Nicola Smith, Dubai
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
LUXURY developments on artificial islands in the Arabian Sea, where highly paid British footballers own holiday homes worth £700,000, are being built by migrant workers earning as little as £3 a day.
The Palm Jumeirah, off the coast of Dubai, has been designed in the shape of a palm tree with 1,500 opulent villas and 30 beachfront hotels, including one under construction by Donald Trump, the American entrepreneur.
David Beckham is among the stars who have bought substantial properties there. They will soon be enjoying attractions ranging from scuba diving to a “golden mile” of restaurants and shops, secure in the knowledge that they are protected from paparazzi by the strict privacy laws of Dubai, the most populous of the seven states that make up the United Arab Emirates (UAE).
But less than four miles from the resort stands the bleak desert camp of Jebel Ali, a sprawl of breeze-block huts and battered trailers where about 10,000 construction workers — including many from the Palm Jumeirah — are crammed into stifling dormitories at the end of the day.
They sleep up to 15 to a room, each with a flimsy bunk bed, a thin mattress and dirty, bug-rid-den sheets. They cook their paltry meals on mini-stoves and squat on the ground to eat. One resident spoke of a strike four months ago over a shortage of lavatories.
The conditions reflect the meagre wages for a working week of six and often seven days. Many of the men believed the assurances of recruiters in India, Pakistan and Bangladesh that they would make enough money to support their poverty-stricken families back home, but have since become trapped in a spiral of debt and despair.
The government of the UAE was accused by Human Rights Watch last year of presiding over abuses ranging from low and unpaid wages to deaths and injuries caused by poor health and safety procedures. But little appears to have changed.
Last week Gandeep, a carpenter in his mid-twenties, said he had been deceived by a recruitment company in his native Punjab that had promised him a skilled job in Dubai. Instead he had been put to work as a helper in a restaurant on the Palm, where British buyers are acquiring a quarter of the properties.
Gandeep earns £76 a month. His hopes of sending money back to his family have been destroyed. With food costing about £35 a month, there is little left to pay off a £1,100 debt to the recruitment agency, let alone to spare for relatives. His passport was taken by his employer when he arrived in Dubai, effectively trapping him in his job.
He seemed resigned to his fate. “I don’t like it here and I want to go back but I just have no means to do so,” he said.
His story is the norm rather than the exception. Murgan, a labourer from Andhra Pradesh in south India who is working on a 10-storey building on the Palm Jumeirah, told a similar tale. He paid £1,400 to an agency and now exists on £83 a month. In other camps, workers on different projects told of toddlers they had never seen and children pleading with them to come home.
Ilias, a 28-year-old labourer who came from Rajasthan, northwest India, to live in the Sonapur labour camp, said he could go home only every two years to see his daughters, aged six and four, and he now had a one-year-old son. “Life is tough here,” he said.
He said he worked eight-hour shifts for £100 a month on a construction site near the Mall of the Emirates, an exclusive shopping centre that has an indoor ski run with real snow.
The driving force behind the multi-billion-pound Palm project and other developments that have transformed Dubai is its ruler, Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid al-Maktoum. With oil expected to run out within 20 years, the emirate has embarked on a building frenzy to secure its future as a tourist destination.
Dubai has the first seven-star hotel and will soon have the world’s tallest building, the Burj Dubai, which is expected to reach 2,650ft. About 700,000 Britons visit Dubai each year and celebrities reported to have expressed an interest in property include Michael Schumacher, the former Formula One racing champion, and the singers Rod Stewart and Michael Jackson.
The sheer scale of construction by an estimated 300,000 migrants working for 6,000 companies has allowed unscrupulous recruitment agencies and employers to mistreat them.
The suicide rate among Indian workers alone rose from 70 in 2004 to 100 in 2006. Two weeks ago an Indian worker was found hanged from a tree in one camp.
Madusoondanan Achari, 42, from Kerala, southwest India, collapsed and died last week after paying a hefty fee to an agency, only to discover there was no job for him when he reached Dubai.
“It is exploitation by our own people. The workers wouldn’t come if they knew it was for only £80-£90 a month,” said KV Shamsudeen, an Indian businessman who has set up a support group for labourers.
