Chris Gourlay and Abul Taher
Enter our Snapshots of Summer photography competition
Islamic militants are suspected of using Second Life, the internet virtual world, to hunt for recruits and mimic real-life terrorism.
Police and the intelligence services are concerned that it may have been infiltrated by extremists to proselytise, communicate and transfer money to one another. Radicals may also be responsible for “virtual” terrorist attacks in which buildings depicted on the website are blown up.
Kevin Zuccato, head of the Australian government’s High Tech Crime Centre, said jihadists may also be using the virtual reality world to master skills such as reconnaissance and surveillance. “We need to start thinking about living, working and protecting two worlds and two realities,” he told a security industry conference in Sydney.
The concerns are shared by Europol, the pan-European police agency, which believes that Second Life provides a means to transfer money across borders in a way that is more difficult for the authorities to monitor. It has recruited security consultants to advise on the use of Second Life for fraud and terrorism.
Of particular concern is the anonymity of Second Life members who can use false names for their digital personas, known as avatars, to disguise their real identity and provide false contact details in the real world.
Intelligence sources said that although communications traffic through Second Life could in theory be monitored, often the only means of tracking an individual is by tracing the user’s IP address - the physical location of a computer in the real world - but even this can be faked. Monitoring complex money movements in the virtual world presents law enforcement agencies with further surveillance challenges.
Second Life, which has a global membership of more than 8.5m, uses three-dimensional graphics technology to create a virtual world. Anyone can become a member or “resident” for free and roam the virtual world after creating an avatar. They then meet and interact with other users’ avatars, visiting shops, theatres and sports events, trading goods and services and having sex.
So popular has Second Life become that companies such as Sony, BMW and Reebok have bought “land” and opened premises there. Some governments, including that of Sweden, have opened virtual embassies in Second Life.
Recently, inhabitants of the virtual world have experienced a more sinister phenomenon - virtual terrorist attacks against buildings and avatars. A recent attack took place at the Australian Broadcasting Corporation’s Second Life base. A number of these attacks, known as “griefings”, have been launched by what industry insiders say are “geeky teenagers” giving themselves names such as the Second Life Liberation Army.
Some experts, however, believe the “virtual atrocities” may have been committed by real Islamic radicals. Rohan Gunaratna, a terrorism expert at the International Centre for Political Violence and Terrorism Research in Singapore, said that for the past three months he had monitored about 12 jihadists who have assumed identities in Second Life. He said they were mostly based in America and Europe.
Some radicals, he said, had given themselves “innocuous” titles, while others had provocative jihadist names such as Irhabi007 (Arabic for Terrorist007). Gunaratna acknowledged that not all Islamists had any intention of carrying out terrorist attacks in real life, but said that they were using Second Life to build a community of extremists.
“Even in the training camps of Afghanistan, less than 1% returned and committed terrorist acts,” said Gunaratna.
Second Life has its own currency, the Linden dollar, named after the company behind the virtual reality world. About 250 Linden dollars are equivalent to one US dollar and residents can buy the currency from the company to trade in Second Life.
Linden Lab said that about $1m (£490,000) a day was exchanged in Second Life.
Linden, which has a team monitoring financial transactions in Second Life, said it was not aware of any money being exchanged by jihadists, but could not rule out the possibility.
Europol and the British Serious Organised Crime Agency (Soca) are concerned that Second Life provides an ideal facility for criminals to launder money through in-world enterprises such as casinos. There are fears that terrorists could also take advantage of difficulties in policing Linden dollar movements to transfer funds between operatives around the world.
A Soca source said the agency was looking at ways to address illicit financial activity in the virtual world.
The source added that policing the movement of money in Second Life presents challenges, as funds may be transferred across borders.
Mark Johnson, chairman of Risk Management Group, a British agency that advises Europol on fraud and terrorism in Second Life, said: “The critical issue with terrorist funding cases is trying to detect money movements prior to the commission of the crime. So if you can move money around in secret in an environment where there is little surveillance, it is a very sensitive point.”
