Paul Kimmage
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
It was business as usual at the Eurosport studios on Friday when David Harmon went to work. The 13th stage of the Tour of Italy had taken the race into the Alps and Harmon had been on air for 90 minutes when he brought viewers the breaking news from Denmark. “The word we are getting over the head-phones is that Bjarne Riis [the Danish winner of the 1996 Tour de France] has admitted using EPO,” he announced.
Harmon, whose cheerleading style is much admired by fans, shares the microphone at Eurosport with Sean Kelly, an icon of the sport, but the former world No 1 seemed suddenly subdued. “The questions will come tumbling out now,” Harmon observed.
Kelly did not ask any. “I shall leave it up to you to draw your own conclusions,” Harmon said.
Kelly did not draw any. Harmon returned to the subject three times before the end of the broadcast, but on each occasion Kelly had nothing to say.
THIRTY years have passed since the 51-year-old Irishman left his father’s farm in Carrick-on-Suir for the bright lights of a professional cycling career. The Flandria team in Belgium was his apprenticeship; Freddy Maertens, Michel Pollentier and Marc Demeyer were the masters to be served. The code of silence was to be respected like a Bible. In the jungle, they played by different rules.
Maertens would test positive during Kelly’s first season; Pollentier would be stripped of the yellow jersey (for trying to cheat the doping control) during Kelly’s first Tour de France; Demeyer would die at 32 with a syringe in his arm. Kelly kept his head down and never told the tales. It wasn’t his style to go spitting in the soup. He would always adhere to the first rule of the peloton. But where does that leave you when the walls come tumbling down?
Like Berlin, nobody saw it coming. In July 2004 the walls had rarely seemed stronger. The Festina affair of 1998 had blown over; Lance Armstrong was winning his record sixth Tour de France; and Bjarne Riis was as far from unburdening his soul as it is possible to imagine. The 18th stage of the race was a 166km ride from Annemasse to Lons-le-Saunier. After 32km a six-man breakaway forged clear and were chased and caught by Filippo Simeoni and Armstrong.
Armstrong wasn’t a fan of the 32-year-old Italian (Simeoni had testified to Italian police that he had been given EPO and testosterone by Dr Michele Ferrari, one of Armstrong’s inner circle) and some heated words were exchanged as Simeoni was pressured to freewheel back to the pack, where he was abused by a number of riders.
“I was protecting the interests of the peloton,” Armstrong, who has never tested positive for performance-enhancing drugs, explained to reporters. “The other riders were very grateful . . . I followed Simeoni. He is not a rider the peloton wants to be in the front group. All he does is attack the peloton, says bad things about the other riders and group in general. When I came back I had a lot of people patting me on the back.”
Two days later, shortly after the start of the final stage to Paris, Simeoni attacked again. “He threatened to ruin my career,” Simeoni told L’Equipe, the French sports newspaper, “so I attacked to show that I wasn’t going to be intimidated by him. When I was caught, Armstrong organised a chorus with [Filippo] Pozzato, [Daniele] Nardello and others and they started abusing me, ‘Bastard! Bastard!’ They humiliated me.”
There was no action taken by the UCI, the sport’s global governing body, against those who had abused Simeoni. “Not even a warning,” Simeoni says, “that was the most disappointing thing, but I had some support.
The Italian federation sanctioned Pozzato, who had said I was a disgrace, that I had spat in the soup.”
Simeoni’s testimony against Ferrari (and admission that he had used EPO) cost him a six-month suspension, but no front-rank team offered him a job when it was served. “Sometimes I regretted having spoken because the omerta always wins out,” he says, “and sometimes I’m sure I did the right thing. I told the truth to a tribunal. But what did it bring me? I was marginalised and nothing changed. It just got worse.”
For two years the circus continued and we watched in disbelief until May 2006, when a huge crack appeared. A Spanish doctor, Eufemiano Fuentes, had been arrested in Madrid on suspicion of providing doping services to almost 50 riders. The investigation had uncovered evidence implicating Jan Ullrich, the winner of the 1997 Tour de France, and Ivan Basso, who won the 2006 Giro d’Italia, and a host of other big names. Ullrich and Basso and seven other leading riders were excluded from the Tour de France and there was the usual waffle about “new beginnings” when the race left Strasbourg. Enter Floyd Landis, the first winner in the history of the Tour to test positive. The sport had reached the abyss.
