For a player that made so few starts and scored so few goals last season 6 million is a good price for Spurs. Allied to that the fact that Mido has played for over 6 clubs in the last 6ish years - he is a risk at 6 million.

On ther hand similar things could have been said about Robbie Keans a few seasons ago - but now he's vrtually indespensible. I loke Mido, but on balance I think 6 million is good business for Spurs

Katjasdad, Wanganui, New Zealand

I don't think we ever saw the best of either player at Spurs. Mido, especially, started like a house on fire with two goals on debut but then struggled with weight and injuries. If he grows up quickly he could be a star. Ghaly will never be forgiven by Spurs fans for showing disrespect to the shirt, but he is a versatile, talented player with an eye for goal. I'd like to see them do well.

Shannon, Johannesburg, South Africa

Ghaly actually cost Spurs around £2.5 million, he was not a free transfer. Mido has been a good player for Spurs, I'll be sorry to see him go. He had a great first season with us but struggled with injuries last season. He will well at Birmingham, he always gives 100% and hes a good character. Ghaly is also a fairly good player, given a run he should do well.

Sam, Enfield, London