistan, India, Pakistan and Somalia. Ukrainian anti-trafficking police estimate that only 20% of those trying to cross are caught. Detainees are held in a refugee camp in Mukhachevo, a small town 500 miles southwest of Kiev, the capital. Last week the camp held 400 migrants.
“I know some people in Birmingham and I’ve been told it’s easier to get to Britain now the Schengen rules have changed,” said Ahmed, a young Pakistani, who was caught trying to cross into Hungary and is now held at the camp. “They can send me back but I'll try again.”
Most immigrants caught by border guards make another attempt, despite having to pay a relative fortune to the smugglers.
The smuggler interviewed last week said that each migrant pays the total sum for the trip, up to £10,000, to a middleman. The money is then split several ways in the course of the journey between smugglers, border guards, drivers and minders.
“There are many wheels to grease,” the smuggler said. “Getting an illegal from his home village somewhere in southeast Asia all the way to Europe is complex. There’s a huge organisation behind it all, which on the Ukrainian leg alone involves dozens of people.”
More than half the illegal immigrants who cross into the EU via Ukraine go first to Moscow, often on official visas. They are crammed into safe houses, in some cases for months, before being driven into Ukraine, hidden in lorries in groups of up to 150 people. From Kiev, or the port city of Odessa, they are taken to border villages.
Impoverished and only a short walk from the border, the remote hamlets are said by police to be teeming with smugglers who conceal migrants in cellars and abandoned farmhouses before leading them across the border through thick woods and over steep hills. The smugglers use boys as guides because they cannot be prosecuted if caught. They take groups of up to 15 migrants.
“People in villages along the border have been into smuggling illegal immigrants across the border for years. It’s their main income,” said a senior Ukrainian police officer.
According to the smuggler, he is paid £500 per illegal immigrant, of which he keeps £100. The rest goes to his accomplices on both sides of the border. He claimed that in spring and summer, when most migrants are smuggled, he could easily earn £1,500 a month - more than 15 times the local monthly salary.
It can be a deadly crossing. Last September a Chechen woman tried to enter Europe with her four young children from hills on the Ukrainian side of the border, just a few miles from the smuggler’s village.
Walking alone she lost her bearings in heavy rain and falling temperatures. Panicked, she left behind her three daughters, aged between 6 and 13, to search for help. Polish border guards found her and her two-year-old son wandering aimlessly. But by the time they reached the girls, all had died from hypothermia.
Migrants are also at the mercy of criminal gangs who pose as smugglers. Recently 12 Chinese workers were held hostage by their minders. They were handcuffed in a cellar on Ukraine’s border with Slovakia and beaten and starved for several days.
Their captors forced them to phone home to ask relatives to wire more money. They escaped and police are investigating.
“No matter how much they tighten controls, we’ll always find a way across,” said the smuggler. “As far as I’m concerned, the expansion of Schengen is a blessing.”
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Ukraine has all interest to have semi-transparent western border.
we do not need all those immigrants in Ukraine and we do not have money for extradition.EU obviously wont support this financially neither EU would ever help Ukraine to solidify its Eastern border.
I
slavik, zaporozhye, Ukraine
First, a correction - it's not "the Ukraine." That's like saying "the England," or "the Poland," or "the Germany."
It's - Ukraine.
Second - I wonder why no mention of all the Russian oligarchs who have arrived in London in such massive numbers that it's now known as "Londongrad"?
elmer, Oklahoma City, USA
You know i was born in Ukraine and i am living here now. At my students times i had also a dream of better life somewhere abroad as many of my friends in that age. I had made a try to come to Western Europe, of course it wasn't a smuggler try:). I went to Germany in absolutely legal way. I stayed there for 2 month, that was enough to see the realities and to get very useful experience. What i have to say now is - ther is only one condition to consider life in foreigh country better - if only you were hungry or oppressed at home. My personal impressions from my life in Germany are not so colourful. It very difficult to live in role of "underman", "half citizen". At first i though that it were just my personal impressions, but this article prove my impressions. European Union will never treat us as equal partners, we are wild tribs for them. I pity that our goverment cannot see these realities. I do hope that we can live in good neighbourhood but i doubt that we need each other.
Ihor, Kiev, Ukraine
2 Dennis, Houston, USA - Is Saudi Arabia making so much troubles with getting visa that anybody needs to go there illegally?
Slavko, Kyiv, Ukraine
Two points in response to this article:
1. Corruption within the ranks of Ukrainian border officers would not be such a big problem, if their counterparts on other side (Polish, Slovakian, Hungarian, etc.) were not corrupt either. There is a border patrol on each side â neither does the work they are paid to do.
