Graham Spiers
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
One of the striking aspects about last week’s announcement of a putative rebuilding of Ibrox Stadium by Rangers was the level of public scepticism towards Sir David Murray, the spinner-supreme of the Scottish game. Evidently, many fans these days take Murray’s public pronouncements on such matters with a pinch of salt.
In this particular case, this may or may not be fair, but the degree of public cynicism towards the Rangers owner is undeniable. It is a scepticism born of an increasing view that Murray for years has had too many principal players among the Scottish football press eating out of his hands.
Murray, I’ve always believed, is a most interesting man. In media circles the general rule of thumb is this: remain sweet about him in print, talk him up and generally support his public profile, and as a gratitude he’ll regularly tickle you with stories and titbits for your newspaper. For years any big “exclusive” stories about Rangers generally had Murray’s hand behind them. The sceptics in my business – the precious few, I might add – refer to it as “Winalot journalism”, likening it to pet dogs being plied with biscuits and pats on the head for good behaviour.
Murray is by no means alone in this exercise but he has had remarkable success at it. The high watermark of “Winalot journalism” during Murray’s time came when, with the financial mismanagement of Rangers having reached near-disastrous proportions with the club’s £80 million-plus debt, those who had to desperately scavenge around for themes for their sports columns somehow always managed to miss the obvious one: castigating Murray over the plight of Rangers. It was a taboo subject, because David might be annoyed.
It is in this context, as growing numbers of Rangers fans are now aware, that the latest grand plans for Ibrox must be considered. These plans may well be kosher but, as always, first there is Murray’s spin to hack your way through. Is this another “moonbeam” of Sir Minty Moonbeam fame? Is this yet another case of “for every fiver Celtic spend, we’ll spend a tenner” as the famous Murray proclamation went? Alas, we all know where that led Rangers.
Yet the thing that troubles me most of all about this potential Ibrox reconstruction is the idea that the stadium needs rebuilding or “modernising” at all. Why? It is a fantastic arena, a credit to Rangers and one marvelled at by many foreign players, fans and sportswriters when they come to Glasgow. Talk of Ibrox needing “modernising” seems senseless, given that the stadium is actually relatively new.
Yes, there is the issue of the arena’s capacity – 50,000 seats is maybe a touch on the modest side compared to Old Trafford, the Emirates or even Celtic Park – but surely this can be fixed without wholesale bulldozing? Certainly, if the virtual dismantling and rebuilding of Ibrox does proceed, it won’t be with Rangers’ money, because the club can’t afford it.
If Chelsea Village is the example Rangers want to follow, with hotels and retail outlets being built around their rebuilt stadium, then be warned. The London club suffered years of financial hassle due to their scheme, a headache that has largely been forgotten only through Roman Abramovich’s arrival. Chelsea, indeed, in their commercial flowering, were seen as having cruelly diminished their identity as a football club.
Football today needs income streams from any conceivable source – that is undeniable. Ibrox, though, is a fine stadium, which is hardly in need of bulldozing... unless someone, somewhere, has an ulterior motive.
Go on, give Mark the job
If you ask me, it is becoming increasingly obvious what should happen to the Scotland job. It should go to Mark McGhee, whom the SFA should appoint on a part-time basis until the summer, allowing him to both finish the season at Motherwell and then take up the reins in time for the first World Cup qualifiers in September.
Forget about his impressive demeanour, McGhee’s managerial credentials are there for all to see. At all his clubs – Reading, Leicester City, Wolves, Millwall, Brighton and now Motherwell – he has performed that mercurial goal of making teams better.
At three of those clubs – Reading, Millwall and Brighton – McGhee won championships, and Leicester went up to the Premiership months after he had been lured away to Wolves, whom he hoisted from 20th to the play-offs in his first full season.
Obviously, McGhee could not hope to win a title with Motherwell, but his ability cannot be doubted.
McGhee has one other quality for the Scotland job – far above Graeme Souness, Billy Davies or George Burley – which is this: given that the international job is now an ambassadorial role as well, you need someone of articulation and substance in charge. Amid the recent tragedy at Motherwell, surely no one now can doubt McGhee’s quality in this regard.