John Zdanowski, chief financial officer at Linden, said the company strictly monitored the exchange of money in Second Life. So far, he added, there had not been any suspicious transaction where the company had called in the police or the FBI.
Linden also said that it was unaware of any extremists using Second Life.
Terror Spotters
CCTV cameras capable of spotting criminals and known terrorist suspects through facial recognition technology are set to be deployed at Euston railway station in London, writes Dipesh Gadher.
The cameras are likely to monitor passengers coming through ticket barriers in order to get a “fix” on their faces. The captured images will be cross-referenced against photographs of criminals.
Sources claim this will initially involve identifying minor offenders, such as pickpockets. Once installed, the technology could also be used with a security service database of terrorist suspects.
Euston already has a network of digital CCTV cameras that should be able to run facial recognition software.
The technology - based on two-dimensional images, or possibly 3-D ones for greater accuracy - is being developed by biometrics experts at the National Policing Improvement Agency.
The trial, which could take place later this year, is part of a wider clampdown on security at key transport hubs.
The July 7 suicide bombers were captured on CCTV as they travelled to London on the Thameslink rail service from Luton. At least two of the attackers had previously been monitored and photographed by the authorities.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the collective power of smart thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Flip MinoHD Camcorder
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
42,945
2008
71,450
Car Insurance
Not Specified
MI6
UK-based
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Save up to £1,000 per couple with Elite Vacations at the five-star Constance Lemuria Resort
and do the British Isles this Summer.
Save up to 60% with Oxford Hotels and Inns
Try our inspiring luxury holidays to the Indian Subcontinent and South East Asia.
Great offers available
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
I would think the issue they are most worried about here is an avenue for money transfer/laundering, not really the fact that 'terrorist like' actions are being committed in an imaginary world. The concern is focused on the real world problem of locking down on terrorist funding.
Joe, Colorado Springs,
I had 2 giant World Trade Center Buildings with airplanes crashing into them, put on my land in Second Life one day and people were shooting at other residents with virtual guns. I missed it till I logged on and found the Buildings. I reported them to Linden labs complete with screeen shots, but never heard of any results other then it was dealt with. Whether it is just wild kids or terrorists I have no idea, but it gives one pause.
RP, Malibu, CA
You know, if people truely wished to use an online source to "Recruit" or to "Gather" any chat room, virtual game that is accessable via the internet, and especailly venues in which money can be transfered would be utilized to the fullest. I guess the only recourse would be to shut down the virtual world fully. Destroy all computers! Why not? It's a witch hunt now, isn't it? All the negative news about Second Life, has been destroying what was created to be an avenue of fun, adventure, and relaxation. Next there's going to be a religous crusade against all the free sex and such that takes place in virtual worlds. Where does it end? Governents just have to have their fingers into everything, including something people utilize for an escape, above all other things. Sadly, what people can do in SL, they're unable in the real world because of Government suppressions, and that of those who have wealth and power. Lord Forbid the people have something to themselves!
Ekaterina, Tennessee USA,
Hey Farrukh, when muslims were profiled going on sports? When muslims were profiled going on adventure? And so on... Come on, poor poor victim! Are you saying that you have now justifications for hatred and actions upon that hatred?!!
Alex Sp, Aberystwyth, UK
This goes to show that people will act the same way in virtual reality that they do in real life. Human nature is the same both on and off line.
Chris, Lynchburg, Va,
Sir,
Isn't this just a sly excuse by some of the SS for obtaining some R+R whilst appearing to be at work?
SC, London, United Kingdom
Probably the most famous 'terrorist' attach in Second Life was when Anshe Chung, a major virtual landowner, was bombarded by flying animated penises during a news conference. Unless militant islam is taking a new tack this is probably of limited use for training real world terrorists.
It is difficult to know where to start with articles like this one. Gambling was banned in SL last week and the opportunities for money laundering in a world where every transaction is recorded, and very few items cost more than a pound or two, are strictly small-scale.
Second Life is perculiarly unsuited to any form of atrocity - for a bomb to do any damage the owner of the land being bombed would have to get together with the bomber, give him permssion for the bomb to go off, and set up programs for it to cause damage to his buildings. Finally anonymity - well if you have to know the real identity of every vampire, stormtrooper and slave girl to feel safe you really do have a paranoia problem.
