Hannah Strange and Philippe Naughton
Subscribe to The Times and The Sunday Times

Hillary Clinton conceded today that a rare moment of public emotion in a New Hampshire coffee shop had helped bring her back from the political dead.
The usually stoic former first lady said that the incident, in which she became teary as she discussed what drove her to keep fighting for the presidency, had afforded her a "connection" with New Hampshire voters that had propelled her to a 3 point victory in the state's primary over favourite Barack Obama.
“I had this incredible moment of connection with the voters of New Hampshire and they saw it and they heard it. And they gave me this incredible victory last night,” she said during an interview with CBS. Analysis of exit polls from New Hampshire showed that women voters, traditionally her most loyal supporters, flooded back after deserting her for Barack Obama in last week's Iowa caucuses. Mr Obama narrowly edged Mrs Clinton for the female vote in Iowa primary last week but yesterday she enjoyed a clear 13-point lead.
The critical moment came when Clinton was asked by how she kept going every day - "how do you keep so upbeat and so wonderful?"
“It’s not easy, and I could not do it if I just didn’t passionately believe it was the right thing to do,” she said, her voice catching. “This is very personal for me. It’s not just political. It’s not just public.”
Thirty-six years ago, the late Ed Muskie was widely reported to have wept while defending his wife from political attacks on the New Hampshire campaign trail, an incident seen as the moment when the Democrat's presidential campaign folded under pressure.
“This time, getting teary seemed to help, not doom a candidacy. A reverse Muskie moment,” the Chicago Tribune said in an analysis today. “Her narrow win was largely women’s work. She carried their votes decisively."
According to an MSNBC Democratic exit poll, women turned out to vote in greater numbers than men in New Hampshire. Fox News found that women voting Democrat preferred Mrs Clinton to Mr Obama by 47 to 34 per cent.
Stunned aides savouring Mrs Clinton’s victory credited the “humanising” effect of the coffee shop incident as well as her performance in Saturday’s candidate debate in which she passionately defended her own record in office against Mr Obama's "message of change".
“They watched that debate. I think they saw Hillary Clinton and she contrasted the records. And I think the humanising moment yesterday, I think that’s what did it,” the Clinton campaign chairman, Terry McAuliffe, told MSNBC.
Bill Clinton too credited the brief glimpse of his wife's vulnerable side for her unexpected win. "People saw who she was," he said.
Mrs Clinton's tough professional exterior has earned her a reputation in some quarters for being a cold and calculating politico, an image she has been trying to soften in recent weeks. At the Democratic debate in New Hampshire on Saturday, she revealed that she did not understand why she was not likeable and that it was a perception she found hurtful.
"Things started to change Saturday night at the debate," an ebullient Mr Clinton said. "And then she just went out and essentially gave her heart to the people of New Hampshire. She didn't ask me anything, talk about anything, say, 'Here's why I'm doing it', and they came back, they turned."
In a Fox News interview, Mr Obama put a brave face on his defeat, pointing that he had been trailing by as much as 20 points in New Hampshire as recently as two months ago and he remained in a strong position.
"This is a high-stakes election and I don't think voters are going to let any candidate take anything for granted," he said. "They want to lift the hood and kick the tyres."
Tabloids in New York, where Mrs Clinton serves as senator, plastered shots of her laughing face on the front page with headlines, 'Who’s Crying Now?' in the New York Daily News and, 'Back From the Dead' in the New York Post.
The former senator John Edwards, second in Iowa, finished third among Democrats, but vowed to stay in the race to the end.
In the Republican race, veteran campaigner Senator John McCain beat the former Massachusetts governor Mitt Romney as well as Mike Huckabee, the ordained Baptist who won in the Iowa caucus.
Mr McCain, 71, who spent nearly six years as a prisoner of war in Vietnam, led with 37 percent of the vote with most of the results in.
“My friends, you know, I’m past the age when I can claim the noun ’kid,’ no matter what adjective precedes it. But tonight, we sure showed them what a comeback looks like,” said Mr McCain, as supporters roared their approval, chanting “The Mac is Back".
