Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes

Hillary Clinton will concede defeat finally tomorrow, congratulate Barack Obama and endorse him for president. But her rally in Washington, where thousands of supporters are expected to gather, is also intended as one last show of strength.
In a letter yesterday to many of those who backed her over the past six months, she said: “I have said throughout the campaign that I would strongly support Senator Obama if he were the Democratic Party’s nominee, and I intend to deliver on that promise. I will be speaking on Saturday about how together we can rally the party behind Senator Obama.”
The delayed endorsement — which ensures that Mrs Clinton will remain the centre of attention for the rest of the week — as well as her implication that she must play a pivotal role in uniting the party, continues to grate inside Mr Obama’s camp.
Both President Bush and the Republican nominee-elect, John McCain, have already congratulated Mr Obama on his victory. Mrs Clinton has not. Instead, she declared at a rally on Tuesday night that her 18 million-strong army of voters should be shown some respect.
During much of Wednesday there were still doubts about whether she would concede defeat at all as her campaign, even in its death throes, demonstrated the dysfunction that has characterised it for much of the past 16 months. Mark Penn, her former chief strategist, who is widely blamed for her many acts of self-destructive aggression, is understood to have urged her to “make Obama grovel”.
Geoff Garin, Mr Penn’s replacement, intervened to tell her that she risked damaging her own future — as well as Democratic hopes of retaking the White House in November — if she appeared ungracious.
A series of conference calls with her backers on Capitol Hill underlined how there was little appetite left for defiance, which, she was warned, was beginning to resemble a stubborn refusal to acknowledge reality. Almost two dozen members of the House of Representatives and eight senators are said to have told her bluntly to quit. “We pledged to support her to the end,” Charles Rangel, a senior black congressman from her home state of New York, said. “Our problem is not being able to determine when the hell the end is.”
Some staff members were in tears when she visited her campaign headquarters in Arlington, Virginia, on Wednesday to tell them not to bother coming to work after today. Others were yesterday said to be drawing “a huge sigh of relief”.
Mrs Clinton waited until Wednesday evening before announcing that she would concede, planning a rally initially for today before moving the date back 24 hours so that more of her supporters could attend. Mr Obama, who had spoken to her briefly by telephone earlier in the day, learnt of the decision through the media.
Yesterday sources indicated that she was unlikely to withdraw formally from the race. Instead, her favoured option is to suspend her campaign, allowing her to maintain control over her convention delegates and to continue to speak out on issues such as universal healthcare. It would also enable her to carry on raising money to pay off an estimated $21 million (£11 million) of campaign debt.
Mrs Clinton is said to have told friends that she wants a roll-call of delegates at the Democratic convention in August so that her daughter, Chelsea, can hear it. One party strategist yesterday voiced suspicions that her real motive was that she was “addicted to drama”.
Others believe that she is seeking to use her vast support — which, by some counts, is larger than that of Mr Obama — as leverage to force her way on to the ticket as the vice-presidential nominee.
Mr Obama’s aides are extremely reluctant to countenance such a prospect, suggesting that Mrs Clinton may overshadow him or undermine his message of changing Washington. There were also reports yesterday indicating that Bill Clinton's secretive post-White House financial deals would not pass muster in a vice-presidential vetting process.
However, some of Mrs Clinton’s supporters are pushing hard to get her the Number Two slot. Congresswomen Debbie Wasserman Schultz and Stephanie Tubbs Jones were yesterday among those demanding it.
Others say such efforts are unseemly or counter-productive. Yesterday, Mrs Clinton’s spokesman said: “She is not seeking the vice-presidency, and no one speaks for her, but her. The choice here is Senator Obama’s and his alone.”
As for Mr Obama, he says: “It’s very important for me to meet with and talk to her about how we move this party forward.” After fighting so hard and so long himself, he is aware that his rival may need a few days to come to terms with defeat.
Mrs Clinton is clearly proud of the way that she carried on until the bitter end — and proud of her supporters with whom she made a genuine connection in the latter stages of the campaign. But, as tomorrow will once again demonstrate, she has never really suffered from a deficit of pride.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Another point is that Hilary didn't get more votes than Obama, she only did if you inlclude the banned states like Florida, where Obama didn't campaign because it'd wouldn't count.
