Tim Reid in Washington
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes

Geraldine Ferraro, the former Democratic vice-presidential candidate, resigned last night from Hillary Clinton’s campaign after declaring that Barack Obama was successful only because he is a black man.
Ms Ferraro’s comments, which emerged on Monday, were condemned by Mr Obama and bought fresh charges of “insidious” tactics against the Clinton campaign by the Illinois senator’s chief adviser.
Ms Ferraro initially blamed the Obama campaign for stoking the controversy, an accusation that Mr Obama denied yesterday.
In her resignation letter to Mrs Clinton, she said: “The Obama campaign is attacking me to hurt you. I won’t let that happen.” She quit as a member of the former First Lady’s finance committee.
Ms Ferraro, the 1984 Democratic vice-presidential nominee, said of Mr Obama: “If Obama was a white man, he would not be in this position . . . He happens to be very lucky to be who he is.” Her resignation came on a day when Mrs Clinton demanded a rerun of the disputed primary contests in Florida and Michigan, part of a strategy to capture the Democratic nomination by belittling Mr Obama’s lead among elected delegates.
With only ten contests remaining in their battle, Mr Obama holds a near-insurmountable lead among elected delegates. It is an advantage that he increased on Tuesday night with his win in the Mississippi primary, where more than half of the electorate was black.
Neither candidate is likely to gain enough elected delegates to win the contest outright, however, and Mrs Clinton is locked in a struggle to convince uncommitted super-delegates that she has the greater claim to the nomination.
Central to diminishing the significance of Mr Obama’s elected delegate lead is agitating for a rerun in Michigan and Florida. They held primaries in January, and Mrs Clinton won both, but the results were nullified because the two states broke party rules by moving their election dates up the nominating calendar.
In Michigan Mr Obama was not even on the ballot and neither candidate campaigned in Florida.
The two states are big, key general election battlegrounds. Mrs Clinton is favoured to win both again if the contests were reheld.
If she also wins the next contest, in Pennsylvania on April 22, her aides believe that she has a powerful argument to make to super-delegates: that despite Mr Obama’s elected delegate lead, she has actually won many more big contests that will be crucial in the general election.
After an intensifying debate in recent days among the Democrat leadership and the two campaigns over what to do about Michigan and Florida, Mrs Clinton entered the fray: “In my view there are two options — honour the results or hold new primary elections.”
David Plouffe, Mr Obama’s campaign manager, called the demand “an increasingly desperate strategy for what they think can help them win the nomination”.
Democratic leaders want the issue resolved but are worried about a disputed vote in Florida deciding the contest, as in 2000.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
It is sad that in this Country it always has to be about race. White people not voting for Obama because he is "black". Wake up, technically he is not. People not voting for Hillary because she is a women. Give me a break. Shouldn't we be voting for who will make the best President. If everyone continues to make it about race and sex, the Democratic vote will be split and we could have another Republican as President for another 4 years. Can this Country really withstand that? Democrats need to stick together now more than ever. If your candidate does not get the nomination, SUPPORT the Democrat who does! And yes, sometimes I wonder, do we really live in a democracy? We should all be questioning that. If we did, would the popular vote not always win? Why do politicians have the right to vote for who they want? And what is up with Superdelegates? What about the American People's vote? That is what should count.
Wendy, NC, USA
I believe what Ms. Ferrarro said is very true. Could you imagine what Obama would be if he was white? The clintons could be down and dusted by now and the whole country would be waiting to mandate his presidency in november by a landslide. Remember the last time a 'white Obama' graced US politics?A certain John F. Kennedy?
Daniel Towett, Minneapolis, USA,MN
"if Jesse Jackson were not black, he wouldn't be in the race."
Yes, these are the same words used by Geraldine Ferraro on April 15th 1988 in the Washington Post. What does this say about Geraldine Ferraro?
Geoffrey McNab, Belfast,
It is the pinnacle of hypocrisy for Geralding Ferraro-Zaccaro to complain that the "race card" is being used to devalue her position. The race card has been one of her principal tools she has used in her political career, just as has been the "gender card". Her real complaint is that she is being hoisted on her own petard.
David, Covington, KY USA
The comments from Obama's spiritual mentor Rev. Jeremiah A. Wright Jr., a couple of months ago, asking for African Americans not to vote for Clinton, were not better.
I agree that Ms. Ferrero should have been more careful with her statements, but unfortunately, she is likely correct when she says that if Obama would be a woman (of any color) he wouldnât have a chance.
Hillary will be a great President, and I hope she wins!
Anne , LA, USA
Im tired of the injustice of this country. Its time people wake up and stop making excuses. Excuses are only for the people that make them. If u don't want me to vote for somebody, give me hardcore facts. Let who is without sin cast the first stone.
