Rod Liddle
Win tickets to the ultimate village fete with welly wanging and more
WE HAD Andy D’Urso down the Den the other week, reprising his familiar and much-loved impersonation of Helen Keller. Few referees possess the talent of D’Urso to bring rival players, fans and managers together in absolute accord. Also, few referees are lucky enough to have websites devoted entirely to their weekly displays, upon which supporters of every club in the league put aside their differences and offer spirited encomiums. Check it out: Andy will be down your way sooner or later and you may subsequently feel the need to avail yourself of its therapeutic facilities.
Much though we moan, I’ve seen only a couple of truly bad referees in the past couple of years or so - D’Urso and a strange chap called Kevin Friend, who controlled proceedings in the manner of someone who has ingested huge quantities of LSD. And maybe some magic mushrooms. Other than that, there have been rogue bad decisions and inconsistencies but, by and large, the quality of refereeing has been of a markedly higher level than the quality of the football. This may not be saying much, but then I think the same is probably true of the Premier League. Yet each weekend referees emerge from their labours drenched in bile; subjected to continual aggression from players – especially players of the big four clubs – and suffering the outrageous contumely and spite of defeated managers. Later, on Match Of The Day, the ref will get a good kicking when the slow-motion replays from five or six different angles suggest he may have got a marginal offside decision wrong. How could he have missed that, Alan? Dunno, Gary, blind as a bat.
A couple of recent incidences concerning players – those sublimely gifted giants of the international stage, loveable Ashley Cole and John Terry – suggest that respect for referees has never been lower. First Ashley, distressed by a decision and perhaps also still smarting over the fact that Arsenal didn’t think he was worth £70,000 per week, turned his back on referee Mike Riley while being cautioned for an appalling foul. If I’d been Mr Riley, I think I’d have nutted Ashley between the eyes and then sent him off; but the refs put up with sub-adolescent petulance and aggression and rarely, if ever, complain about it. More telling was John Terry’s considered rationale about how to deal with refs. You shouldn’t spit at them or punch them or be rude to them, he conceded, but he did have the right to “discuss” decisions with them. No, mate, you don’t. You are not a delegate from the United Nations. There is nothing to discuss. You abide by the referee’s decision, shut your fat mouth and get on with the game. What’s to discuss? Decisions are not subject to negotiation, or should not be. It is time for Keith Hackett to get tough and instruct his team of referees to book players who challenge a decision, especially those who believe because of their magisterial qualities that they are justified in so doing.
And then there’s the managers. As Roy Keane has rightly pointed out, it is the most delicious hypocrisy of bosses such as Sir Alex Ferguson to demand that players show referees more respect when they themselves singularly fail to do so. Ferguson said last week that “the haranguing of referees is absolutely ridiculous”.
Yet a week or so earlier the same man had sprayed his foam-flecked invective over the referee, Martin Atkinson, and his boss, Hackett, when Manchester United lost at home to Portsmouth in the FA Cup. As the excellent Keane attested: “Man United always taught me to be gracious losers. They weren’t that day.” Keane, of course, was not always a loveable little monkey during his playing days, but his well-tempered and rational analysis each week during Sunderland’s struggle against relegation has done him an awful lot of credit. I don’t think I’ve heard him blame a referee once, yet he has probably had rather more occasion to than either Ferguson or that other serial whinger, Arsène Wenger.
There’s no question in my mind that some of the anger directed at the refs stems from deep-seated ambiguities over the rules of the game. The laws relating to what constitutes a handball, or dangerous play, for example, seem to vary wildly depending on where the offence has taken place. Since Fifa abolished the offence of “obstruction” and its consequent punishment, an indirect free kick, refs have struggled for consistency when doling out penalties. And of course, there’s the hilarious unlaw of offside, which nobody understands, least of all Fifa.
But these are not the main reasons that players no longer show referees the respect they deserve. The main reason is that the players are absolutely ghastly creatures, so full of themselves and of their own intimations of greatness that they are incapable of recognising an authority which surpasses their own. In short, it is another manifestation of the affliction that mars our national game and has left the national team a laughing stock. The adulation and the money warp their perception of themselves; they believe they are unchallengeable. It took David Bentley, who is rapidly becoming England’s most overrated player since Alan Smith, about five minutes after he replaced David Beckham against France last week to open his gob to the referee.
Bentley believes it is his right to do so. It’s about time we told him – and the rest of them – that it isn’t.