Clinton's campaign, disingenuous to the end..
Owen, London, UK
"Tough luck, Baby - Them there's the breaks! No hard feelings, OK Sweetheart?"
"Oh, Barack, you have a knack...Darling! I just love it when you talk dirty! Well...well..what's going to happen to me now? What am I going to do? I'm not nobody..I'M HILLARY CLINTON!"
"Frankly, my Dear...."
Garth Strong, Los Angeles, USA
Well of course the meeting was NOT held at Clinton's home - I wonder if Times Online would care to correct the erroneous headline? I mean, if you're going to report on another country's election process, you should try to get the details right.
Mark O, New York,
If Obama were to chose Hilary Clinton as his running mate I, a Democrate, would not vote for that ticket. I don't trust her or Bill and they would be a thorn in Obama's side. Please Mr Obama DON'T pick Hilary as a running mate. (Yes I am a female).
Laurie, Eugene, USA
I would have to say that I watch the campaigan from the start, Obama and Clinton both have good idea for the US and the world. suports from both camps need to look at first keep a cool head and stop the Republicans AND LET OBAMA PICK THE VP (Hillary or not)
Kevin, Saskatoon, Canada
James - the DNC and media did not pick Obama. Yes, she finished strong but not strong enough to make up for losing 11 in a row early on. And who's to blame for that? Not the DNC. Not the media. The blame rests with HRC and her campaign strategists, who did not know how to work the caucus states.
Mary, Chicago, USA
I blame Hillary for the misconception many of her supporters have about the nomination being "stolen" from her. First of all, the claim that she has more votes is bogus because she's not counting caucus states and IS counting states where Obama and she were NOT supposed to run. Only delegates count
jburke, Chicago, USA
There are positives and negatives about both campaigns. Democrats, disappointed Hillary didn't 'win', must look to their hearts before voting another Republican into office; too much damage has been done to the USA, its people, its image by the Bush administration. Vote your party not the person.
alice hudson, quimper, france
"Actions speak louder than words". What are the changes Obama will make? Be specific. And Hilary Clinton is knowledgable and experienced enough to carry out the changes. That'll be beneficial for the Democrats as well as the public. Otherwise, Hilary voters will either not to vote or vote agai
Phuong Nguyen, Houston, USA
In response to an earlier comment you don't need to worry about running Hillary supporters out of the party, we are already leaving in droves. We are not having a fit because our candidate didn't win but with the way the process went. The media, DNC, and party elite chose this nominee, i.e. FL 2000
James, NY,
Sen. Clinton as V.P. would be disastrous! She and Sen. Obama are ploar opposites. He stands for unity and respect. She stands for divisiveness and prejudice. She divided the Democrats by class, race and gender. The pathetic part is that she's not even good enough to help him win those votes bac
joe, Sioux Falls, USA
I can only hope that Obama realizes that chosing Senator Clinton as his running mate would not benefit him. Yes, she has many supporters, but having her on the ticket would get more Republicans to the polls to vote McCain than just about any issue you could name. The smart move would be John Edwards
Angelica, Portland, Maine, USA
And why do you think Obama is in it Geoff Butcher! Not for the good of his health! David of LA you got it so right. More people voted for Hillary which is what a lot on here forget! Obama needs her as VP. First black man as president and first woman as VP is a vote winner against McCain.
Kay, Islamabad,
Why is everyone surprised by the graceless behaviour of Mrs Clinton, i remember reading reports of the handover of the White House from the Clinton to the Bush administration and the farcical behaviour shown then. Of course no one likes to lose but it demonstrates her lack of substance as a leader.
Mike Thomas, London,
As Edward G. Robinson said in the "Cincinatti Kid"... See, As long as I'm around you'l always be second best, see kid!
Baja Joes, hanover,Ks, USA
As we have seen;
Hillary along with Millions of her supporters have been caught up in classic Freudian divorce transference with Obama (the one she did not have but always wanted with Billy), and now that she has decided NOT to live together -as husband and Veep- we now have the classic Freudian example of millions of women supportors jumping the first idiot man that happens along -Mc Cain- even though he would never measure up if the pink Freudian slips were in their right minds!