The battle will be especially fierce among the Republicans in Michigan, where Mr Romney will be under intense pressure to pull off a surprise. Mr McCain won in Michigan during his failed presidential bid in 2000, but Mr Romney grew up there as the son of a former state governor, while Mr Huckabee will look to make inroads with the state’s evangelical Christians.
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Enjoy screenings of all the classic films you love, plus take advantage of two-for-one tickets
Times Online's new TV show helps you make the right decisions for your pet
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles


Overseas contacts and local business information

A treasure trove of baubles, booty and stylish quests

2007
£47,995
2008
£42,945
06/2006
£40,850
Great car insurance deals online
£33,000
Macmillan Cancer Support
Central/South West
£50k
NHS
Nationwide
£
£30k OTE
Meltwater News
Nationwide
circa £70k
Central Office of Information
London
Great Dubai Investment Opportunities
from £89,950
Luxury Appts, beautiful gardens w/ Thames views
Studios £33K, 1 Beds £60K, 2 beds £79K
Great Investment, River Views
New York Christmas Shopping
Christmas Cruises
From only £995pp
APTs East Coast now from only
£2425pp.
Great travel insurance deals online
Suggestions to the Clinton campaign:
1. She should have these humanizing moments before each primary/caucus.
2. Give specific examples of "35 years of national political experience". Some suggestions are (a) played a central role in the prevention/cure of [specify your choice of disease here], (b) played a central role in the restoration of peace/democracy in [specify your choice of country here]. Regarding the latter, I know Hillary has already claimed credit for peace in Ireland and Africa, but I think she should include the Middle East as well. May be Taiwan, too.
Bob, Denver, Co
What in the world is wrong with this country that its people would vote for a person to run the country and make the biggest choices in the name of the people. Are we so into who is most popular than who can do the job? beside being a very very very good motivational speaker, and I do believe that Obama is just that what does he really say. Hillary has the background and the smarts to do this job. Just because she is a very serious demeantor does not mean she is not the right person. So I ask only that each and everyone before casting your vote to ask one question. experence and toughness. or popularity hummm. then vote. Maybe someday popularity will be all that this country needs. But today my fellow americans is not that day. Would you hire someone that is popular or someone you know could do the job that you have that needs done? PLEASE THINK and don't waste your vote.
Teresa, Piqua, Ohio
Who wants a president who gets us into wars that we can't get out? Who, can't stop the September 11th tragedies and can't bring anyone to conviction over it? Can't fix the propblem in New Orleans and he should have cried then, it was sad! I would rather have a president who cries, but can get the job done, then have over the last 225 years of men who can't fix the problems in this country!
C Jenkins, chicago, il
An appeal to all US voters: try to look beyond gender, beyond tears, beyond racial biases. This is all a mere shell game. Presidents should be judged on merit, record of service, integrity, ability to negotiate consensus, savvy and skill to gauge the pulse of multiple, competing interests and steer a wise course on domestic and foreign fronts, and to take a stand away from popular opinion when needed. Stop the trial-by-popularity contest. Popular does not mean competent, and charismatic does not mean capable. It's demeaning to the essence of democracy and to each of you. Learn, listen and trust yourself. Your wiser than the media and pollsters.
L. McNulty, Vancouver, BC
I think the real reason Hillary won is because her campaign had been spreading rumors insinuating that Obama might be anti-choice (it was later proved he is pro-choice) and that fooled a lot of people in New Hampshire into voting for her.
Rosalind Lord, San Francisco, CA USA
But who wants a president who bursts into tears at the first summit?
John Ledbury, Kings Lynn, England
I think that Hilary Clinton is the most competant and capable candidate in the Americal Race for presidency. if America wants Change - they should recollect a tiem whan America was a leader in the world and respected during the Clinton Administation - of which I believe was successful beacuse of Hilary Clinton's input with Bill Clinton while he was president.