Gordon, listen to me, it’s a shoe-in!
Thanks for your enmity
Notwithstanding my own minor involvement in it, I thought one of the gems of the past literary sporting year in Scotland was the book, It’s Rangers For Me?, a collection of essays by those who either grew up with the club or at some point became a part of “the Rangers family”. The book is a gem because of the sheer range of voices – authors, academics, actors, company CEOs, fans, even the odd sportswriter – all of whom grew up supporting Rangers and who provide various insights on a great but troubled club.
This weekend It’s Rangers For Me? is being celebrated even more in certain circles after its publisher announced that the book has totally sold out, with a reprinted version shortly to be released.
More amusingly, I’m told the publicity for It’s Rangers For Me? appears to have been aided and abetted by an attempted boycott of the book by a website of hardcore Rangers fans, who have become famed for their paranoia, and who objected to the book on account of criticisms of their club within in.
As a book publisher, hardly for a first time, happily pronounced: “Thank goodness some people fail to understand that, for any book, there is no such thing as bad publicity.”
Fair shares for Willie
Was it just me, or is Willie Miller looking more and more like an ageing Inland Revenue inspector these days? Willie, it seems, is weary trying to make Aberdeen’s paltry bawbees add up. Meanwhile, the Dons chairman, Stewart Milne, is now said to have a £600m fortune. Give some of it to Willie, will you, Stewart?
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
"And all the talk of "spin" over the proposed Ibrox revamp is nonsense. Rangers very obviously didn't want the story to come out at this point and tried to damp it down by sticking a brief piece on their website on Saturday night.
Donald Cameron, Glasgow,"
How naive are you Donald? Do you really believe what you have written here?
Mike, Glasgow,
If Rangers didn`t want it to come out then how did it come into the public domain, i will tell you, because David Murray told his pals in the press. The reason for the brief piece issued was there are no details . It is mixture of smoking mirrors and complete lies.
Graham Lowrie, East Kilbride, South Lanarkshire
Well done Graham,a man without fear.
J, mwell,
"It's Rangers For Me"
oh wait, no it's not.
S Kholi, Glasgow,
No, Mark McGhee wouldn't be the first Scotland manager from a Catholic background. How about Tommy Docherty? And another conspiracy theory bites the dust.
And all the talk of "spin" over the proposed Ibrox revamp is nonsense. Rangers very obviously didn't want the story to come out at this point and tried to damp it down by sticking a brief piece on their website on Saturday night.
Donald Cameron, Glasgow,
Well done Graham selling out the first editions of "Itâs Rangers For Me?" I believe another 25 copies are to be printed.I will not be buying it yet ,at 25p a copy from Patricks Market it is far too expensive!!
Ian Anderson, Aberdeen, UK
Yes,nine paragraphs ,of going over old ground.
A late reaction,from someone as "offended",as your good self.
You started with a question,and ended,with no answers.
NINE paragraphs,of pish!!!
geo, greenock,
Does nobody but me and Sir David think that the Rangers re vamp and village is a great idea what with the commonwealth games coming to Glasgow, surely any outlay would be easily re-couped.
Hunter, kilwinning, Scotland
I would bet money on the Ibrox Stadium story being 100% true - that is the REAL story and not the one spun by those with an obvious anti-Rangers agenda. I would have thought a journalist who likes to show off his intelligence after a long session studying a thesaurus, and with a self proclaimed antipathy towards spin would have got to the truth...
The REAL story is that Rangers are planning to commission a feasibility study for finding the most cost effective way for increasing the stadium capacity. Obviously they will look at a range of options without automatically ruling out any - from increasing the stadium by a few thousand seats to a complete rebuild (a very unlikely scenario which just might end up being the best).
The £700M mentioned, would not be the cost of a new stadium either, but would be a total investment in the entire area, similar to the Chelsea Village mentioned in the article.
The REAL story is therefore eminently plausible and therefore the ridicule ill placed.
