Graphic: how the shoot-out unfolded

Manchester United (4-4-2)

B Foster: Capable understudy for Edwin van der Sar but bit nervous on the big stage. Still learning his trade; will get better with experience … 7

Rafael Da Silva: Loves to roam forward but often pinned back by Steven Pienaar and best work done in defence. Still, big one for the future … 5

R Ferdinand: Strong as an ox in central defence as had been in Champions League win against Porto in midweek. Penalty miss marred assured display … 7

N Vidic: Partnership with Ferdinand is among the best in the business. Scored in the spot-kick shoot-out, too. Man of many talents …8

Fabio Da Silva: Like his brother, Rafael, steady rather than spectacular. A commentator’s nightmare when the twins are on the park together … 6

Park Ji Sung: Usually know what you’re going to get from the South Korean – industry and graft – and got it. Ran out of steam, though … 6

D Gibson: Rare chance for the Irishman to shine and kept it simple. Did not really impose himself; needs to show more self-belief in undoubted ability … 6

Anderson: Rewarded with start after impressive display in Portugal. Did not reach the same standard but not through the want of trying … 6

D Welbeck: Tricky, always threatening, but ultimately flattered to deceive. Should have earnt a penalty in regulation play when tripped by Phil Jagielka … 6

C Tevez: Moans about lack of opportunity but, when one comes along, didn’t take it. Ran around a lot yet ineffectively … 4