The American public should not be voting for "Change" for teh sake of change - but voting for the candidate who has vision and backbone and has a record of being able to make that happen. Hillary has forethought, realistic views and tough actionable plans with specific actions to cause a desired resulted and not just lofty goals. Remeber Hillary had fought to try and get your American System to provide Universal Health Care way back when Bill was president, and though it was never passed, what your American public wants now - she has teh smarts to try and achieve 8yrs ago. Vote Smart America - VOTE HILLARY!!!
PY Chan, Vancouver, BC, Canada
You Hillary supporters make me sick. I could care less if she cried or not, it is the "Principle" that she has to use phony emotion tactics to win the sympathy vote, and THAT is what I find to be pathetic, and you all were fooled. You say she has all this experience, so in this case I guess all first ladies could make good presidents because they were married to one. Mitt Romnney should be the next president. But then again, he has only run a state as governor and run successful businesses, but Hillary has more experience. What a joke.
Chris, Tampa, FL, USA
Several correspondents refer to Clinton's experience. What in, exactly? As far as I can recall, she undertook to revamp US healthcare during her husband's first term in office and failed. If the experience is in helping Bill Clinton to become president and being First Lady, then, with respect, it doesn't seem to be a very convincing argument for her (or Chelsea, or Bush's daughters, or Reagan's son, or any other erstwhile resident of the White House) being president.
Steve Evans, Hong Kong,
I am surprised how many people worry about having a US President who may (or may not) show genuine emotion but have no difficulty in electing a President who regularly (and with other world leaders - Mr Blair) prays for guidance before mounting invasions....
Dave Gordon, Edinburgh, UK
Errm, .....crocodile tears ? Acting ..... ?
If this is the reason how a candidate became elected makes American politics laughable.
Truly pathetic.
Steve, Rugby,
Real emotion, or fake emotion, Hillary is the candidate I will be voting for. She has real experience and therefore has a legitimate chance to make change. This is what people should be focusing on, not whether or not her eyes welling up was a sign that she was a softy.
Gabrielle , New York,
Perhaps those around the world dont realize that Hillary has a 50% negative in the democratic party. among independents and republicans, it is much higher. if the republicans nominate a moderate (or if an independent enters the race) she has no chance of winning. check out any of the liberal blog sites and you will see what i mean.
ps: the woman in NH who asked the question (that made Hillary teary) voted for Obama because she felt the whole thing was contrived. as soon as the cameras went off, she went right back to a policy wonk discussion like nothing had happened.
Xspotster, San Francisco,
Such hooey over an "emotional moment." Like the entire "race" for presidency is not an emotional decision? Please. Obama lacks experience but is quite gifted with speeches. A Clinton/Obama ticket would be something. Hillary Clinton understands politics because of her experience. How she will act once president, as any candidate would act, time will only tell. Any (democrat) is better that GW Bush - what an idiot. He is an embarrassment to the U.S. and to our allies (what few we may have left) around the world. Hillary is human like us all; her experience, however, sets her apart. We need a tremendous leader to pull us out of the abyss Bush has engineered. God bless all the candidates running, our allies, and everyone in the Middle East whom we have harmed. Prayers to all who have suffered because of Bush!
rs, Nashville, Tennessee USA
I feel that we should have a vote in the coming elections what with all the media coverage over here.
With the Clintons you'll have two presidents sitting in the white house, not sure if that is such a good thing.
Obama does seem to be a breath of fresh air, that is something different that your country and the world needs.
Kris, London,
America does not need nor want more years of controversial politics. Many of us still remember how the impeached President Clinton side tracked American progress with his unacceptable behavior.
We would only be in for more of the same if the Clintons were to re-enter the White House. We also must demand to see a detailed list of the changes Senator Clinton is claiming to have exacted during her "35 years" in power.
Senator Obama has done considerably more than Senator Clinton has, and all with less controversy. Barack Obama is ready to successfully lead this country. This fact must be communicated as clearly as possible in every venue, debate, conversation, meeting, and memo. There should be not one person left with a doubt about the strengths and capabilities of Senator Barack Obama.
Willie L. Perry, New York, NY
There were NO tears! She was just a little choked up. She was hated for being tough, now she's put down for being soft. Where is your sense of fairness in people? If someone is an image you hate or are jealous of, you just have to find some sort of excuse to justify the discrimination.