2. Illegal immigration will slow down significantly if EU citizens stop hiring cheap labor, people with no right to work legally in Europe. Stop providing social and healthcare services to illegal immigrants. This will not solve the problem, but will reduce the number of people trying to sneak in without permission.
US face the same problem with millions of illegal immigrants already in the country and hundreds trying to cross the border every day. There is no easy solution for this, and I donât plan to start long discussion about it.
Dennis, Houston, USA
To Saud from Riyadh: Have any of those Brits in Arab world come there illegally? Have they crossed into Saudi Arabia without visa or work permit?
Dennis, Houston, USA
uhm, I wonder if Mr Franchetti has bothered to visit Ukraine at all. "chewing pork fat... with golden teeth" sounds very Borat ) Mukacheve (btw this is the correct spelling) is not 500 but 350 miles SW from Kyiv
In the comments to this story a former smuggler debunks some details of this article: http://korrespondent.net/worldabus/352822
according to him, most smuggling business is controlled not by gangsters but by SBU (former KGB) and police. "Boys as guides" is also a hearsay - it's mostly border guards and local villagers
I don't really get how all this can harm GB which does not participate in Schengen agreement anyway!
Max , Toronto , Canada
"each migrant pays the total sum for the trip, up to £10,000" - are you kidding, where do they get it? The problem of illegal migration is really very serious, butt this artickle is a load of old cobblers.
Alisher, Bochum, Germany
Ukraine - for ever!! Slices of pork - for ever!! I like you Europe, almost as well as slices of pork. Bandera - hero!
Taras, Kiev, Ukraine
We all know we are the laughing stock of the world. However, there are so many 'good-doers' in this country if anyone speaks out they are accused of racism!
Hard working people that are paying their taxes are left to pick up the cost of this 'traitor' government.
My mother is enraged that her father chose to fight for this country even though he had the option to not go! Many more of the older generation must wonder what on earth they bothered fighting for!
Boucher, West Midlands, England
the tragedy is not that these people come, but that so many of them become enemies of the West although their own countries and their creeds have ruined their lives.
Sigge Bock, Sweden
sigge bock, krylbo, sweden
To: Geoff, Seattle, USA.
You better deal with your own country. You got your lively boy - G.W. Bush, so try to get rid of him first! :)
Oh... I forgot:"God blessed America!"
P.S. Same things happen all over the world. That's the human nature:"looking for the better life" And they have a right to live better.
Oleg, London, England
there are 5.5 million brits living and making living abroad spcially in arabian gulf so what is wrong with 5.5 million forginers coming to england if it good enough for the brits to live abroad then it is good enough for others to come to the uk
saud, riyadh,
How many times over the past few years have I written about the decline in the English way of life. I am 74 and I am sure that up to 10 years ago, I have lived through the best times that this country had to offer. Within the next 20 years no English white person will live in a country that had great freedom of choice that once was. Goodbye England...
victor arram, westcliff on sea, essex
All totally predicatable and foreseeable to anyone but our brain dead Labour Members of Parliament .Immigration, immigration, immigration - do Bliar Tony, Bottler Gordon, Saddo 'kebab'Jacqui, Hormone Harriet, 'Incompetent 'Hain and their friends get the point yet?
david, Uzes, France
Hi Geoff - no doubt your relatives did exactly the same thing en route to the promised land...much the same as many of the white, Anglo-Saxon, Protestant supremacists that your civilised country has produced...?
Peter, Portsmouth, UK
I think Geoff of Seattle completely sums up what a great many Brits think. Unfortunately England is no longer in the process of being destroyed because it already has been. Stopping all immigration tomorrow would not put right what has happened. Maybe this is the reason why more than ever of us are voting with our feet and leaving. That fact and the considerably higher birthrate among immigrants does not bode well for the future.
B Redfern, Krsko, Slovenia
Like The Who say, "There is no England now...." How sad! You are letting yourselves be destroyed by illegal immigrants. Don't you understand, they're leaving their countries because they're horrible. The problem with that is this, they come to Great Britain and don't assimillate into the British culture. instead, they drag their own broken cultures with them and impose them on everyone around them. They feed off your welfare system until it's bankrupt, then demand that you accomodate them further by letting them practice their own customs and language rather than obey yours. Good Lord GB, where is Churchill or Thatcher when you need them! I pray that your people will rise up and throw Labour out on its ear!
Geoff, Seattle, USA
For this we pay the EU £10 billion a year?
Peter, Manchester, England