Questions were being asked of Basso. He lied. Questions were being asked of Basso’s manager, Riis. He lied. Questions were being asked of Landis. He directed us to his lawyers (he is now appealing his conviction in front of a tribunal in California). The stink was so bad that even the UCI was jumping. “When I came into this job I wanted to clean up cycling and I will clean up cycling,” Pat McQuaid, the new UCI president announced. It was hard not to laugh.
“The UCI deserve a golden ostrich award for hiding its head in the sand for so many years,” Christian Prudhomme, the director of the Tour de France, observed.
With sponsors withdrawing and the teams under pressure to respond, none responded more admirably than the German’s, T-Mobile. They sacked Ullrich, who still denies he ever took performance-enhancing drugs, and restructured the team’s management; Rolf Aldag, a former professional, would be the new team manager. Two doctors from the University of Fribourg, Lothar Heinrich and Andreas Schmid, would police the team’s strict new antidoping controls. But the problems were obvious. Hold a mirror to most of the top professional teams and the story is the same - former riders who move up to become managers or masseurs or mechanics. They all understand the rule of silence. They all understand how the game is played. Aldag had raced with the team in the 1990s; Heinrich and Schmid had also served the team during those years. How were they going to defend themselves if the shit hit the fan? They were prisoners of their past.
Last month, Der Spiegel published extracts of a new book by Jeff d’Hont, who had worked with the team (then called Telekom) as a masseur from 1992 to 1996. According to D’Hont, Ullrich had been given EPO injections by Schmid and Heinrich in 1996. He also claimed that Riis had used the drug. Schmid and Heinrich refuted the allegations. Riis also denied he had used the drug. T-Mobile announced an immediate investigation and the doctors were suspended.
Three weeks later, the walls started to crumble. In an interview with the ARD television network last Monday, Bert Dietz, who had raced with the team from 1994 to 1998, admitted that he had doped with the team and had been assisted by the doctors. On Tuesday, another former rider, Christian Henn, confirmed the allegations. On Wednesday, Aldag and Erik Zabel joined the list. A few hours later, Riis announced plans for a press conference in Copenhagen.
The game was up. He came out with his hands up, the first rider to admit having used performance-enhancing drugs while winning the Tour de France. “I have taken doping. I have taken EPO,” he said. “It was part of everyday life as a rider. My jersey is at home in a cardboard box. They are welcome to come and get it. I have my memories for myself. The time has come to put the cards on the table.”
Indeed, but how many of his fellow team directors will follow? And when will the UCI accept its responsibility for the mess? Ten years ago, after a major doping investigation in L’Equipe that featured several rider testimonies, Hein Verbruggen, the then UCI president, responded in the time-honoured tradition of those who enforce the omerta.
“I was not at all impressed, not at all, with the accounts given by riders like [Giles] and [Graham] Obree [the Scottish former world champion had told L’Equipe that he was giving up the sport because he couldn’t compete with riders who were using EPO]. What we are dealing with here is guys at the end of their career who can no longer hang on. I found it cowardly, there is no other word.” Verbruggen is still the UCI vice-president and the second most powerful man in the Olympic movement.
“What we have seen this week,” Prudhomme observed, “is the end of a hypocritical system put in place back in the 90s when a miserable cycling was run by Hein Verbruggen. Not only the riders have to pay for he doping culture that we have to get rid of; those at the command of the teams, whether they have cheated or not, have to pay as well. The wall of silence is not totally broken but the wall is crumbling.”