Jason, Redwood Valley, U.S.A.
If nothing else, surely he'd be undermining his own message of "change", were he to appoint her as VP?
Hassan Azam, Banbury , England
There is no metric that gives Senator Clinton a majority of the popular vote unless votes for Senator Obama in every Caucus State are uncounted. Make no mistake, he won the popular vote, pledged delegates, states and super delegates. To claim otherwise is just the usual Clinton smoke 'n mirrors.
Robert, Boca Grande, Florida
Hillary's ego is too big for number 2. There will be constant battles within government and Obama must know that.
Well done America for choosing Obama to bring some stability and diplomacy to this deteriorating world.
Let's pray that he becomes the first, historic black president of the USA
Mr Taz, Preston, UK
Are there no limits to what she would do for even a bit of power. If Obamas got any cigars....
john, Liverpool, U.K.
Well Larry, It's clear he never had your VOTE anyway - you know the real reasons why -no loss -
SoniaC , London, England
I don't think for one moment Clinton would be a running mate for Obama.
Those who have supported Clinton and now support or intend to support McCain have a lot to answer for especially to their conciences. Their treachery speaks for itself and they should be drummed out of the Democratic Party.
Rodney Barker, Gainsborough, Lincolnshire UK
i agree with Larry, I would only vote for him if he had her as VP, many others feel the same
Mike, London, UK
My UK POV- It is a shame that this presidential race seems to be solely concerned with personality of the candidates: How can Hillary supporters expect a democratic government if they don't vote in a democratic way- need to stop trying to make a vote 'count' and support policies over personality
Ashby Field, London, UK
I don`t think Obama will have Hillary as his running mate. The batte was fought,lost and won. Obama has no obligation to Hillary but it seems she and some of her advisers think she does. Echoes of the error of judgement that shaped her initial campaign strategy and consequently cost her the vote.
Abimbola Jackson, London, UK
Bilderberg Group.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bilderberg_Group
Take a look at where they are meeting this year. Just so happens Hillary and Obama are both meeting at the same place where the Bilderberg Group is.
Andrew, Katonah, USA
No! No! No! Obama should pick Nancy Pelosi. He Needs a lieutenant, not a marriage convienence.
Devin, Salt Lake city, USA
okay so i like the article and this has nothing to do with it's overall content, but you need to refer to them both as sen. obama and sen. clinton. they are elected officials and have earned their titles. by not doing so it almost makes the article seem biased, like your showing your distaste.
chase, chicago, US
Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton.
M A P, Rochester, Monroe
Michael is right. Hillary supporters wanting to vote McCain should do so with their wide eyes open & without holding their noses - for McCain is against a woman's right to choose! McCain will continue the war in Iraq, meaning many more American lives will be lost! This is not about Hillary anymore!
Jimmy C, Letchworth Garden City, UK
Well Hilary you gave them every chance to see what was happening.
Better luck next time good job done and thats what counts.
Mark my words, something smells wrong here the Democrats and the rest will live to regret this, like the UK and our fabulous NuLab
Keith, Oxford, UK
Hillary for VP? Talk about 5th columns!! No No and NO. Obama would be stark raving mad if he had her - and I don't for one moment believe that he is. Perhaps Minister for Health though even that leaves me very uncomfortable given her pathological need to be the star attraction of any show.
Paola, Milan, Italy
I hope these two can settle any lingering differences or agree to disagree. Obama/Clinton would certainly be a dream ticket. Those 18 million supporters for Hillary need to be retained. Without them his bold quest will be lost. without doubt.
V Cooper, Yeovil, UK
I love how some Hillary supporters are urging that everyone who voted for her should unite behind McCain. I'd love to be able to leave my ideological beliefs on the doorstep that easily. I think they forget that there are actually big differences between what the two candidates are proposing.
Michael , Kennington,
We were robbed of votes when Al Gore ran against Bush.That whole episode was a fiasco.Hillary remained committed to Americans and stayed the race until every state had their chance to vote and all votes were counted.She's shown exemplary strength of character and grace, very presidential qualities.
