Richard Hobson
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
Peter Moores has questioned the role of the stump microphone to relay information from the field to television screens after the confrontational second npower Test between England and India. The England head coach and team director also tried to draw a line under the jellybean incident, saying: “It had no meaning whatsoever.”
Even the ICC, the sport’s earnest governing body, joined in the mickey-taking yesterday by releasing its latest player rankings under the headline “Sweet success for Zaheer”, while suggesting that “Vaughan’s continuing resurgence sugar-coats England’s loss”. Clearly, Trent Bridge will not be remembered for swing bowling.
By highlighting the role of what is an aid to broadcasting, Moores risks being accused of diverting attention from the behaviour of his team – in other words, of trying to shoot the messenger. Against that, he is following others in wondering if the microphone is too intrusive.
In January, Herschelle Gibbs was suspended after a racist comment made at the crease about Pakistan supporters was overheard, prompting Mickey Arthur, the South Africa coach, to criticise the system. Moores has adopted a milder tone and has not lodged any complaint.
One consequence is to debunk the myth that sledging is based on wit rather than what David Lloyd, the Sky commentator, described yesterday as “inane banter and claptrap”. The reason for Zaheer Khan’s anger four days ago may not have emerged but for the microphone that overheard talk about the sweets.
Defending the chatter in the field, Moores said: “There is an issue about whether the stump mike should be so loud because sport is a battle. There is no point making noise for noise’s sake, but we have talked about trying to get teams to appear to be more up for the challenge, so we are going to play with passion and commitment.
“The volume of the stump microphone has been a consideration. There have to be some things left on the field to be fair to the player so that he can play the game without worrying that everything he says will be relayed.”
An ICC regulation states: “The stump microphone must be off except when the batsman is taking guard at the start of his innings, as the bowler commences his run-up until the ball is hit or passes the bat and as the fielder launches his return throw until the ball reaches the keeper’s gloves, the fielder at the bowler’s end, or hits the stumps.”
Shane Warne, the former Australia leg spinner, has said that comments are made in mid-pitch or at the end of an over when the microphone is off, while Alec Stewart, the former England wicketkeeper and captain, went the other way during a bitter one-day game against Sri Lanka in Adelaide in 1999. Almost leaning into the stump, he told Arjuna Ranatunga and the world: “Your behaviour is appalling for a country captain.”
On Sunday, the jellybeans were placed on the pitch while Andrew Strauss stood in temporary charge, with Michael Vaughan off the field. Asked if what Vaughan called a prank could equally be termed as childish or puerile, Moores said: “They are your words. I do not want to focus on it.
“Nobody would argue that a couple of lads put a couple of jellybeans down there. It was meant to be a joke and now looks a bit silly. I think people will try and read things into it, but it has no meaning whatsoever.”
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Well said Steve Baldrock (and father). You speak for all of us. Not Matt Prior, Vaughan or any of the "pranksters".
Pete, London,
If players behave corrrectly, than it doesnt matter what is in the stumps. Mr. Moores the onus is on you to get players to behave like gentleman, like the game once was
Hank van Essen, Harbord, Australia
The nonsense served up by Prior and others would not be allowed on the tennis court. It would not be allowed on the golf course. It is not allowed in American Football, basketball or baseball.
It would even bring a warning from the referee in the boxing ring.
For some unknown reason cricket tolerates what these other sports do not. It is time the umpires were allowed, and encouraged, to stamp it out.
Roger Tilbury, Worthing, England
In the absence of a trophy for contests between India and England, a la the Ashes, perhaps the boards should be instituting a jar of jelly beans for the eventual victor.
What a trophy to fight for! Imagine Dravid holding up a magnum of jelly beans after this series concludes. The TV networks would also welcome the telegenic potential of the victor showering his team with multi coloured beans.
Rajan Iyer, Melbourne, Australia
Is Peter Moores just trying to prevent the indespicable words his lads keep sledging with? If its just harmless banter then what is he afraid of?
Looks like he has just admitted openly " Look my lads want to keep saying those bad words which I do not want children back home to listen. But I would not do anything to stop that. But you should mute that mike."
ILoveCricket, Bradford, UK
This is really an overreaction. The jelly beans are so insignificant compared to the actions of the indian bowler and batsmen. To deliberatly barge someone, or aim the ball at a batsmens head or wave your bat at someone are the matters that we should be reading about not the fact that a couple of sweets may or may not have been placed on the pitch. Sledging has been part of cricket for a long long time ask the aussies and south africans. Get over this
Michael, Poole, Dorset,
This shows ICC and its match officials are fully controlled by England. Just like UN being controlled by America. I bet, it same behaviors and jelly joke was done by an Asian team or Australia, the same English officials and ICC gang would rape opposition for pitch altering and other out of world allegation.
