James Bone in New York
Pick up your copy of Joy Division: Closer at WHSmith today

Eliot Spitzer was on the brink of resigning as Governor of New York yesterday after the crusading former prosecutor once known as The Sheriff of Wall Street was exposed as Client 9 of an international prostitution ring.
Mr Spitzer’s forced departure would clear the way for his deputy David Paterson to become the first black governor of the state — and the first legally blind governor in US history.
Aides of Mr Spitzer and Mr Paterson, New York’s LieutenantGovernor, were reportedly holding “transition meetings” on the expected transfer of power.
James Tedisco, the leader of the Republican minority in the state assembly, said that he received a call from Mr Paterson on Monday asking if he would be willing to work with him. “He called me to ask if we would give him the benefit of the doubt, and go forward,” Mr Tedisco said. “I told him we would.” Mr Tedisco threatened to seek Mr Spitzer’s impeachment if he did not stand down within 48 hours.
New York state politics ground to a halt because of the sex scandal, which left even Mr Spitzer’s harshest critics dumbfounded.
Mr Spitzer, the scourge of whitecollar criminals of Wall Street during eight years as New York State Attorney-General, took office as Governor pledging to clean up state government.
He issued a humiliating public apology on Monday after being identified as Client 9 in six secretly recorded telephone calls to set up a tryst with an “American, petite, very pretty brunette” prostitute called Kristen in the Mayflower hotel, Washington, on the eve of St Valentine’s Day.
The wiretap also captured Kristen discussing with a madam Client 9’s alleged preference for unsafe sex.
The madam asked Kristen if Client 9 “would ask you to do things that you, like, might not think were safe — you know — I mean that . . . very basic things”. Kristen responded: “I have a way of dealing with that . . . I’d be, like listen dude, you really want the sex?”
Mr Spitzer had to sneak past his state police bodyguards for his tryst with Kristen. He reportedly rented a second hotel room for the prostitute as George Fox, the name of a close friend and leading campaign contributor.
The recorded conversations make clear that Mr Spitzer was a regular client of the Emperors Club VIP escort service, because he had credit from previous encounters and left a deposit for future services.
Newsday reported yesterday that he had at least seven or eight liaisons with prostitutes from the service around the country, including in Washington and Florida, paying several thousand dollars each time.
Mr Spitzer, 48, who is married with three daughters, faces possible charges stemming not from the sex, but from his payments to the alleged prostitution ring.
The former prosecutor, who has put at least two prostitution rings on trial in his career, could be charged with concealing the purpose of the payments to a criminal enterprise — an offence called structuring that carries a five-year prison term.
He could also be at risk of a separate charge because the prostitute crossed state lines by travelling by train from New York to Washington for the date. The investigation began as an inquiry into suspicious cash transfers involving the New York Governor that investigators suspected initially might be linked to bribery or campaign finance violations.
Using a former prostitute for the escort service as an informant, investigators obtained a judge’s approval for wiretaps and an examination of banking records. They traced the payments to the Emperors Club, which charged up to $5,500 (£2,750) an hour for sex with more than 50 prostitutes in cities from London to Los Angeles.
Mr Spitzer has retained the prestigious Manhattan law firm of Paul, Weiss, Rifkind Wharton & Garrison, which is expected to negotiate with prosecutors to avoid any risk of a felony conviction that could cost him his lawyer’s licence.
Mr Paterson, 53, is the son of the late state senator Basil Paterson, one of the so-called “Gang of Four” politicians who dominated New York’s black stronghold of Harlem. He has been legally blind since an eye infection at the age of 3 months.
Mr Paterson took his father’s Harlem seat in the state senate and was picked as Mr Spitzer’s surprise running mate.
In the presidential campaign Mr Paterson has been a Hillary Clinton loyalist. The Times found him campaigning for her outside a polling station in South Carolina during January’s primary, seeking to persuade black voters to back the New York senator over Barack Obama.
If Mr Spitzer steps aside Mr Paterson will become a super-delegate for Mrs Clinton at the Democratic nomination convention in his place. But Mrs Clinton would lose one precious super-delegate because no one would inherit Mr Paterson’s ex officio vote as a Democratic lieutenant-governor.