Hall of shame
- While Bjarne Riis is the first winner of the Tour de France to admit to illegal doping, last year’s winner, Floyd Landis, may be stripped of his title. In stage 17, the American produced an incredible performance during which he beat his rivals by nearly six minutes. Less than a week after being crowned as champion, it was announced that a sample he provided after the stage tested positive for incredibly high levels of testosterone. The B sample also tested positive. He is appealing against the decision in a tribunal in America
- Three race favourites were kicked out of the 2006 Tour de France before it even started - Ivan Basso, the 1997 winner Jan Ullrich and Francisco Mancebo were banned after being linked to a Spanish antidoping investigation
- Organisers of the 2006 Tour of California boasted that no riders tested positive for banned substances, but later admitted that nobody had been tested for EPO, the sport’s most abused drug
- Last week Riis’s teammates Erik Zabel and Rolf Aldag also confessed to using EPO
- The lowest point came in the 1998 race, when French antidoping police raided team hotels, entire teams left the race in disgrace and two sit-down strikes by protesting riders stopped the race entirely
Paul Kimmage was a professional cyclist before he turned to journalism, twice competing in the Tour de France. His book Rough Ride is widely acknowledged to be the most honest account of life in the professional ranks. He has been named Sports Interviewer of the Year at the past five Sports Journalists' Association awards.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Great stuff Kimmage, it's making a difference.
Bryan LONG, cork,
Good man Paul, tell it like it is......... it has been a long road 17 years.
Keaneo, Dublin,
Peter Kelly,
are you mad ?
I presume you are dusting off your shorts at the moment to cycle with another "legend" Sean Kelly.
Now there a coincidence, Mr Kelly from Waterford defends Mr Kelly from Waterford's cohorts.
The style and the motives of the author's articles do not deflect from the fact that his accusations are now being proved true on a daily basis.
Shame on you for criticising a man with the courage of his convictions, Bravo Mr Kimmage.
plaw999, Waterford, Ireland
Paul,
I read kimmages book first at age 15 and it left me completely disillusioned with those who I had idolised for years.
At 16, I quit cycling.
I am now 31 and returned to racing two years ago, I recently dusted off Pauls book and read it again. As an adult I am glad to say it offered a different perspective, not just on cycling but on the motives of an author who is just about to embark on a journalistic career for writing a book of this nature.
Doping is completely wrong but so were the style and motives for writing this book. Paul is far removed from the victimised altruist he portrays himself to be. Implicating people who have helped you during your career is ethically questionable also.
The negative tone and complete defeatist attitude of Kimmage does not fairly reflect all the positives of such a great sport.
If Paul Kimmage was the principled 'victim' he portrayed himself to be then why did he not donate the proceeds from his book towards the fight against doping?
Peter Kelly, Waterford, Irealnd
This is a long-time problem. Finally someone is doing something about drugs and not saying there going to do something about drugs in the peleton.
I raced in the early nineties as an elite level racer on both the road and Mtb. I never turned pro. Mainly because of injury. But there were racers that I crushed one year and the next they flew by me. Training wasn't what made them better. It was drugs and little or no doubt exists in my mind!
I read Paul Kimmage's book in 91 or 92 and I told myself that I would never dope. Also a factor, the group of riders that died of heart attacks, roughly about that time. Mainly from EPO, the doctors didn't know how to treat their "patients" yet.
In regards to amnesty, maybe but all should come clean and the tests should be foolproof. The Lands case seems to show a shoddy run lab facility. Reading the trancripts from the trial leads one to believe that even if he is guilty(Floyd) that sloppy lab workers will lead to a not guilty.
B-love, Denver , USA
Paul,
Nice article. I do have one issue with the article. Floyd Landis did not test positive for incredibly high levels of testosterone. In fact, his levels of testerone weren't even high, his Epitesterone to Testerone levels were high.
Do you believe anyone if the peloton is clean? As far as Landis goes, did you follow his case to see the case presented by USADA? If so, what did/do you think? There's a website that covered every day of the arbitration (http://trustbut.blogspot.com). The witness' for USADA were horrible.
You speak of an Omerta in the peloton, but what about the Omerta controlled by WADA?
Every rider is considered guilty now, is it possible that maybe one is innocent?