Rod Liddle is the most controversial commentator on sport in the British media. Previously the editor of BBC Radio 4’s Today programme and now a columnist with The Spectator, he brings an often outrageous and always provocative fan's view to The Sunday Times every week
Follow our three athletes' progress in their preparations for the London Triathlon, and pick up training tips and more
Enjoy screenings of all the classic films you love, plus take advantage of two-for-one tickets
We explore leisure activities that are safe and suitable for all of the family
Times Online's new TV show helps you make the right decisions for your pet
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers

Find a course, arrange a game and save money


Will your team win their match this weekend?
2002/02
£59,995
The Midlands
F/1989
£36,000
Hollingworth At Ombersley
2007/57
£35,000
South East England
Great car insurance deals online
90K plus bonus plus options
Confidential
London
To £28k
Barclaycard
Various (outside London)
£
£40,000 - £50,000 + benefits
Lloyds Pharmacy
Coventry
£38k
Barclaycard
Various Locations
Live in One of London's Most Vibrant Areas
From £249,950
Beautiful Gardens w/ stunning Thames Views
Studios £33K, 1 Beds £60K, 2 beds £79K
Mortgages, bank acc & money transfers to help you buy abroad
Explore mystical Jordan
From £1030 for 7nts 4*
to USA's Most Cosmopolitan City; San Francisco!
£POA
Book Now for Winter 08/09 and Get 10% off!
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Search globrix.com to buy or rent UK property. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
"Birmingham player shoulder charges Sun Ji of Man city..... referee awards penalty to Birmingham!
tari, London, UK"
BUT NOTE THE REACTION OF THE PLAYER. No histrionics, to snarling and screaming at the referee, simply a disbelieving smile and a shrug of amazement to his manager on the bench. I support City and was gutted by the decision, but delighted by the response of Sun Jihai.
I wish more would respond in that way.
dominic, Teddington, Middlesex, UK
...and so are you
Tony, London, UK
Could of course just pay the referee's as much as the players or managers. Then they and we mightr have right to demand perfection. No that's wrong I am asumming that the managers and players don't make mistakes.
Terry, Alicante, Spain
Gregor - that's a fair point, I reckon.
rod liddle, marlborough, wilts
There is a simple solution. The sin bin, as in rugby union. People do pay good money to see the so-called "stars" of football and it is probably too harsh to send them off for questioning any decision. But mild dissent could be rewarded with 10 minutes kicking heels on the touchline and the chance for the opposition to take advantage. The irony, of course, is that in rugby union any dissent is dealt with immediately by referees (and team captains and colleagues) and is almost non-existent.
mike cresswell, London,
(Posted by Jasper)
In rugby, you question the ref once you get a warning (that's verbal not some worthless laminated piece of yellow card) the second time you spend 10 mins watching the game, enjoy!
(Posted by me)
In football, if you collect five yellow cards you receive a one match ban. If you collect two yellow cards in one game, you are sent off the field of play for the remainder of the match (two yellows in one match also carries the penalty of a one game ban).
How many of your all important verbal warnings does it take to get a one match ban in Rugby?
Or did you just think, 'worthless piece of laminated yellow card' sounded funky and clever?
Paul, Amsterdam,
All games should begin with the referee saying this to the players:
"Right lads, I won't tackle a defender, turn him and try to curl one into the top corner if you don't try to do my job. If you do, then all bets are off."
That would do one of two things:
Result in a football match in which the players shut up and got on with it, or result in a football match of great hilarity and huge ratings as referees saved the ball on the line, attempted to tackled Fabregas as he headed goalwards, or kicked the ball into the crowd to waste a few minutes.
Which is more likely?
Stephen McAlpine, Perth, Aus
Good piece by Liddle! Although, how come that players are so full of themselves, feeling so unchallengeable? How about admitting some of the guilt of your own side, the media, in hyping up this sport for the very same reason that Ferguson and Wenger et al are playing their hypocritical games: money. I suppose that would be too much for the other people with the big egos in the business, yourselves! Don`t expect this to be put on the net, but there is always hope. Prove me wrong, you champions of free speech!
Gregor Wessels, Nishihara Town, Japan, Okinawa
Bottom line is that football is far too large a component in British culture and media. When a large proportion of British men want to be buried in the football strip of the team they support, you know this is no longer a nation of shopkeepers, but of spectators. Presupposing they go to Heaven (unlikely), do you suppose they are using the Pearly Gates as goal posts?
Andrew Milner, Karuizawa, Japan Alps
Rod Liddle is a class act - and dare anyone think of suing him!
Let them try.
Hugh Futcher, London, UK
The opposite is true. Time to take the referee's personality out of the game. No one pays money to watch them, yet their need to impose what they see as "authority" on the people who we do pay to watch effectively cheats the viewer when a contest is ruined by an "attitude" sending off or a frenzy of card flashing. Steve Bennett's pompous body language (ditto many others) always creates fear for the result. That shouldn't be. The fact that I know his name is the problem. Have two or three faceless referees and rotate them during the game. We must also have video refereeing and bombard a match with technology to take out cheats and errors. Try turning your back on a faceless video ref in the gantry Ashley. Why is it football is so luddite? Out with the Blatters and the Plattinis, bring on the 21st Century and say goodbye to the personality ref. Better still make them all women. Hard to square up to them and still be macho.
Ray Beaton, Hong Kong,
- 1
- 2
Next