Kevin Eason
Win VIP tickets

Gerry Sutcliffe, the Sports Minister, has launched a withering attack on football’s finances in an attempt to save the game for ordinary fans, but he quickly ended up beating a retreat.
Sutcliffe, only three months into his job, had made an impact in a high-profile appearance in front of almost 300 leading opinion-formers by describing John Terry’s “£150,000-a-week” wages as “obscene” and warning clubs charging high ticket prices that they risked alienating ordinary fans. But his good intentions came with a lack of hard facts, the same fate that befell Richard Caborn, his predecessor. Caborn was struck down on a radio sports quiz in which he could not answer a single question; yesterday, Sutcliffe had all the right arguments but not necessarily with any of the right numbers to back them up.
Chelsea had borne the brunt of his attack as he questioned the club’s ability to sustain financial losses of £250 million. However, the club were demanding a retraction last night after pointing out that losses amounted to £80 million in their last year-end accounts and that the patronage of Roman Abramovich, their owner, meant that Chelsea were financially stable. Terry, the Chelsea and England captain, did not rise to the minister’s criticism but it is thought that his wages are closer to £130,000 a week.
After giving his opinions to the FT Sport Industry Summit in London, Sutcliffe then said he was off to deliver his views to Richard Scudamore, chief executive of the Premier League. But a Premier League spokesman said last night: “Yes, Mr Sutcliffe was here but I don’t think the issue was ever mentioned. It has all come as a bit of a surprise.”
Yet Sutcliffe’s criticism will find a place in the hearts of many supporters, who are suffering ticket prices spiralling to exorbitant levels and daily see their footballing heroes living out extravagant lifestyles by driving plush Bentleys and living in huge mansions, far removed from their own lives.
It was that well of disillusionment that Sutcliffe was trying to tap in to when he said: “Good luck to John Terry, but I think it is obscene to be on £150,000 a week. I understand that a footballer’s career is limited in time, but people in the street cannot understand salaries like that. Chelsea are £250 million in the red and they may be able to cope with that, but it’s not the real world – £250 million in the red is not sustainable.
“We can’t dictate what they do because the Premier League operates in a commercial marketplace. But there has to be a balance between the commercial aspects of the game and the needs of the ordinary fans, who are in danger of being alienated. It’s my job to be a critical friend and things have gone too far down the commercial road.”
Sutcliffe, born in Salford, sees the polar extremes of football as a Manchester United supporter but also a follower of Bradford City, as MP for Bradford South. He pointed out that United fans suffered a big hike in ticket prices this season while Bradford held season tickets to £138, guaranteeing attendances above 14,000 for each game.
“This year, Manchester United increased their season tickets by 13 per cent and said fans have to automatically buy European and Carling Cup games as well, and that costs an extra £200,” he said. “That’s taking the game away from the ordinary grass-roots supporter. Ordinary working people who want to go and see Manchester United face being priced out.
“There is a danger that there will be a move away from the game and we don’t want to be in a position where people are alienated. As Sports Minister, I am concerned for the grass roots of the game and the fans who have supported through the bad times as well as the good.”
Politician’s curve-ball
How many politicians does it take to make a complete Horlicks of the draw for the CIS Insurance Cup? If Alex Salmond, Scotland’s First Minister, and Alex Fergusson, Presiding Officer of the Scottish Parliament, are pulling the balls out of the bag, it would appear that the answer is two.
Salmond and Fergusson beamed with pride as they made the semi-final draw for the competition at the Scottish Parliament in Edinburgh yesterday. Heart of Midlothian would play Dundee United, Rangers would play Aberdeen, and that was that.
Backs were patted and everyone went home happy until the Scottish Football League announced at 6pm that there had been a terrible mistake. Aberdeen would actually play Dundee United and Rangers would take on Hearts.
The teams had been allocated numbers based on their final league positions last season, but rather than call the four-ball draw correctly, Fergusson had made an elementary mistake and announced the wrong teams.
“This was a genuine error and I can only apologise for the confusion caused,” Fergusson, a Conservative member of the Scottish Parliament since 2003, said. “We have worked as quickly as possible with the Scottish Football League to resolve the situation. As a lifelong Stranraer fan, I think everyone can be assured that there was no ulterior motive.”
— Words by Kaveh Solhekol
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Manchester United is currently playing Premier League home matches to full houses. If ticket prices are reduced to allow "ordinary working people" the opportunity to watch these matches at Old Trafford, on what basis will these cheaper tickets be sold ?
Will supporters be means tested, so that anyone earning more than £400 per week is excluded ?
Perhaps there will be special areas allocated for these "ordinary working people"... maybe a 'prawn sandwich' exclusion zone ?
Bill, London,
Unless Mr Sutcliffe wants to go and live in the Soviet Union - which surprise, surprise, does not exist any more, - then he will have to put up with the fact that in a free country you get paid what the market can bear. Labour says it wants a meritocracy (although I didn't see Peter Mandelson's or Charlie Faulkner's jobs advertised in the classified small adds) and that means the best in their field get to the top. And the wages you earn at the top are determined by market forces. Good luck (for that is what it is) to Terry, Rooney et al. They dragged themselves by their own hard work out and talent out of their previous existence. Thank God we live in a country where this can happen.