Dana, Riverside, CA, USA
Hillary Cling-on should sign up to be a contestant in the next series of the UK version of the fast degenerating "reality" show The Apprentice. She could play the baddie, and I reckon S'rallen would definitely hire her. He seems to favour cheats, liars, sob-story tellers and undermining backstabbers
christopher Icha, London, England
The Clintons, BIll and Hillary, should now be consigned as quickly as possible to the "ash heap of history"! Best place for them.
James Mason, Dubai, UAE
She wants a roll-call at the convention so that her daughter can hear it??? Her true colours are out folks! This was not about the American People - as Barack keeps saying - this is about the Clintons! And it will continue to be if she's made the VP running mate - which is why she shouldn't be!
Jimmy C, Letchworth Garden City, UK
Reading the Obama Hillary haters, it is easy to see why Obama will LOSE the race. Remember all you Hillary haters, she GOT MORE VOTES THAN OBAMA, you might not like it but the facts are the facts. His Hillary trashing by the Obama supporters will drive away her 18 M voters, LIKE ME.
LARRY , los angeles, usa
Jenny from Portland - do you mean to say the Clintons have had no shady connections in the past? You sure don't know your history, do you? Not to mention shady connections in the present - she may not be VP because Bill won't pass the vetting process due to his financial dealings.
Mary, Chicago, USA
"Yes that's true. None of her friend have been indicted and found guilty. I won't bother to mention any names."
Actually Jenny J, Portland that's not true; Norman Hsu and James McDougal are two indicted and convicted friends of Hilary just off the top of my head.
Jeff, Los Angeles, US
if "Hilary had won would there be any talk of Obama being the Vice President?"
Absolutely - a far stronger ticket - and he'd be a shoo in for his own White House in 2012 or 2016
malc, hong kong,
Hillary's supporters should unite NOW and and PROMISE to vote for McCain.
Remember, if McCain is the President, Hillary will be in a powerful cabinet position. She will implemrent what she stands for. McCain will support her.
We will never miss her leadership then.
PLEASE, Hillary Democrats, VOTE FOR MCCAIN, if you want Hillary in power.
Jkan, IA, USA
Geoff Butcher is right. When Hillary supporters finally wake up and see they are being used as a weapon (and nothing more) against Obama to seek her own political ambitions and stoke her big ego, they will flock to him like a magnet. Her supporters are being used -- big time.
Rachel, NYC, USA
Anybody (of the legal age and a natural-born citizen) is entitled to run for President of the United States. That included both Senators Clinton and Obama. To suggest that "he ruined it by running" is first a slap in the face of what a democracy is about. Anybody can run. He ruined nothing.
Christian Seaborn, Monrovia, United States
Obama/Hillary- Yikes!
Obama is a force of his own and his vp need to be honest and ready to change this country.
Public education reform should be a priority. What is the real purpose of the schools anyway? Answer to a bell, destroy any interest in thought, and be a good complacent citizen. Sad.
Karen, Factoryville,
First, She lies to her teeth about accomplishments. She changed the rules in the middle of the game when she learned she was behind. She also mismanaged her campaign. And now she is defiant and ungracious in defeat. She might as well be a Republican.
Noel, Burbank, CA, USA
David Cunard said "[Clinton] makes up for what [Obama] lacks...in experience".
I think that the experience Clintons brings is not as essential as Mr. Cunard says. There are others with plenty of experience, e.g. Joe Biden. At any rate, I don't think Clinton really has that much real experience.
Thomas Fee, Denver, USA
I disagree with David from LA. Obama with Clinton would be a disaster. She might help him get elected but we need ONE president and she could never play second fiddle. How can he do his job with both Clintons looking over his shoulder, jockeying for power? And the roll call is pure ego.
Mary, Chicago, USA
When Hillary was first elected to the Senate as the junior senator from New York, she was asked point blank if she ever would run for the Presidency. She replied with an emphatic, "I do not plan to seek that office." In other words, no.
Hillary prevaricates constantly. That's why no one trust her.
Dave, Phonenix, AZ, USA
I strgly disagree about the description of Hillary and her fight to the "bitter end,"no matter who says it or how it's said.It is not the end let alone the bitter end.Hillary was instrumental in spurring on voters who literally came out of the cracks to vote.Shes written a new chapter in history.