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
In our new series, Tony Hawks takes a dry, wry look at modern life - junk mail, interminable meetings and snooty sales assistants
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
2007
£30,000
2006
£14,337
2008
£39,937
Great car insurance deals online
c.£75,000
GlosFirstmeansbusiness
Gloucestershire
Competitive package
Npower
Midlands
£
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
Competitive Package
Npower
West Midlands
1 & 2 Bed apartments
From £249,995
Great Investment, River Views
Great Dubai Investment Opportunities
from £89,950
low-cost ownership homes in London
Multi–Centre 9 Nights
From only £925pp
View thousands of properties online with your Vacation Rental People
£POA
List your property with two leading travel websites
£POA
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - find property for sale and rent in the UK. Milkround Job Search - for graduate careers in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Client No. 9? Busy lady.
Andrew Milner, Karuizawa, Japan Alps
We are all human, and once will fall short of expection,i wish to to thank Mrs. Eliot for her stand. Mum thanks and i wish nothing of the sort will ever come again between yourself and your man. Be strong and fight for your family.
Peter Njoroge, Nairobi, kenya
I think it is OK for his wife to be on his side. It only emphasizes that in America family values are very important.
Al, VA, USA
Al, Octon, Va, USA
Many people are talking about the poor passive wife who is standing next to him while he apoligises for being a douchebag and a cheat and all things unmentionable. Has any one considered that the lady knew and probably suspected that her husband was playing away? I think many of these women who are wronged in public know about such things but they keep shtum because they are asked to. So lets stop the poor me routine and let her grin it and bear it. At the end of the day, she has the option of leaving him to face the music.
Jessica, Coventry , United Kingdom
I still do not understand why his wife was standing next to him on Monday.
I'd be like listen Dude, take care of yer own sh.t!
robert, vancouver, bc
Mr. Spitzer is/was good at his job, but by paying for prostitution "services" in other states it makes this whole thing a federal offense (paying for an illegal activity across state lines or something like that, i don't know the exact law).
It's a shame, but not an uncommon fact. More marriages end in divorce than "death do us part" in the US...this guy just had more money and power to "get what he wanted"...
It will be interesting to see what happens....
John, Orlando, Florida, USA
Dear Cynthia Edwards, Huddersfield, United Kingdom, you think this toe-rag should keep his job? Even though he made his own moral crusade against others doing exactly the same thing? A man who condemned others and branded them criminals for doing what he did. A man pledged to clean up white collar criminals. A man who dragged his passive wife to face the humiliation in front of the press. A hypocrite on all levels. You think he should keep his job?! What planet are you from
John, Chichester, UK
I am sitting in my office in crime ridden South Africa contemplating leaving this country because of it corrupt leaders and systems and then I come upon this article and it soo disspointing to know that this sort of corruption is rife even in a First World Country. Are there no decent people left in the world? or is it that people who come into power just can't resist the evils of the world. What a shame. There really is no hope for the world.
M. G, South Africa
M G, Durban, South Africa
What is taking this sleaze so long to step down...Spitzers ethics alone should knock him off that soap box he stood on so proudly and so arrogantly... I hope they prosecute him as he so adamantly did and pushed for as the Attorney-General. "Clean up the Government" PLEASE. I hope and pray his wife and daughters are giving him HELL. There's three young ladies that are going to require some lying on the couch time.....
R.T. New York
Robert Tull, New York, NY
I am ashamed of Governor Spitzers lack of morality.
I am enraged by his misuse of government funds. It is his fault the MTA proceeded with the fare hike- when all we needed was for him to lobby to the government for 262 million. The entire time, he supported the hike- and in lieu of this atrocity I can see why.
I look forward to a new day, with a new Governor. The winds of change are blowing through this country and the air never smelled so sweet!
S Davis, Brooklyn, New York
Non-New Yorkers probably do not have a full appreciation of what an enormously self-righteous bully Spitzer was as a prosecutor and Attorney General. He made a career of ruining men for what were often extremely marginal transgressions. Knowing the public character of this man, it is hard not be cheered by this.
As far as the criminality of his conduct. He knows better than anyone where the proceeds of a criminal enterprise like this leads. Also, where was all this money coming from? My wife would probably have questioned my spending about $50,000 on illicit sex if I were using the family checkbook.
kevin, NYC,
I just love how some of the"Holier-than-thou" Europeans commenting to the above article try to create some feeling of moral superiority by questioning the concept of whether or not prostitution should be legal in the US. Clearly they do not hesitate to throw around comments about Puritanism or backwardness.
It is peculiarly troubling to know that these critics are the same hypocrites who would cringe in disgust if they found their own spouse, relative, or daughter, engaged in that sordid business.