J'Maine, Clarksville, Tennessee
I suggest that Ms Ferraro is now protesting too much in attacking Obama for his defending himself regarding her comments. Unfortunately as a democrat I find her original statement and her follow-ups to be extremely distasteful and a poor reflection on the state of our party. I wonder what her response would have been if someone had correctly pointed out that Hillary Clinton would have been un-known but for the fact that she is married to Bill. She only obtained he position in the Arkansas legal firm because the firm wanted to get the inside track with Bill Clinton the Arkansas Governor.
Victor Marriott, Sarasota, FL
"If Jesse Jackson were not black, he wouldn't be in the race," she said.
Yup, the same Geraldine Ferraro in April 1988.
Geoffrey , Belfast,
Ferraro has a habit of making racial remarks; almost identically Ferraro said in 1988: "If Jesse Jackson were not black, he wouldn't be in the race"
With high-profile supporters like Ms Ferraro and the priapic Eliot Spitzer it is little wonder that the Clintonista campaign has crashed and burned. More slime to come no doubt but whichever way they slice 'n dice it Senator Obama has won. It is time for the DNC to step in and stop Clinton's scorched earth policy making the Democrats unelectable against McBush.
Robert, Mobile, Alabama
It really saddens me that a vote for one or the other candidate somehow "proves" you are either racist or sexist. As if there is any other motivation!
Ben Hoff, New Jersey, USA
Even if Obama is voted for by black people becasue he is black, so what?!! That's a good thing! A lot of people who would never vote are out there votting now, for whatever reason. That's great.
Bush's supporters voted for him because he has the same background as them, rich greedy and selfish.
Many of Clinton's supporters will vote for her becasue she is a women, and she does play that card. So what? This is all fair enough.
By the way Obama's speeches are the best I've heard in many years, by any politician, especially in the states.
TV, Lancs, UK
Her entire history until now is one of boredom and bungling and political failure, now she adds ugliness.
We've had touchiness in the press before over various remarks that really weren't racist, but Ferraro's remarks were genuinely racist.
And, like all racist remarks, they display hateful ignorance.
Who ever thought this person suitable for any office?
John Chuckman, toronto, Canada
Wasn't there an issue with counting ballots in Florida when Bush was elected? And now they spoil the Democratic selection process by moving their voting dates. How long are they going to be allowed to gerimander before being made to get their house in order?
Adam, London, UK
I had respected Ferraro in the past but now she has made herself look ridiculous and a fool. She is quoted now as saying that she is being attacked because she is 'white' and unapologetic.
People forget that Obama's mother was white but now he is considered a 'black' candidate. Keanu Reeves father was Chinese but he is never considered a 'Chinese' actor.
Obama is a deserving candidate because he has earned the respect and vote of the American public who decide, not on skin color (or half skin color), but on real honesty and integrity, something both Clintons will never have.
John T ex-pat, London,
There are two ways to campaign. Either leave race completely out of it, or include it and discuss it accurately.
The Obama camp does seem to allow race to be used to his advantage, ie, the virtue of electing the USA's first Black President. Therefore we may talk about it.
Obama is not "Black". He is Arab-Caucasian. genealogically
speaking, he is 50% Caucasian, 43.5% Arab, and 6.5%
"Black", which is below the legal limit for claiming minority
ethnicity.
So in the interests of accuracy, Obama supporters could claim
the virtue of electing our first Arab President.
Maybe race doesn't matter - but intentional and clever deception should matter.
Dave M, London, UK
I've never been a fan of Ferraro that is until this evening. She spoke the truth. And its damn unfortunate for America that expressing ones beliefs are labeled racist way before freedom of speech is considered. She is right!! The media is making Obama. Sadly its the same old story. Take New York's governorship. The story now isn't about who succeeds the present one...its all about the first NY "black" governor. Race even transcends the fact that he is legally blind. The real tragedy though is that blacks can say nearly everything they want about caucaisions in the media. But as soon as a white expresses an opinion they're denounced as rebel flag waving crackers bent on keeping the black man down. And the media lets them get away with it.
Murph, Madisonville, KY/USA
Does anyone else feel that there is some kind of irony in the argument from some in the USA that they are bringing 'democracy' to other parts of the world? When dynasties and superdelegates rule, where is democracy?
Steve, Preston,
Geraldine spoke truth. Why should she feel remorse for that. This is why politics is corrupt!!!!!!!!
ET, Montgomery, Illinois
Rules should not change. Obama has won more states bringing out the African American vote, which is very important., pulling Republican votes as well as Independent and white votes. Also, there simply is no money and no guarantee that mail-in and private contributors won't lead to fraud. Hillary has betrayed the people.