Officials like Moore deserve to be out of cricket. He will hurt cricket in long term.
Question is also on Asian fielders for being soft. In this case, Sreesanth apologize in media twiceâ¦for what? Zaheer and Dravid not complaining to ICC. No matter what happensâ¦Indian players will show that they are soft.
Nick Peter, USA,
English cricket at the top level has gone downhill ever since the Atherton "dirt in the pocket" incident and cheating now seems to be part of the game. Pity that Mr Moores didn't condemn it out of hand.
I hope the microphones are left on all the time and the volume turned up so that we can hear what the cheats have to say. Maybe they will keep a little quieter then.
Keith Fletcher, Chesham, England
England coch Peter Moores should fired by ECB for making such comments about 'Sledging'. It is very difficlt to undertand his rational how this helps the Gentelman's game in white Cricket?
These are different times than Midevel times of the past. This kind of Childish tactics by English players and coaching staff does not help the game Cricket.
G2m, San Jose, USA
The sort of sledging and constant chat which Matt Prior and his kind exemplify ought to have no place in any form of cricket, Test or otherwise. However, the reason we have to witness such behaviour - and what an appalling example it is - is because Cricket's governing bodies, and I include the MCC in this, have failed to take a proper lead in the matter. Players must be told what is and what is not acceptable, and those who overstep the mark must be severely punished. Otherwise, the lowest common denominator will apply, as in football and much of modern life, and we will be left with a game which true lovers of cricket will want no part of. The MCC are supposed to espouse the 'spirit of cricket'. The sort of sledging we hear about in the modern game is well outside that spirit, and it's about time the authorities displayed some strong leadership.
Colin Smith, London,
Dan, no-one's suggesting we need to be "chummy" with the opposition. However infantile behaviour like throwing sweets on the wicket is unnecessary and infantile. We only need to look to the 2005 Ashes to see a great contest between 2 closely matched sides, played with maximum passion and commitment without anyone demeaning themselves in this fashion.
Genuine aggression and menace in a battle (think Donald vs Atherton or Flintoff vs Ponting) makes for a captiviating contest and some of the best cricket I can remember. Behaviour like this only serve to embarrass the players concerned and by extension the country itself.
Ed Duncan, London,
I have read that teams seek the 'mental disintegration' of opponents. Ideally this disintegration comes from superior performance - but also includes inane remarks. (Do you remember "Sticks and Stones may break my bones, but harsh words never will")
Now we apparently have hit a new low with arificicial aids ( jelly beans) being used/. What other aids will England now use to seek the mental disintegration of opponents?
Concentrate on bowling, batting and fielding so that oppponents expect to be beaten - that is when real mental disintegration takes place
Wessex Man, Taunton,
Instead of dealing with the disgraceful 'over the top' behaviour of the players he attacks the stump microphone...that says it all as to the society we live in. Cricket used to be a game for decent people - not now of course we are in the 'new age 'of uneducated riff-raff both on and off the field.
Next time you are out on a golf course try coughing whilst your opponent is on his backswing - you wont be invited again that's a promise. Just try cheating at golf -this is a simple an example but watch the behaviour of these professional sportsmen or snooker players who call their own fouls nobody in those governing bodies will protect cheats.
victor cowen, Malaga, Spain
100% right Steve.
Perhaps The Times could let us all know which one of the chavs who represent England drives the Porsche Carrera?
ManchesterO, Manchester, UK
Since this is done by English player you may call it childish. However, if this had been done by opposing team what would you have called it as -- "Doctoring the pitch to its favour". The ruling of third umpire needs to be verified if this is in order? The game is played by seniors with resposibility and such prankish attitude can not be exonerated.
S.K.S, Morden, Surrey, U.K.
At last it is clear why Moore got the job. His ability as a " chirping" coach clearly gave him the edge over other candidates. He's now reinforcing that reputation by condoning the yobbish behaviour of his players. He' has obviously forgotten Denis Healy's "law of holes", namely, when you're in one, stop digging.
Bina, Worcester Park, Surrey
If there is no meaning to the "incident", why did it occur in the first place? If you want to be chummy with the opposition in the international arena I suggest you find alternative sports to play.
Dan Avey, Reading, Berkshire
I play for a village team and on Saturday I shall go out to bat in the sunshine, I shall be seen with a smile by those driving past the ground, my turn at the crease shall be an antidote to my week in the office and it shall be part of an afternoon spent with friends in a gentle celebration of one of England's most traditional pastimes. I shall get to the crease and some 16 year old wicket keeper will start sledging me.
Matt Prior....you and your shameful kind are responsible for this. You may play for England, but you do not represent me or the game of cricket I and millions of others love.
My father was right when he taught me that winning without dignity is not winning.
Steve Baldock, Handcross, England