ZF, Wellington,
Hillary will win the primaries and the election. You all make very good point about a leader needing to have experience, but I don't think you understand how much more divided this country will be. Republicans will not work with her. They HATE her. Obama brings to the table a more centrist point of view. You should really take time to appriciate his speeches, because you may never hear anything of that caliber again. He's already said that this is a one time campaign, and I believe him, the timing is right and the people are ready. He will not have another chance to get as far as he is going to go. Can you imagine a Clinton-Obama ticket?! it would be a dream for the Democratic Party. Unfortunately this will not happen because of the Mudslinging done by both Bill and Hillary.
My Point?!
Congrats to the Clintons, but I fee bad for your party as you do not have anyone of Obama's caliber for years to come. The Republicans always have people waiting in the wings.
Allan, North Port , FL
The world needs an experienced US President Not someone who is spinning a fairy tale with the feel good magic. Americans have to realise that this is not just an American election, this is a Global Election. The world does not wish to waste another 8 years being led by a comedian. This time around the economic damage to America will be greater if a wrong leader is selected. China and Russia are looking to seize global leadership from the once all mighty America!
I am all for Hillary not because she is a democrat or a republican but because I think she is a smart women and America is crying out for a smart leader!
James Gill, Singapore, Singapore
If I'm expected to believe that Hillary won her lopsided victory over Obama (where the actual win, if you only include dem votes, was, I believe, in the order of 10 points) because she teared up a bit? Nonsense. It may have accounted for 1/2 point, maybe 1 point, but no more, of her win. Something's wrong with this picture. I would like to know how there could be such a huge difference between Hillary's vote in New Hampshire, and her vote in Iowa.
I would like to know, if the perception that she wouldn't be as able to defeat a republican in '08, as well as Obama could, came after, or before the media attack on her, followed by the starkly contrasting vote numbers we saw in Iowa compared with New Hampshire. This lady has gotten some brutal treatment by media and republicans, that should be investigated.
john polifronio, los angeles, calif
Dear Doreen from Jacksonville.
As far as it is nice you have such a high respect for us here in britain and the rest of the world, most the people i've spoken to about this are way more in favour of barack obama.
Hilary Clinton just seems like another two-faced politician who supported the war which sent thousands of ameicans and hundreds of thousands of iraqis to death.
Great improvement she would not be..
x
N Lampkins, London, uk
She didn't cry. Watch the footage. She had a somewhat soft moment and her voice faltered slightly, but there was no tear, no blubbering. The moment has been exaggerated in reports.
Her performance in the debate - where she successfully outlined her 35 years' experience making change - was likely a more significant factor in attracting votes than her "crying".
Jay, Sydney, Australia
She's too tough! She's too soft! Let's cut Hilary some slack and let her be human for a minute. It takes guts to be vulnerable - maybe we should congratulate her for being a little bit more like every one of us. Plus - if you're questioning how she would handle another 9/11. Personally, I would rather a President who cared enough to cry than to see another President read an upside down book.
J.L.M., San Jose, USA
Apparently N.H. voters decided to show their "independence" by both, purposefully voting against the polling leader (I would call this defiance and not independence) and voting out of sympathy for a candidate. Neither is condusive to freedom.
Richard, Richmond, VA, U.S.A.
As i said before, if Hillary Clinton gets in to white house, I am
sure she will help porest American, specially older generation,
Lacking health treatment, proper homes, free schools-in all-
USA-down south, full employment, better America for American
as a whole :Cllr Ken Tiwari (Oxford UK)
Cllr Ken Tiwari (Independent), Oxford, United Kingdom
I am worried how she can lead a country , when presidents need to take enormous risks and stress. I wouldn't want her to be crying for things.
sc, US,
It's about time we had a president in the US who not only shows their emotions, but actually has them!