Dana, Riverside, CA, USA
Hilary is a very clever politician, never forget that. She knew weeks ago that she wasn't going to get nominated & that Obama wouldn't be strong enough to beat McCain. All she has been doing is strengthen her case for the democratic nomination the next time round! She sees the Clintons as a dynasty!
Andy, Buckden, UK
Geoff Butcher, Farnum, UK says it well. Hillary Clinton is in it for herself. She lacks the charisma. Her facial expressions, her smirks, and smug smiles should not be the characteristics of the world's most important chief executive. This Is a serious job, Where is her presidential demeanor???
Ed Brylawski, Milford PA, USA
Straight from the gut: I really liked her back when, but the more I saw how she operated, the less I liked her. Now, i actually can't stand to see or listen to her. Buh bye! Nice try.
mark G., whidbey island, usa
Hillary,
I supported your race from day one, and now, due to your delay in admitting the reality before in a timely, gracious manner, I severely regret that support.
How dare you act with such a since of entitlement, with such horrid self-interest, rather than act in the interest of the nation, and the party to which you are a member of.
You should be ashamed of yourself. If you are ever back on the national stage again, expect to see me rallying support against you.
Hermes Solomon, Pueblo, USA
Could not have said it better myself. Good show David!
Laura, Kentucky, USA
Unity in the Democratic Party? What unity? There was unity a year ago, then Obama destroyed that.
Oh, that's right. He "the uniter, not the divider." My bad.
Hey! Didn't GW Bush say that a couple of years ago? We all know how that went.
Jenny J, Portland, USA
Classy Obama he goes to her house so her supporters can get some face saving satisfaction
She will not be his running mate. Take that to the bank.
She is old Washington politics.
Shirley PettawayGreen, Tampa,
"...something about her personality that simply does not stack-up."
Yes that's true. None of her friend have been indicted and found guilty. I won't bother to mention any names.
Jenny J, Portland, USA
Hillary's "agression and defiance" has not only managed to hurt the democrats to the extent that the Republicans have real hopes of winning, when loss was a forgone conclusion. Worse, her negativity has destroyed the Clinton legacy that survived violent assaults from Newt Gingrich, Ken Starr & co
Gini Appu, Jambugasmulla, Sri Lanka
Here is a choice the media mongers have not considered: Perhaps she plans to run as an Independent?
It would certainly make for a very interesting election.
At this time it is really rather dull. Two candidates with unrealistic view of reality!
Jay Mason, New Brunswick, usa
Obama will not choose Hillary, nor should he. He will choose a white male w/ military and/or long-standing experience as an elected politician. Hillary adds nothing. Independents and moderate Republicans--Obamacans--hate her. Bill is a loose cannon. They have a fraud trial in Aug. Nope, won't happen
Dr. Bev, San Francisco, CA
Hillary might offer herself as John McCain's Vice Present. He certainly has turned herself into John McCain's biggest campaign asset.
Jules James, Seattle, USA
"Yesterday, Mrs Clintons spokesman said: She is not seeking the vice-presidency, and no one speaks for her, but her."
No one speaks for her...except her spokesman apparantly
David Pickford, Oxford, United Kingdom
This woman DESPERATELY wants the VP role. In case Obama or McCain mess-up as President and she nips in the back-door. Job done!
Do not trust Billary, there is something about her personality that simply does not stack-up
IPD, Leeds, UK
Mrs Clinton should be ashamed of her sleazy conduct during this campaign. Now, when she should be uniting the Party, her plan seems to be one of hobbling him (by claiming ill treatment) so that he cannot win against McCain. She will no doubt direct her supporters to vote their consciences; (wink).
Charles Murray, Toronto, Canada
Obama without Clinton will be a disaster; she makes up for what he lacks, both in experience and for attracting votes. 18 million of those can make the difference between winning and losing and four more years of Republican missteps. As for a roll call, all the better to show unity in the Party.
David Cunard, Los Angeles, United States
Hillary Clinton is not in the Presidential race for the American People nor for the Democratic Party. Hillary Clinton is in it for Hillary Clinton.
Geoff Butcher, Farnham, UK
Hilary had won would there be any talk of Obama being the Vice President?
patrick moore, tokyo, japan