Work-related deaths are another well-kept secret. Officially, 34 workers died on site in 2004. An investigation by Construction Week, a Dubai trade magazine, found 880 migrant construction workers had died that year, although it was unclear how many had been killed at work.
A volunteer named Joseph visits injured workers in hospitals, helping to raise funds to go home. One of his clients is an Indian worker who has been lying in a vegetative state since September when he succumbed to dehydration, fell and was dumped by his employer at the side of the road. His name is still unknown.
The UAE government was jolted last year by a revolt of 2,500 labourers at the Burj Dubai tower. It promised to improve conditions and fine companies for late payment of wages. Yesterday it emerged the government was considering introducing a minimum wage.
A spokesman said the authorities were cracking down on rogue recruitment agencies. But the government has failed to legalise unions despite promising to do so, and human rights activists say many of the changes have not been implemented.
“The legal framework is not very clear for the labourers. There are lots of loopholes through which companies abuse them,” said Mohammed al-Roken, a human rights lawyer who has been banned from writing in local newspapers.
Dissent on construction sites is swiftly stamped out. Two weeks ago 250 workers on the Dubai marina were deported after an 8,000-strong crowd demandeda 25p-a-day rise in their monthly income of £75-£85. Some have had no pay increase since 1990.
It is all a far cry from the lifestyle of the England footballers who treated themselves to the finest villas at Palm Jumeirah on their way to the 2002 World Cup in Japan and South Korea.
The completion of their homes is now imminent. A spokesman for Beckham said he had been told the workers on his property had not been maltreated.
“We have been assured in the past that workers’ rights are being respected and that pay is reflective of the pay in that area. If there is any further information that comes to light then, of course, we will put those points to the developer and ask for answers,” he said.
Nakheel Properties, one of three principal developers in Dubai that manage the main construction sites, including the Palm Jumeirah, said it complied strictly with UAE labour laws. But a spokesman said it was up to contractors to set the pay and living conditions.
A volunteer who helps exploited workers said: “Dubai wants to be a modern-day Las Vegas or Monaco and attract the affluent but it doesn’t care about the people at the bottom.”
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
I live in Sharjah United Arab Emirates, and experience how Indians are exploited on a daily basis. Many Indians work as labourers drivers house maids and office jobs. Actually things back home for these workers are not so ROSY so many Asian workers actually accept such appalling conditions. They are ready to be exploited because they don't have a better alternative in their home countries. There is so much talk about India becoming a super power yet we see so many Indians living in poverty in the United Arab Emirates, and in India.Their Country seems unable to do anything for them. The only escape for these labourers from their miserable life is to see the occassional Indian Movie with their heroine actress Aishwaria gyrating in her semi pornographic Bollywood dance and sex scenes.These approximately 500,000 labourers live without female company for years in labour camps. Why blame the rest of the World blame India.Apart from cheap vulgar Movies what does it provide for Indians???
shaheen hamadani, dubai, united arab emirates
It's all true, I lived in Dubai for 3 years and have just recently returned back from Dubai, These stories are about the worst cases that mainly apply for people in the construction or cleaning industries, but believe me this is rife in all areas of that country. It is often not seen by the many torists that visit it. Lets face it the government knows exactly what is going on but they simply dont care. I had a proffesional job in a financial institution and I was exploited very badly, it left me very depressed. I was nearly put in prison until I wised up and realised that nobody was going to sympathise with me nor help me. Lucky for me I escaped that hell hole. I would not recommend it to work, Believe me Human Rights Watch is not making a noise about nothing. My story is very long and the scope of this forum does not allow me to go into details here due to word constraints but I would loveto spill the beans on whats its really like to live and work in the city of gold.
kam, Londlon, England
Ilias, a 28-year-old labourer who came from Rajasthan, northwest India, to live in the Sonapur labour camp, said he could go home only every two years to see his daughters, aged six and four, and he now had a one-year-old son. Life is tough here, he said.
his one year old son !! how he did so ? va e mail ?
after all it is a sad story ..but i think it is true . but life had been so sence evere ...i dont belive it will change .