Mike, Mooresville,, NC, USA
http://blog.environmentalchemistry.com/2007/05/mainstream-media-where-are-your-science.html
Mike, Mooresville,, NC, USA
Paul is evidently correct, however the current process of "witch hunting" (Guilty until proven innocent) is even more imoral, damaging and wrong than the doping itself.
Landis needs to win his case for this reason alone.
Athletes must be held innocent until proven guilty - and the incrimintaion process must be foolproof -yet not run by fools. The current process fails on every one of those points.
I'd like to here paul's views on Greg Lemond. Greg is attacking all other athletes - but surely his 3 wins of the TDF must mean that he is not above suspicion himself. On theother hand - if he is clear, then he is living proof that you can be the very best without drugs - so why does he try to put down all the other champions?
Ian Beveridge, Aime, France
Seems like there is more spit than soup, and if it comes out that legends of Kellys' standing have been having us off all these years, it will be too unpalatable for many cycling fans to bear. I know of one guy not too far from here who decided long before his first child was born that if it was a boy he would be called Sean, if it were a girl - Kelly. It was a boy. Maybe we've all been watching a circus all these years.
Benny Andrews, Liverpool,
Not true about Landis: "Less than a week after being crowned as champion, it was announced that a sample he provided after the stage tested positive for incredibly high levels of testosterone".
Landis had a high T/E ratio. He had a low level of epitestosterone, not a high level of testosterone. That's supposed to indicate, indirectly, that you've been using testosterone. But his actual levels of testosterone were normal.
hughw, Austin, TX/USA
Paul Kimmage:
I read your book (Rough Ride) in 1991 and was convinced you were the True Hero of professional cycling. You column last year about the Tour de France was awesome! As far as I am concerned you are the only journalist qualified to cover the Tour de France and I hope that you will continue to do so in the future. There is an audience out here for the unvarnished truth!
I know it has been a long sixteen years for you after publication of "Rough Ride" but please hold on! Everything you have ever said is beginning to come true!!!
The only time I will ever believe cycling is a clean sport is when I hear it from the lips of Paul Kimmage. Until then the television remains off and my subscriptions to the cycling journals remain non-renewed.
Keep going Paul Kimmage! The job is almost finished !!!
splitwheels, New York , USA
Very good article, and you have pinpointed the problem with the cycling establishment, many problems in this wonderful sport have been created by the UCI and Verbruggen in particular. His nickname is "Mr.Verbuggeritup". He does not know the adage "If it aint broke, don't mess with it" The new head of the UCI Pat McQuaid has a good reputation but he still has HV on his shoulder and things won't be sorted until he high tails it out of the sty, but this won't happen because the feeding trough is too tempting.
Chrissie, Ashford, Kent
well said paul
not many people dare to bring kelly into this mess
but we know there are many like him
if only more clean riders spoke out !
hopefully with cav etc theres a new begining
riders like yourself and boardman where unfortunately born too early
good luck with your writing
duff fawcett, liverpool,
For football fans out there who are reading this thinking cycling is full of drugs, it may be of interest to know Sepp Blatter has requested (only 1 year after the affair came to light) information about footballers use of Dr Fuentes (who also said when originally arrested that he treated athletes, tennis stars and footballers as well as cyclists). Will we see similar investigations in football and other sports?
Steve, Notts,
As usual with Kimmage he is so ready to point the finger at Cycling and drug abuse. What about the wall of silence that seem to protect the Footballers, Tennis players and athletes allegedly involved in Operation Puerto - along with the majority of the British press, not a word.
Cycling once again is being hung out to dry while the 'mainstream' high profile sports act as though they are whiter than white.
Eric Farquharson, Walton-on-Thames, Surrey, UK
When will Nike's lance Armstrong brand fold?
Selling $300 Nike sneakers and expensive chemo therapy drugs for Bristol Meyers Squib breeds tremendous brand loyalty and fancy denials.
In any case, FIFA, tennis, NFL & Olympics are wholly doped out too, and nobody is trashing those marketing business models.
They all dope. All sports, all positions. The top athletes get the best doping protocols, marketing cover and assistance.
The media loves it! Fans won't boycott doping!
Thomas More, Santa Babara, USA, California