Tim, washington, dc
As an American woman who had not quite made up her mind who to vote for, it was so refreshing to see these readers' comments! I agree that there is nothing our country needs more than someone who is intelligent, knows their way around the political workings of Washington as well as the rest of the world. We need someone who can help restore the respect around the world that George Bush has destroyed. And when I see that people in other countries, such as Britain, see those strengths in Hillary Clinton, it helped me decide who I will vote for in the Florida primary at the end of January.
Thank you for pushing me to the correct candidate!
Rock on Hillary!!!
Doreen, Jacksonville, Florida, USA
Mr Rodgers, don't be such a twit. She cried because she was feeling the strain and the pressure, it wasn't calculated. It was a spontaneous reaction to an emotionally provocative question
Greg, Oxford, United Kingdom
Lord help us if she gets in too emotional
Bob, cardiff,
This is one reason why Hillary Clinton should never be elected to the office of President. Do we really need a President who breaks down and has a good cry under pressure?
If she cries at such a minor event, what could America expect when she is really in the thick of it, up to her neck in alligators? Would she break down and cry?
Mark, Maidstone, UK
I think it was that planted placard 'IRON MY SHIRT' being held in the audience, which really brought the women out to vote. Nothing to do with the so called 'tears'
Arvin, London, GB
Hillaryâs tear moment and comments were choreographed by Bill. The words reminded me of Bills Monica denial which was carefully worded to lie to the public.
But, with that said, the female card worked for her. Anyone who thinks that Hillary is not acutely aware of the camera recording this tear moment for broadcast is clueless about the real world of politics. By the way, Hillary's bid for the White house is strictly built on the race card and the gender card and you will see this played out often in the coming months. She will either play the cards herself as with the tears or one of Bills operatives will get it out there. You donât have to believe me just watch it play out exactly as I have stated herein.
Bob Connors , Bridgeport, Ohio
Bob Connors, Bridgeport, Ohio
Absolutely classic! Someone shows they can't handle the pressure so the women of America vote for her to become president and have her finger on the nuclear button. Makes you wonder why women were ever given the vote doesn't it!
Bob Finbow, Haverhill, England
So there you go - a few tears and that's it. Really sophisticated electorate! The day Hillary Clinton liberates anybody hell will freeze over. (She only sings when she's winning and cries when she's losing).
Ian Burgess, Bristol,
I am glad that the American voters base their decisions on such rational factors...
Robert Miller, Halifax, NS, Canada
I don't buy this story. Instead, to me, it looks like the 'american people' got kicked in the teeth with election fraud.
Two things speak in favor of that assertion.
First, in NH counties where votes were hand counted, Obama won. Where the votes were counted by Diebold counting machines, Clinton won.
Second, the polls before the election were strongly in favor of Obama win and post-caucus, they turned out to be correct in all other aspects except Hillary/Obama angle, which the polls got badly wrong.
A hand recount of all votes would be in order to bring back some credibility to the process.
Thor Amudsen, London, UK
Hillary is the best candidate for job. She has all it takes. Ob would be an ideal running mate. Both would be unstoppable
Ob wouldbe ideal - but he lacks experience. Next time!!!
Andrew Lewis, Cardiff,
Who needs politics when it is the soap opera acting that will decide?
B Wood, London,
Remember the scene in 'Broadcast News' when William Hurt made himself tear up so as to appear more empathetic to his TV audience? Politics imitates art.
Carsten, Virginia, USA
Yeah, yeah, yeah. You know she was just putting on a crocodile-tears act to get more votes. Besides, she didn't even cry. She just got tears in her eyes.
And it worked. It was a brilliant strategic move on her part.
I'm no big fan of Hillary because she pretends to be against Bush's policies, but she really isn't. However, I find this whole thing tiresome. Before, right-wingers loved to vilify Hilary for being cold and calculating. They did it so obsessively it was almost as if they secretly had a crush on her.
Now the mainstream media is in hysterics because she dared to display some emotion. It's like no matter what she does, there will always be someone who complains about it.
Rosalind Lord, San Francisco, CA USA
So what happens when the next 911 incedent happens?
Does America have to wait while the lady president has a little weep in a quiet room?
