Tim Reid in Washington
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes

A Pentagon decision to allow the sale of Playboy and Penthouse magazines on military bases has appalled US religious groups, which insist it is illegal.
After dozens of anti-pornography groups complained to Robert Gates, the US Defence Secretary, over the sale of magazines and videos, a Pentagon board reviewed the contents of Penthouse and Playboy and decided that they were not sexually explicit.
The review board was asked to determine whether hundreds of pornographic publications breached the Military Honour and Decency Act of 1996, which bars shops on military bases from selling “sexually explicit material”.
The board decided that because the majority of each title’s contents dealt with advertising and non-pornographic material, then “based on the totality of each magazine’s content, they were not sexually explicit”. The Pentagon thus allowed the sale of titles including Celebrity Skin, Penthouse, Playboy, Playboy’s College Girls, Playboy’s Lingerie and Nude.
It banned from military shops several videos, including Girls’ Night In and Blonde and Beyond. The Pentagon said that about 67 per cent of the 473 titles reviewed had been banned.
A spokeswoman for Roscoe Bartlett, the Republican congressman who sponsored the 1996 law, told The Times that military bases were enclosed environments where families and children also lived. The base shop was often the only place for spouses, children and soldiers to buy things.
She added: “These sexually explicit magazines are treating women as sexual objects, and it is demeaning to female soldiers.”
She said that pornography increased the risk of sexual harassment and abuse of female soldiers.
Pat Trueman, the head of the Alliance Defence Fund, said that he, along with other family values groups, was overseeing an e-mail campaign to two million Americans asking them to lobby their congressmen against the Pentagon decision.
Mr Trueman told The Times: “What they are trying to do is to ban the hardest-core pornography, but allow the softer titles. That’s not obeying the law. The law says ‘sexually explicit’.”
The 1996 Act defines sexually explicit film or printed matter as “the dominant theme of which depicts or describes nudity” or sexual activities “in a lascivious way”. The Act was challenged under the US Constitution’s free-speech provisions but was upheld by an appeals court in 2002. The American Civil Liberties Union takes a different view from Mr Trueman. One member said it was absurd that the US asked soldiers to risk their lives to defend the Constitution, but there were bans on what they could read.
On the Alliance Defence Fund’s website many bloggers also defended pornography. “Hundreds of thousands of men: not allowed to be gay; expected to remain faithful to their wives. And you don’t allow porn?” said one.
Another wrote: “Porn is essential to release pent-up manhood.”
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
I think they should exercise some Christian charity and give the guys who risk their lives so they can go to crystal cathedrals to have all the porn they want.
Titilated of Tunbridge Wells, Sydney, Australia
it is a bit rich for the religious fundamentalists to connive at the ruination of Iraq and Afganistan and get into a lather about playboy - lather is probably right... send the boys home and playboy with them - make love not war
Robin, Dublin
Robin Harte, Dublin, Ireland
Trying to add to any rational discussion by quoting the bible seems rather ridiculous Kelly. I might as well say Father Christmas doesn't like porn and wants us all to be good boys and girls and therefore we shouldn't look at playboy, it makes an equally unconvincing argument.
Richard, Worthing, UK
JESUS said that "whomever looks at a women with lust, has commited adultery in his heart" now top that!! Thous shalt not commit adultery is one of the Ten Commandments, if not familiar its time to learn them.
Kelly, Malvern, Arkansas
The guys need something to keep them going!
Will they be able to say its againt their human rights not to ogle?
I don't know what the fuss is about Playboy is very soft considering what else it out there.
As long as they know the score about being discreet around female collegues. It should be O.K
Eloise, san francisco, ca
A) Only porn made by large companies who donate to political parties will be allowed on US armed forces bases.
B) Risk your life for your country and kill but don't you dare look at ladies without their clothes on!
C) If the soldiers can't have porn why not give them the actual models? Would increase recruitment into the services!
will, whitstable, kent
If magazines are banned, what is next? Television maybe! Take a look at some of the Prime Time Broadcasts.
L. Bolling, Bristol, Tennessee/USA
It is quite funny, as if soldiers away from their partners are not going to have porn with them now.
Charlie, Salisbury, England
So its fine to shoot at people but porn is evil..?!?!?!
God bless America...
Nick, London, UK
Porno on bases is especially wrong because there are so many women in today's military and many are already being raped and brutalized, and I am sure that on-site porn isn't helping the military men to see their female colleagues as equals-- quite the contrary. Pornography is bad for women and should not be on US bases.
Trilby, New York, New York
I agree with the ban. I am a female veteran, and unless you're on this side of the fence you don't know what it's like to feel sexualized b/c of this type of magazine.
It's a power trip. A very uncomfortable power trip
The whole porn thing is another way of putting women "in their place" by displaying them in subservient positions in a magazine, and then translating that attitude into real life.