freedonader, Dubai, U A E
The pyramids in Egypt always made me wonder about the number of workers died because of bad working conditions and slavery in the construction process and felt a pain in my concience when I cldnt keep myself from admiring these statue of human torturing and exploiting other humans for selfish whimsical beliefs and pseudoneeds...But;then I say ,those were ancient times,the rules of forest were prevailing....Has human concience shown no progress at all since those times?All the juvenile and other innocent people`s deaths in the world because of wars,famine,bad living condtions a.t.l.and now a striking example of slavery type of working conditions....How can people believe in Good and religion of any form and do these at the same time?They all believe in one god whether christian or Muslim or of any other religion....MONEY....and cover up their real beliefs ............Duygu,Turkey
DUYGU KOMAN, ISTANBUL, TURKIYE
I wonder what the Indian Government does to protect illiterate Indians who are stranded in Dubai. The passports of these illiterates are supposed to have been rubber-stamped "Emigration Clearance Required," meaning that these illiterates needed protection from The Indian Government from exploitation abroad. The Passport Offices in India make a BIG FUSS about this rubber stamp, but I never hear of the Indian Government lifting as much a finger to bring back these blighted illiterates home.
Premkumar Thoppae, Gachibowli, Hyderabad, India
It is slavery and exploitation, pure and simple. It is shameful and degrading to all concerned. There is no justification for it and no one with any understanding of the problem would or should attempt to excuse it. The government and authorities are willing partners in this greedy and dastardly venture.
K Shrimanker, Bristopl, UK
Dear SAM, Dubai
I do not see how this "artical" is one sided...
Yes, but at least they're on home soil, they're somewhere they call home, and not some foreign desert. In case you did not read, they were "lured" there by individuals who are making a quick blood buck on these people. Its easy to dismiss this as "they came on their own will", but they were decieved with more money. As for your suggestion about feeding them, no government will take them in simply because of the red tape surrounding them... most of these labourers have no passport and have no means to get home. Not only that, thats not what this article is about. Its about getting the dubai rulers to look this way and work to give the labourers a better deal, and in exchange the rulers get goodwill as well as better quality workmanship...
Andre, Mumbai,
Pretty much all of the Arab world, is simply authoritarian and kleptocratic. Dubai might be shiny, but it's no different from any other - strip away that veneer and you'll also see that it's little more than a dump in a desert, with the mother of all property crashes just about to happen..... The exploited workers have my sympathy.
GB, London,
Gulf , especially Dubai still remains to be a dream for millions of poor unskilled workers from India, Pakistan, Bangladesh and Srilanka. The fact is that they at least get a job and payment when comparing to the unemployment and poverty of their mother country. Most of the comanies and recruiting agencies take advantage of the weekness of these workers. They take not less than one thousant pounds from each applicant and send them to the Arabian desert to die. Then only they realize that facts are often stranger than fiction. I know many people who curse their fate and live lifeless life in Gulf.Congratulations to Nicola Smith for depcting the true but tragic life of poor immigrants in Dubai.
Manoj Mathew, Middlesbrough, United Kingdom
Sam, with respect, how they live in their own countries has nothing to do with it. Dubai carefully tends the image of a civilised society: let it then treat its indentured workers in a civilised manner.
Dubai entrepreneurs are charging prices for real estate that are not far off UK prices, and paying labour costs that are not even 5% of what a UK construction worker would expect. If this is not a perfect example of greed and exploitation, then I don't know what is. And the confiscation of passportsis but one small step away from outright slavery.
And as for Saint Beckham - "oh they told me the workers on my estate are well-treated, and of course I believed it, so that's all right then".
Michael Deman, Cairo, Egypt
Before you write about their life in Dubai, go and see how they live in their owen contries and how much they earn there if they get any job, or why don't you suggest to your goverment to take all these poor labores and feed them, so that you stope writing such one side of the story articals.
Sam, Dubai,
All the Arab states who call themselves as the custodians of muslim faith and yet rob these poor hard workers of their blood money should hang their head in shame. They are disgrace & should not label themselves as muslims.
M Akram, Ilford, essex, UK
Did one say that slavery was abolished 200 years ago? I am dreaming. Slavery is here and we are all guilty for our indifference for so long.
Anil Gayan, Curepipe, Mauritius
When people accuse Isreal of "Apartheid" they should look to the Arab states. There is a defacto apartheid in the whole of the Aram muslim world.
Masood, Tokyo, Japan