Kevin James, Stirling, Scotland
The australian Broadcasting Corp appear to have owned up to a sever error on july 7, so the whole story is based around a non-event. As it happens, I think they inadvertently returned their own build.
I suppose on the grounds that terrorists are as likely as anyone else to enjoy a virtual life, they may be in SL... but the fact that the author of the article didn't check those facts he included leads me to suppose that they have no better information about that than I do.
Fiona Berry, Uxbridge, England
Some of these issues relating to virtual world platforms are discussed in more depth at www.metasecurity.net
Roderick Jones, San Francisco, CA
Well Farrukh, you know who to blame for all that, don't you? The extremists who dirtied the name of your religion by their actions, and all those who don't stand up to counter the ideology behind them.
Suzy Kang, London,
Teenage boys have for years loved blowing things up. Fireworks, mentos and coke, and all manner of dangerous and stupid methods have been used. Boys have also been playing war games since history began.
These days however war games are frowned upon and any child or teenager carrying a toy gun runs the risk of being shot for real by someone with the real thing.
So big surprise teenage boys on a virtual world play war games and blow things up.
Its safe and its fun. Like all environments where kids gather - arguments happen. But in Second Life you can vent your anger (though it is frowned upon) by exploding your 'enemies' buildings - or even by shooting them.
12 jihadists among the huge number of second lifers is a miniscule amount. Most second lifers are fairly bright and independent minded kids and not at all ripe grounds for terrorist recruitment. Now if you told me that MI5/FBI were recruiting there I might believe it.
Michele, UK,
First Muslims are profiled when go on sports days e.g. kayaking. Then Muslims are profiled when we go on adventure days e.g. tank driving. Then we are profiled if we have too much money and take flying lessons. Now every Muslim who plays a computer game is ALSO going to be suspected of being a terrorist or wanna-be terrorist. What on earth is left for me to do? I suppose if I stay at home and bake cookies all day... but then I'll probably be profiled for creating some chemical concoction giving the standard of my baking skills. Oh to have been born a white guy.
Farrukh, Woking, UK
Yes, thats right we need to protect the virtual world from virtual attacks. What a load of old rubbish. Dollars are being traded for nothing of physical worth or value and we have to be concerned about virtual terror? Really this has gone far enough, let the teenagers run free on the companies stupid enough to invest in money for nothing. I for one support vitual terrorist attacks. Who gets harmed? No one! just a bunch of people who expereince a minor inconvienence. Put these people into a real terrorist situation where their families are killed or maimed and then they will see the horrors of real life. Who really cares if he virtual australian embassy is attacked. People who are shallow and selfish, thats who
Bob Arctor, Accrington,
Gambling was banned from Second Life a few days ago and how anonymous one can be in there is to be seen, following the case Eros LLC vs. John Doe a/k/a Volkov Catteneo at the U.S. District Court in Tampa, Florida. In theory it can be used for recognition and all sort of things, as anti-terror training too, but we need to be careful to not jump into conclusions that target a technology based on highly hypothetical scenarios.
Fernando Barrio, London, UK
SL is a powerful collaboration tool, education and training are flourishing as interactivity is ideally suited for rapid learning scenarios. Virtual environments reflect the real world and will be used for activities ranging form the legitimate, to the illegal. It is important that we extend our security measures and our vigilance to persistent online environments, just as we do in the real world. Islamicists and their sympathisers will be active in SL, just as they are active in neighbourhoods, towns and cities across the UK, and overseas from Hamburg to Helmand.
Halo DeSantis, London,
Have any of these experts actually been in Second Life? Trying to train terrorists in the Second Life virtual world would be like trying to show someone how to tie their shoes while wearing oven mits and dark glasses. Just trying to sit on a chair without ending up standing on a table can prove difficult.
As for using SL as a means of recruiting, I think tradition websites are far more effective.
No, seriously. Have any of these experts been in Second Life? Seriously.
Christopher Simpson, Toronto, Canada