Why do men feel it's their right to ogle naked women, and then tell us to relax, stop being so uptight? Well, I AM uptight! I HATE being disrespected like this, as if we're there for their pleasure in any way shape or form, even in the military. It is demoralizing to say the least, and highly insulting, to view women as just another aspect of a day in the life of some oversexed, overstimulated man who sees all women as attainable sexually because they have the "power" of seeing us in simpering sexual positions for their enjoyment, day in, day out.
As usual we women have no say in the matter.
rita, Peyton, CO, U.S.
Life is already tough at the frontline for all male troopers. They are at war, and most of them will go into combat in near future.
Surely, a little bit of pleasure shouldn't be denied for them? Besides, its all simple: if you don't like porn, don't buy it. But don't deprieve other people of that choice.
After all, do we expect all of the men to be like monks when they are in the army? C'mon.
Tim, Singapore, Singapore
I agree with Andrew Milner. All we really need to do is to drop a few 30,000lb Mother-of-all-Porn-Bombs on Al Qaeda and all resistence would immediately cease. They'd all be in such a disfunctional tizzy, they wouldn't have any idea of what to do. We'd have every single one of them renouncing Islam and lining up to apply for US citizenship immediately (with a complementary subscription of course).
Of course this is only the lightweight Playboy version. The nuclear option would be a bit, er, hotter - maybe Hustler spiked with some biker rags.
Scott, Durham, NC, USA
I read it for the news and holiday decorating tips.
Doug, Phoenix, AZ, USA
I'm so sick of the religious right pushing their so-called morals on everybody. Time to ignore these idiots!!!!!!
Jeff, Whitefish, SA
Why is it that these things get reported in foreign newspapers which only go on to show how absurd America can be? Good friends in the UK, I trust you know that our religious right does *not* represent the majority of America, despite their desire to paint themselves as centrist and normal.
GF, Topeka, Kansas, USA
Of course the most recognized source of pornography is the "Christian" Bible. Therefore wherever the Bible is sold anything else
also must have shelf space to be sold as well.
Tucano Fulano, Big Bear, California USA
As a former soldier of 8 years and a veteran of Bush War 1, I am outraged at the ridiculousness of this! Once again, the nutters in the Religious Right know what best for all of us! When I was in Iraq in 1990/91, porn was one of the very few things we could enjoy that would take our minds off of what we were doing and where we were! I was married at the time (to the same woman that I am still married to today!!) and my wife would send me Penthouse and Hustler magazines in my care package.
Once again, the small minority trying to decide whats best for the majority.
Good grief, when will they ever see?
Chris, Manchester, TN
Anyone who knows somebody in the armed forces will know that soldiers like porn. FACT.
If these time wasting nutters had any idea of the true standard of "sexually explicit material" being swapped around their nation's global military bases, they'd swallow their teeth.
No wonder the US can't run it's mortgage market properly, they're too busy trifling over utterly pointless moral quibbles like this.
Matt, Bristol, Bristol
There you go. The religious right strikes again. Where would we be without them? No Al Queda, no taliban, no killings over religious differences and hatred. Women would be treated as equals, rather than being reduced to creatures who exist merely to seduce and corrupt men. Science and its burden of proof would rule, rather than ancient fears, superstitions, and faslehoods. But then there might be no one to complain about magazines that show women's breasts. How absolutely horrible that would be.
Joe, Carlstadt, New Jersey
With each passing issue the religous right takes a stand on, I find it harder and harder to share a democracy with their mindset. They force their beliefs upon others, in defense of freedom for all. They demand life for all american fetus, yet insist on the death of others thru wars they will never participate in. They support sending others to fight for them, and now they want to decide what the soldiers can and cannot do with their free time while serving in Iraq. It's beyond obsurd, we've lapped ourselves in obsurdity.
drew, philly
drew, philly,
First of all, the military bases are not the only place for families to shop. Every Base has a Superwalmart nearby, that sells the same things. Its amazing how people are so quick to trample sexual material, but allow movies like The Terminator, Scarface, Star Wars, Transformers, and other movies with a tremendous amount of graphic deaths and violence to remain. The real problem is that some of these these so called religious people are the very ones who are morally weak and likely to committ sexual misconducts.
David, Beaumont, Texas
I can't believe they'd even mention that children and wives shop at the base shops and therefore such magazines should be banned. Children and wives also shop at convenience stores and book shops here in the States where the magazines are sold. They are always wrapped in plastic, ensuring that all potentially naughty bits are covered and they are usually put out of reach of little hands. What's the big deal? Just the religious nuts getting up in arms about something seriously trivial. It's ridiculous.
Alicia, Powhatan, VA, USA
ironically, troops on bases in the states and overseas can buy playboy, and the book "hello my big big honey!" and other *romantic* media simply by going online to amazon.
internet has made many of these efforts to censor the media counterproductive for those who complain, and great ad campaigns for playboy and others when they do.
sheila carfenders, bangkok, thailand
I take it for the Gardening Page. Now if only the US had dropped copies of Playboy, Penthouse and bottles of Jack Daniels on al Qaeda and the Taliban, opposition would have crumbled years ago. I advocated this at the time, but nobody listens to me.
Andrew Milner, Yokohama, Japan