Politics is a tough business. She may have won the sympathy of the voters in New Hampshire but turning on the waterworks but could she do the same with every other head of state in the world?
GJB, Slough, Berkshire
Wait, hold on a minute - she was asked "who does your hair"
Right before she welled up.
A far cry from "how do you keep so upbeat and wonderful"
I saw it on the news, and I heard it. The news anchors even commented on it, thinking the pressure was getting to her because such a silly question caused her to choke up.
What's going on? I personaly like hillary, but someone has changed the story.
Mike, Boston,
Hillary Clinton is an experienced politician. Barack Obama may be a good guy but he is inexperienced and, so far, no-one knows what he stands for, especially regarding foreign policy. It's all very well saying that troops must be brought back from Iraq but what about the global scene? Surely, logic must dictate that experience is all.
leila , manchester, uk
Women have got their way by crying for thousands of years - nothing new has happened here.
John Tomlinson, Brentwood, UK
Mrs Clinton used her teary moment to bolster her campaign and then twenty seconds later went on the offensive. She probably had a bag of onions hidden under the table.
Max Rodgers, Chicago, Illinois
As a citizen of the United States, I'd sure hate to have a President who cries because things get to be too hard.
Lizzie, Houston, Texas, U.S.A.
Well done, Hillary. She has more depth, character and experience than Sen Obama who calls for change without knowing how to put that change into effect. Ironically the best person to change anything is someone who knows how the old system works.
I knew Hillary would prosper when the voting came down to ordinary members of the public rather than political activists as it was in Iowa. She appeals to a broader section of society than Obama and having picked up 45% of registered Democrat votes as opposed to 34% for Barack, she only stands to gain in the coming weeks. If he plays to the African-American gallery he only stands to alienate white voters. If he tries to argue for change Hillary can still point to her record on effecting change. Obama would make a good VP and President in 2016 but for now he is no longer looking so watertight and Clinton can now consolidate her position. GOOD LUCK, HILLARY!
Louise Hartley, Reading, UK
Go Hillary win these primaries and then the White house the world needs an American president who is normal bright and intelligent !!
Go Hillary and bring back the honour that the U.S is lacking for so long.
David Shulman, Tel Aviv, Israel
Her narrow margin of victory in New Hampshire is hardly a mandate or convincing return to the lead.
It's troubling that someone vying for the most important job in this country would get a little weepy in public when things aren't going her way. Not inspiring.
James, Washington, DC
Well those of us outside the US of A who've been following the Presidential elections, feel that Hillary is cut for the job with her vast experience in this Circus called Politics.
Obama sure has Charisma, and the rhetoric he's built around his "Campaign of Change" well, cannot last long.
People of America are mature enough to realize that you don't need people giving you false hopes, just because you can make good speeches.
And maturity and experience does count in the long run.... which Clinton has and Obama doesn't.
Vivek, London, UK
Excellent, never mind their political message or ideas! All that matters is a brief trembling voice. My faith in the world is restored.
So these alleged women suddenly think, "Gee shucks, I guess she is affected by her emotions like everyone else! That's the most important issue to me, because it totally changes everything to the point I'd change my voting intentions!"
I'm sure no-one else in the race ever suffers from their emotions.
Just as well these elections don't have any significance, it's not like we could be potentially looking at the most powerful person by the end of the year, in a country burdened with Iraq and a potential looming recession. Oh, wait...
Ridiculous. And this is from someone who's quite a Hillary fan.
David Smith, Leicester, United Kingdom
Regardless of what, she has my vote 100%!!!
Her husband was a "great' President, for two terms. Many people loved Bill! He did a great job.
Hillary, has the experience in order to both do, and get the job done. As far as I'm concerned. She's strong willed, and she is determined to turn things around as they should be.
This is "not" the time to put a novice in the White House. We need someone with experience. Well, since Al Gore refuses to run. Than Hillary will do very nicely, thank you!
Hillary..."You go girl"!!! You have many supporters, world wide!
Tucker, Trenton, USA
Also, Hillary has Welsh blood - and proud of it. She would have my vote - if I had one!
Andrew Lewis, Cardiff,