Martin Samuel at Villa Park
2 for 1 tickets to Singin' In The Rain, this coming Monday. Book now

The sing-along for the travelling fans before the game proved eerily appropriate. Chelsea Dagger by The Fratellis got the vistors going. By the end, however, speculation surrounded the likelihood of one being planted between the shoulder blades of José Mourinho, if he fails to improve on this.
Roman Abramovich does not say much. Yesterday he did not need to. His exit two minutes from time after Gabriel Agbonlahor put the match beyond Chelsea’s reach was a speech in itself. Face like thunder, Abramovich headed for the exit as his team limped towards journey’s end behind him, pausing only to give the most cursory handshake of congratulation to Doug Ellis, the former Aston Villa chairman.
The official explanation was that he had gone down to the dressing-room to see the players, but that is a strange one. Did he not think they were still going to be there five minutes after the final whistle? Why the rush? Already rumours have circulated that he is unhappy with the thrill factor of Chelsea’s play this season — hence his stalking of Ronaldinho — but until now he has at least been unable to question the return. This was quite different, though. Lousy football is one thing; lousy losing football quite another.
This is to take nothing from Aston Villa, who were worth their win, whatever the bizarre protests of Chelsea’s manager. If anything, Villa played Chelsea at their game, looking like Mourinho’s championship vintage team from two seasons ago, with pace on the flanks, energy in the heart of midfield, solid defence and a bruising battering ram of a striker.
Ashley Young marked his call-up to the England squad with an outstanding performance but it was John Carew, in the role of Didier Drogba, that left Chelsea’s defence uncommonly rattled. John Terry had terrible problems with him early on, while debutant Alex looked worryingly short of the combative qualities that are essential for Premier League success. In many ways, this is mitigation for Mourinho. It is hard to blame him for Chelsea’s failings, when so many of his judgment calls are being proven right.
He was believed to be resistant to the purchase of Alex last season, considering him short of the level required, and Juliano Belletti was not his first-choice right back, coming into the picture only when the move for Daniel Alves had collapsed. On both men, his instincts appear correct. Neither Alex nor Belletti impressed on their debuts.
Unlike Villa’s new signing Zat Knight, scorer of the first goal after 47 minutes. His header from Gareth Barry’s corner, which eluded Petr Cech and Ashley Cole on the goalline, revealed just how vulnerable Chelsea can be when challenged. They demonstrated a damning absence of invention when asked to chase the game.
Mourinho tried all his tricks, throwing on Joe Cole, Claudio Pizarro and Salomon Kalou and even ordering Terry to go up front but to no avail. By the time Joe Cole hit a post with a shot from the left it was deep in injury time and Chelsea needed two goals for a point, not one.
Chelsea’s problem was a surfeit of scufflers: John Obi Mikel, Claude Makelele and Michael Essien all deployed. Without Frank Lampard there was no goal threat from central midfield, Drogba had one of his petulant afternoons while Florent Malouda was largely anonymous and Shaun Wright-Phillips lively but overanxious in front of goal. The upshot was that Chelsea, for all their possession, did not look like scoring. Villa, by contrast, were counterattacking chaos on toast.
While Carew battered the defence black and blue, Agbonlahor and Young wreaked havoc down the flanks and Luke Moore was tireless in support. Often, Chelsea’s centre halves had no answer to the physical challenge of Carew other than crude attempts to manhandle him, much to Martin O’Neill’s frustration. It could be argued that Villa rode their luck when Martin Laursen made a similarly clumsy effort to stop Wright-Phillips in the second minute and was fortunate not to concede a penalty, but Chelsea more than got their own back as Villa pressed on.
Alex never gained composure but even Terry looked uncomfortable. His fitness is still an issue and neither centre half was anywhere near a cross by Young in the 45th minute, which Ashley Cole cleared from his goalline under pressure from Moore.
Ultimately, Young got his reward as the architect of the opening goal. It was his shot from 20 yards, tipped over by Cech, that won Villa’s corner from which Knight scored.
A late second on the counter was always likely. It was rather a splendid one, though, Young bursting down the left flank and whipping in a cross that was rewarded by a first-time finish from Agbonlahor.
The best result for Villa under O’Neill? Undoubtedly. As for Chelsea, they are two points worse off than at the same stage last season when the grapevine began humming with news of Abramovich’s dissatisfaction. Yesterday, though, the empty seat said it all.
How they rated
Aston Villa 2 Knight 47, Agbonlahor 88
4-4-2 S Carson 7 O Mellberg 7 Z Knight 7 M Laursen 6 W Bouma 7 G Agbonlahor Y 7 N Reo-Coker Y 7 G Barry Y 7 A Young 8 J Carew Y 7 L Moore 7 Substitutes S Petrov (for Moore, 79min) Not used S Taylor, M Harewood, C Gardner, S Maloney
Chelsea 0
4-4-2 P Cech 7 J Belletti 5 Alex 4 J Terry 6 A Cole 6 M Essien 6 C Makelele 6 J O Mikel 5 F Malouda 5 D Drogba Y 5 S Wright-Phillips 6 Substitutes Kalou 6 (for Makelele, 63min), Pizarro 6 (for Mikel, 52), J Cole 6 (for Wright-Phillips, 63) Not used C Cudicini, T Ben Haim
Referee: M Clattenburg
Attendance 37,714
Enjoy screenings of all the classic films you love, plus take advantage of two-for-one tickets
Have you ever dreamed of owning your own racehorse or a beautiful painting?
Enjoy comfort, safety, space and great design. Plus enter our great competition
Times Online's new TV show helps you make the right decisions for your pet
Are you California dreaming? Explore the wonders of the Golden State. Also enter our fantastic competition
Do you have what it takes to be a Times photographer?
Your brain is capable of more than you might think...
Find out to make the most of your money with our wealth management guides
Need help with your property? We have an entire how to guide - buying, selling, letting, moving, to help you
We are seeking entries for the inaugural Sunday Times Best Green Companies Awards
Enjoy some wonderful inspiring wildlife moments
An interactive preview of the brand new For Your Eyes Only exhibition