Bill, Bristol, UK
why is it always footballers that get stick for what they earnt? Someone like Paul McCartney earns far more than any footballer and all he did was write some songs and play a bit of bass etc (talented as he was). I don't begrudge his earnings, and i don't have a problem with what footballers earn either. If they have a salary cap then the rest of society should too.
Introduce a salary cap and see if the world's best players will still want to play in england for a tenth of the money they could earn in Span or Italy
Joe, London,
Gerry Sutcliffe is spot on!!! I really don't know how Alex Ferguson can try to defend uniteds season ticket prices!!!
The Premiership should put a cap on players wages as a proportion of income and give more of the income to grass roots football.
Henrymen, Manchester,
Dear Bishop,
If everyone followed football rather than religion what a safer and happier place the world would be. Thank God (sic.) for economics - think about it...
(Although Norwich supporters may have a valid contra argument for the happier point!)
Kelvin, London,
Bishop Dominic,
There are plenty of players earning far more than they can spend, ask them then for a contribution. They cannot possibly spend it all. And I suspect the vast majority will be Christian.
Generally, there are lots and lots of people that earn in excess of the John Terry wages. This is an issue about supply and demand. And at the moment the demand is there.
Simon, Ticehurst, UK
What scares me most about all this is how naive people are, at least judging by the views printed on this page.
Are the players' wages huge? Of course they are. Do they deserve it? Only one entity get to answer that and that is their employers. And there, the economics is simple - if the employer thinks the employees generate sufficient value, then he pays them accordingly. End of story.
Some are even suggesting this wealth should be distributed more fairly!! Interestingly, this system is called 'socialism' and was once used in Soviet Union. It failed.
Finally, there is something particularly annoying about the government and the church complaining about taking money away from the 'man in the street'. The former has spent billions on destroying Iraq alone and the latter has been taking from the 'man in the street' for centuries. I really don't wish to be preached on this issue by either.
Steve, London,
I guess it's a matter of scale.
I would no doubt be disgusted with the amount of Gerry Sutcliffe's expenses?
Bill Bird, Wallasey, Wirral
Footballers should only earn £47.63 per week. esp. Arsenal.
Dan, Chigwell,
'people at the bottom struggle on £200, while footballers get £100k, therefore we live in a sick society', says Keith Fletcher.
Reading to this, you'd think their respective salaries were decided by lottery!!
So, what is the right society? The one where we take from people who have made major sacrifices and worked incredibly hard to become the best in the world in the their chosen profession and give it to those who didn't (and, in a lot of cases, didn't even try)?
Does this sound like a fair society? Not to me, Keith, not to me.
Whether you like it or not, those players on 100k per week are a key part of one of the most successfull commercial organisations in the world and get paid a lot as a result. Those on £200 per week aren't, so they don't get paid a lot.
Sounds fair to me.
Mark Stevens, London,
Football as a sport disappeared a long time ago. It is a global business and so long as people are prepared to pay ridiculous prices to watch pretty boring stuff on occasions, the few young men advertising their sponsor's products will continue to be overpaid, especially when the British Government allows people like Abramovitch to stay in the country throwing around billions of rubles, which I believe really belong to the Russian people.
Apart from the UK stadiums I have noticed from watching European games on TV that there are more and more empty
seats. Has football peaked, is it the cost, or is it the violence from mindless chanting, "supporters"?
Supporters used to follow their team through thick and thin. Today's "Supporters" are a fickle bunch following the most fashionable club. Shirt buying Kids are being ripped off as their favourite players switch allegiance in order to fill the offshore bank accounts of agents in the global market
which is what the game has become.
peter fieldman, paris, france
101 economics class, the demand for Terry's skills determines his wages. The premiership is watched by 160 million people, and all of them pay, directly or indirectly to watch these footballers. The players earn the wages they get. That is the law of demand!
mukwaya, clemson, usa
Just half of one weeks wages of one premiership player (not even a top one) would cover all the required work on my church building. Yes, the wages are obscene.
Bishop Dominic Stockford, Teddington, Middlesex
It's no wonder Bradford City can afford to only charge £138 for a season ticket, £6 a game, when they charged me £20 to watch Darlington there 3 weeks ago. And they ran out of food before half time.
Andy, Darlington,
No condoning the level of wages any football receives as we don't know the full facts.
However its hypocritical coming from somone in government with the billions being syphoned from the lottery fund for the Olympics. Anyone checking where the £9bn is going?
Jay, Berkshire, England
When the people at the bottom struggle to earn £200 a week and survive whilst soccer players get over £100000 a week we are surely living in a sick society. Peace and harmony won't come until we have a fairer and more equal world.
Keith Fletcher, Chesham, Bucks
So, Simon, it's alright for politicians to let rip, without the politicians even bothering to check their facts? So opposition politicians can claim that everybody is out of work, just because there are people out of work?
No wonder politicians lie continually; there's always somebody supporting them.
cotumely, london,
I'm an American that took a tour expecting to see Sheffield United at Manchester United and unexpectantlly got to see the 7-1 drubbing of Roma. Didn't even have tickets until I arrived in Manchester. Not a bad deal. Bottom line is they still sell out the stadium so as a business owner, you have to look at maximizing profits. The prices suck but I'd pay it again when I come back. Go ManU!
Jarrod McConnell, Evansville, IN, USA
totally agree with the minister......hard facts or not
simon, las palmas, sppain
Soccer is such a dud game in any case who really cares.
Ross Hall, Canberra, Australia