Sherae D White, South Boston, Virginia
I believe that if the shoe was on the other foot and Obama was in the position Hillary was in he would want the votes to count also. I think that if the money can be raised by private contributors then it should be raised and the primaries should be held again. Futhermore, if Obama had seen that Hillary still had her name on the ballot in Michigan and Florida then Obama should have made SURE!!! his name was on the ballot also....Even if the votes didn't count. My opinion, it is his fault he lost those votes...
Dwayne Willis, South Boston , Virginia
I think it's too late to do anything about Florida and Michigan now. There's no way we can count the votes already taken especially as Obama wasn't on the Michigan ballet. I also remember Hillary referring to a future victory in Florida shortly after losing Iowa so although she didn't campaign there, she certainly wasn't ignoring the state. A re-run of both votes is feasible but who would pay for this? I suspect that even if both ballets were held again it would make no difference and Obama's support in both states would be high making absolutely no difference to the final nationwide delegate count. Let's face it - Obama is the Democratic choice for President. He's played fairly, he has wider appeal and far less hatred directed to him, he's appealing to new voters and independents and he now has the support of more than half of the states of the United States (26) with 10 still to vote. Hillary would make a great President but Obama would make a greater President.
Tom Swade, UK,
I am surprised that Ferraro still cannot see that she sounds a lot like a modern day version of those folks in Mississippi who defended segratation in the 1960s. Bottom line here is that what she said is highly offensive, she needed to resign.
Also most people believe Ferraro was out there as part of the planned offensive behind the scenes by the Hillary team, that if true, is much more worrying because it means that the Clinton people will stop at nothing to win, even if it means using Machiavellian tactics and dividing the United States of America.
JP, Milano, Italia
Rules are rules and if the democratic party decided not to count the votes, than everyone should stand by those rules. Do not change the rules because things are not going your way. Stick to the rules and make your word your bond........
Wanda Vaughn, South Boston , Virginia
At last, we on this side of the Atlantic have something with as arcane a set of rules of Cricket - Democratic candidate selection. While I try to understand the whole concept of test matches, would someone in the UK try to explain to me the intricacies of this election muddle?
But wait, I am a sociologist by training (O, OK, college training but not university) and what I that training tells me is that this is not about rules, but about a Iron Law - the Iron Law of the Oligarchy: "those in the power elite will do anything to stay in power." The Clintons (bedfellows of the Bushes, family friends of the Bin Ladens), while not in office, are still part of the power elite. Obama is not.
Ah, I understand; now, if only I could only get our selection process to limited overs.
Rev Randolph Becker, Key West, Conch Republic
People in London must be sitting back and laughing at our juvenile-looking woes over spilt milk. Mrs. Clinton has taken the high road with her thought of fairness to the voters in the primary. We can see through this ploy and know that she is feeling the pressure of being behind Mr. Obama. She deserves credit for her attempt but she should not be taken too seriously by the party. The votes in Florida and Michigan should still not count.
Dennis Dawson, South Boston , Virginia
rules should be followed no matter what! if Hillary is going back on her word with this, how can I give her my vote? and trust her to be the next president of this great nation?!?! If she will go back on her word to get her way on this she will go back on her word when she is in the White House to get what is good for her not what is good for this country!
Rachel Blosser, South Boston , Virginia
Ferraro's resignation letter does NOTHING to correct her mistake. It only reinforces her firm racial discriminatory attitude towards colour. What a travesty!
Ajay Kansal, Glen Carbon, IL USA
Play by the rules. Michigan and Florida were decided ages ago and Clinton did not complain at the time. Too late now. How low can you go?
Phil, Hong Kong,
Let Florida and Michigan votes stand or revote
Linda Farmer, Mammoth Spring, USA AR.
The rules should go by what was addressed when the issue of the Michigan and Florida primaries were first addressed. Obama has a strong advantage over Hillary and she is getting scared. There aren't finances that are trust worthy nor reliable to fund the primaries to be redone. Simply put, things should be left to the set rules and not tampered with.
Gabrielle A Watkins, South Boston , Virginia
Don't recognize Michigan and Florida because they broke the rules and you alienate the people of Michigan and Florida.
Break the rules and recognize Michigan and Florida, and you alienate Democrats in the entire rest of the country.
Violate the rules in Michigan and Florida, and if Clinton wins the nomination as a result, Blacks just might sit out the election. Can Democrats win without the Black vote?
Arik Silverman, Milwaukee, USA
The Clintons in charge of a mail-in re-count. Who is going to oversee it-Jimmy Carter?
Desmond Taylor, Houston, Tx USA