Cuban Pete, Washington, DC, USA
My question is why do we always see the wives of these corrupt degenerates 'stand by their man'?" The message these women are giving us is that their physical and emotional well being ( and the well being of their children) is secondary to their husband's pathetic need for public approval. There is no honour in enabling criminal behaviour. There is no honour in standing by your man if he isn't man enough to live an honourable life.
Anna, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
We down in contentinal Europe will never understand all the fuss about a politician getting intimately involved with his secretary (see former deputy Prime Minister Prescott) or a call girl.
Nevertheless Spitzner should resign because as an Attorney General he applied vigorously America's ludicrous laws on prostitution while eventually being part of the picture.
carl van hoolandt, Lillois, Belgium
Well, at least the guy immediately owed up to it. Bill Clinton denied denied denied and never had the balls to owe up.
Murmel, Denver
Murmel, Denver, Colorado
Article is a bit vague as to the specifics of âunsafe sexâ Spitzer liked to have with prostitutes. His behaviour seems foolish and very irresponsible, particularly to his wife. He was getting a bit too caught up with himself, something all politicians do with great capacity.
Kirst, Josi, SA
Carolyn - if he has been doing this for years, as you say, then it says a lot for the decency and discretion of the girls whom he went with than none has sold her story.
Possibly he could reciprocate -and blow away the present smell of hypocrisy- by seeking to liberalise the NY laws on prostitution.
David, London, UK
I gather that it is perfectly fine to some people that Spitzer, while Attorney-General, arrested prostitutes but now is being serviced by them. Apparently some people do not see the double standard. Spitzer campaigned as Mr. Clean, Holier-Than-Thou, above cleap sleaze - and now he is caught with his pants down. Hoisted on his own petard.
Nona, New York City, USA
Jonathan of London I am not sure you read the article properly. The man stands to be charged with breaking the law on two counts quite apart from serious errors of judgment and duplicity. How can someone in such a position, especially one who sits at the state bar, possibly stay in office?
Rob, Warfield, England
Is prostitution illegal in America? Weird.
MT, Sydney, Australia
Spitzer should have practiced what he preached and prosecuted others for! As Governor, he pledged to clean up the state's government, and he broke that promise. He should have respect for the process, the law, and tax payers and just step down. He should feel the need to save his family from any further embarrassment!
Steph, Rochester, NY
From what I have read he appears to be very good at his job. Therefore I think he should keep it, why ruin his life over this.
Cynthia Edwards, Huddersfield, United Kingdom
Prosecuting Prostitutes and then Patronising Prostitutes. Who can take his seriously any more?
robert peterson, melbourne, australia
It would be a career ender in the UK too Carolyn of NY. The Profumo Affair in 1963 is one example after the late War Minister's dalliances with the prostitute Christine Keeler led to a humiliating resignation. More recently Mark Oaten had to resign his position with the lib dems due to his alleged relationship with a rent boy.
Robert Baker, London, England
I thought we shouldn't discriminate against people because of their sexual preference?
Peter, London, UK
What century are we in? It's 2008 not 1908.
I m sure we all know people who have done similar or worse things and have not mentioned them.
We all need to stop being so judgmental. After all nobody is whiter than white.
He needs to try and save his marriage if he can and to do that he needs stability elsewhere. He may be a hypocrite but it shouldn't cost him his job. I suspect the pain of this is probably punishment enough for him.
Spitzer should stay in office.
Jonathan, London, England
What was he thinking? Apparently this has been going on for years. I don't know if his marriage can weather this storm, especially in light of the fact that he left a deposit for a future assignation.
This wouldn't be a career ender in certain other western nations, but the U.S. is still rather Puritanical about these matters and his political epitaphs are already being written.
Poor fool.
Carolyn Bongiorno, Glenham, NY U.S.A.
The front page of the New York Post was a picture of this dude, and a huge headline that read, "Ho No!" I can't stand puns, but I had to LOL
Karen Kraft, Santa Cruz, CA
Got nothing against sex. Got a big problem with hypocrites.
Furriskey, Singapore,
Democratic sleaze? What do you conservatives have against sex? Republican sleaze gets American soldiers killed.
David, Costa Mesa,
Good point Richard. Thank goodness the Republicans have no scandals with sex, drugs, infidelity, etc.
Joe, Ontario, Canada
It's not just Democratic sleaze, it's political sleaze. It's not restricted to the USA, and it's not restricted to party. Show me an honest politician and I'll show you a pig that can fly.
Paul Downes, Milton Keynes, Bucks
more Democratic slease so what's new
Richard K, Nottingham,