Love Sudoku? Play our brand new interactive game: with added functionality and daily prizes

Are you irritable when you return from work? Drained of emotion? You could be suffering from boreout
Prepare for some shock and awe, petrol lovers. Despite the greens trying to wipe it out, the car is about to offer us the most exciting year ever
We've trawled the brochures and websites to find this summer’s best holidays for every taste and budget

Find a course, arrange a game and save money

Will your team win their match this weekend?


Direct from the farms

in The Sunday Times, Times and Times Online
2007/07
£57,500
South East England
2007/07
£40,995
South East England
2006/06
£41,995
South East England
Great car insurance deals online
£40-55k+benefits+uncapped commission
Morgan Keating
South East
Up to £30,000
GLE
London
£
c£75,000 + executive benefits
Morgan Keating
London and South
Unpaid with travel expenses
Network Rail
Globrix, the property search engine
Visit Times Online Property for homes for sale or rent
Residential development site with planning permission
£1,500,000
Mortgages, bank accounts & money transfers to help you buy abroad
Dinarobin Hotel Golf & Spa 7 nights
From £1830 per person – saving £530.
Walking & multi-activity holidays in Cauterets. Stylish self-catering apartments.
From 350€ for 7 nights.
SAVE 25% on Sandals Luxury Resorts
Great travel insurance deals online
to the Liverpool man...playing well against sub-standard teams without your key men means nothing. If I'm not mistaken, it was Gerrard who saved your team against the very same Midlands club at Villa Park on the opening day of the season.
I think this report is a bit harsh on Chelsea to be honest. They were lost without Lampard, true, but only because Chelsea dont have creative midfielders. They have no nonsense ball winners, and a goalscorer (who was absent). It is equally arguable that had Villa been missing Gareth Barry or Ashley Young (our creative midfield men) we would not have stood a chance.
Benni, Birmingham, England
The rating of Laursen was questionable but other than that I felt Samuel's analysis was very accurate. Villa looked much the more enterprising going forward. "Counterattacking chaos on toast" indeed.
Rory, Leamington Spa,
Chelsea already have 2 points they stole at Liverpool after incompetent refereeing. They need to stop whingeing. They may have money, but can they buy success? Not in the long run.
Ralph Thackray, Grand Brassac, France
we didnt al together play well and certainly didnt deserve to win.but neither did we deserve to lose.its all about football and that is the beauty of the game.am glad manu is behind us
kayode ogundun, kano, Nigeria
First let me say that I'm both a Chelsea and a Martin Samuel fan. Then let me say that in this instance, I think Martin is a little guilty of simplifying the truth to make his story more compelling.
I refer specifically to his negative comments regarding Alex and Belletti. His match review suggests both had a torrid 90-minutes. 'Neither Alex nor Belletti impressed on their debuts.'
I must point out that this is not entirely the case - watching the first half live on Sky, I was impressed by both Alex's solidity, he dealt with Carew pretty well - coming out on top in most of their one-to-one situations - and was a threat at corners (and Chelsea had lots in the first half). Similarly, Belletti did well up against Moore in this half - and also pushed forward, putting in a couple of good crosses and winning some of those numerous corners.
Just to reinforce my case - checking the Sky commentary, even Andy Grey agreed with my analysis.
So come on Martin - a little more balance please.
Fraser Southey, London,
Mr Samuel was obviously watching a different match from me. Belletti and Alex both played well, especially Belletti, as he has often done when I have watched him play for Barcelona. And Shaun Wright Phillips was a real hand full. Much rather him than the pedestrian Beckham for England. Luke Young was good, too. I hope they both start for England. As for Carew, well he played a bit better than usual but was hardly a real threat. Tell me when and what chances he created , or converted. I am not a Chelsea fan - I am a gooner.