Callum Lester, Milton Keynes, UK
well said mr speirs you are a credit to journalism why cant people handle a bit of critism
danny murray , new london, connecticut/usa
It should absolutely *not* be McGhee, IMHO-- it would be scandalous to rob a team, currently playing some of the best football in Scotland, of their manager just six months after he arrived. Or do the SFA care more about the international team than the quality and level of competition in domestic football? Poaching McGhee, an ambitious man who would be unlikely to see out his contract as Scotland manager anyway, would be as bad for the domestic game right now as the Old Firm's tactic of buying up the other SPL clubs' best players and leaving them on the bench.
"Obviously, McGhee could not hope to win a title with Motherwell, but his ability cannot be doubted." So what could he be expected to win with Scotland? At the very least he has the potential to win cups and European places at Motherwell. With Scotland the best he can hope for is to retain the Kirin Cup.
Oh, and if you want articulate and ambassadorial, George Burley is every bit a match for McGhee on that front.
Numpty, Dublin, Ireland
Classic example of ignoring the big pink elephant in the corner of the room, and instead re-hashing the same old tired conspiracy theory accusations there Pearl, if you follow follow me! Nice work!
Mark, Glasgow, Scotland
What a pearl of wisdom from Mr Watson.
The truth hurts, doesnt it.
Stevie, Glasgow, uk
If appointed will Mark McGhee be the first Scotland manager from a Catholic background or will the spirit of Sir John Ure Primrose live on?
Jim Lister, Glasgow,
Shhh ! Graham , dont tell them anything ,You see the truth is Mr Murray is converting Ibrox into an Ark filling it two by two of animals of every kind ,then sailing the whole stinking wreck doon the water.You can swim but you cant hide1
Chris Lane , Arbroath,
Good article re the ibrox revamp. the chelsea warning si celar enough, you'd need pretty stable finances before you set out on such a scheme and I'd doubt Rangers are in that scenario right now. Sensible to question the motives and an excellent quick summary of the Rangers PR methodology.
As for the book, methinks the lady above is confused. Does she mean the cyber followers didn't herd like sheep behind the guys who saw red ( white and blue) at some of the criticisms within? But even then someone must have bought it to read to the others.
McTavish, Renfrew, UK
The Ibrox revamp story smacks of nothing more than a feeble attempt to try and get Celtic off the back page by Mr Moonbeam.
Remember the all seater stadium for reserve games Rangers were building? The Casino?
I can't wait to read about the next "Murray masterstroke"!!
Mark Smith, Glasgow,
Q. Whatâs real reason to rebuild Ibrox?
A. To sort out the drainage issues, obviously. Anyway, why rebuild when they can convert what used to be the trophy room into a pumping station? Maybe the water could be diverted to make a moat around 'Fortress Ibrox'.
John, Aberdeen, Scotland
Where I do not agree with everything Mr Spiers says I think you'll find alot of Rangers fans simply do not like the man as he is/was a fan who has hit home a few home truths regarding his/their club. His comments regarding Mr Murray and the Scottish media are spot on and many of my Rangers supporting friends agree with that. The mis-management of Rangers finances under his control has been criminal at times yet the criticism from the Scottish media minimal. Winalot journalism indeed.
James, Glasgow,
Great to finally see a piece of unbiased journalism. Keep up the good work Graham!
Peter Grant, Glasgow, Scotland
Moonbeams he may be, but if this is a smokescreen to stop our wrath, if mr smith does not get any transfer funds, no amount of spinning will stop the backlash.
Fraser Mcghee, Glasgow, Great Britan
What a 'Pearl' of wisdom that was, ha ha, in all the Graham Spiers articles I have read, I've never once seen his lips move!
Keep telling it like it is Spiersy, 'Sir Minty Moonbeams' can't be too pleased with this article, although as the publisher mentioned above, there is no such thing as publicity. Anyway, who would want to build a £700 billion stadium on a notorious flood plain? Land Ahoy!
John, Pointe Noire, The Congo