fred, st michel deuzet, france
Villa refused to concede one inch of the pitch to Chelsea and displayed the spirit for which Martin O'Neil's teams are renowned. Every player knew their role with forwards coming back to defend as required. In midfield Reo Coker and Barry were outstanding with Martin Laursen deservedly the man of the match.
What was disappointing was the unsporting manner of some of Chelsea's play. As England captain John Terry seems to believe he has the right to referee the game as well as play. His attitude incensed the Villa Park crowd earning him verbal sanction throughout the game. I suggest he concentrates on his play, he looked a very average player. In addition Drogba on two ocassions fouled Laursen and got away without sanction from the referee whereas any hint of a tackle on him saw him tumble to the ground in dramatic fashion.
Perhaps it was these features of Chelsea's play which saw Abramovich depart in haste leaving Randy Lerner to savour a well earned victory.
John Wgelan, Birmingham, Uk
Jose has to learn to talk not only lesser but also sensible. Like what Fergie says, he's got into a lot of trouble. Learn to admit mistakes, admit that you're not good enough or for the matter, your oppenents are better. He should keep his opinion to himself except his own team. I think the Blues fans are getting tired of him and that's really A SHAME!
Gregory, Singapore, Singapore
moho has lost the plot selling great players and buying saloons. my bet was that seven would take over, but im told he"s in line for an england recall with gaza.
michael joseph heavey, cahersiveen/adams town, madness
Laursen had a fantastic game, were you watching the same game as the rest of us.
maddog, Tamworth,
Did this reporter watch the match?????? Martin Laursen was outstanding and even by the Times' stingy player ratings he deserved an 8 or 9. He got the same rating as John Terry but was by far the better performer and help his team earn a cleansheet and 3 deserved points. To the reporter, try watching the match
Calvin , Southend,
Was martin samuel at this match???how he can rate Laursen as Villa's worst player is unbelievable
andy newman, derby,
Abramovich should do Chelsea and English football a favour and sack Mourinho.
See him off with a pat on the back for the good work done.
If not, he runs the risk of being a spectator to many more mediocre performences. Given the quality of the players, that is unacceptable.
He should then hire one of the most successful managers of our time: Fabio Capello. His track record is a guarantee for results, quality of play and professionalism.
Lawrence, London,
Chelsea lose Lampard or Terry with injury and they are nothing. Liverpool lose Carra and Gerrard and we still look as good as ever. Jamie and Steven put the icing on the cake!
Tony Bleasdale, Liverpool,
Villa played some good football but the new boys for the Blues
didnt quite cut the mustard and if you;re going to win the league you cant afford the luxury nof bedding players in.Still,care free.........
george baldwin, battersea, right state
To award the same mark to Juliano Belletti and Jon Obi Mikel is ridiculous. belletti looked comfortable and behaved with the essence of a honed premiership full back. Mikel's mark of five flatters him.
DG, York,
Villa looked brilliant on sunday, the main difference about us this season to as many seasons back as can remember is that even after 42 mins of pure pressure we didn't crack held our ground and even scored on a lovely counter and i don't care who you are and what stage the games at catching Chelsea on the break is hard. With Martin O'neil, Villa Park the signings the new facilitys the new chairman and the fan base we are a club in the up so all you so called big guns watch out the Villans are back in town.
Matthew Cobb, croydon, england
chelsea, come on..... ask more $$$$ from papa.....two players for each position, not enough....make it 3 or 4.......hahahaha
jeffery, brunei,
chelsea r the best
jack, tolox, malaga
I as a Chelsea fan think of it as only 1 point lost not 3, as we never win and always draw a Villa Park! We will still win the title when it all clicks together!
Russell, Fleet,