Graham Spiers
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
Mike McCurry, one of Scotland’s leading referees, was forced to admit yesterday that he got two key decisions wrong during the Rangers-Dundee United match at Ibrox on Saturday, a game that Rangers won 3-1.
McCurry, who made his admissions on the SFA’s official website, confessed that he should have awarded United a penalty after David Weir tripped Noel Hunt inside the box, and that he was also wrong to disallow Danny Swanson’s goal after 71 minutes with his side 2-0 down.
Craig Levein, the United manager, made one of the strongest attacks witnessed on a referee at the post-match press conference, claiming that McCurry was “weak” and that he had “bottled it” in front of a 50,000 Ibrox crowd. The 3-1 defeat ended United’s hopes of grabbing a Uefa Cup spot.
Levein spoke last night in response to McCurry’s statement and remained just as withering of the official. “It’s too late, the damage is done,” he said. “If Mike McCurry is supposed to be one of our top referees, he shouldn’t be making such blatant errors as he did. And they were absolutely blatant errors. Moreover, what concerns me is that you could never in your wildest dreams imagine such decisions going the other way against Rangers.”
McCurry apologised yesterday for his lapses, in a manner that some felt was humiliating for the match official.
“In the 55th minute of the match Rangers were in possession of the ball and attempted to clear it from their defensive area,” he said. “I started to run towards the halfway line, anticipating the ball being cleared, but the clearance was not successful and the ball struck Noel Hunt, who then chased the ball into the penalty area followed by David Weir.
“I was caught out of position and my line of sight was partially obstructed by another player. I saw Hunt fall to the ground with Weir in close proximity, but as my vantage point was extremely poor it was not possible for me to say if any infringement had occurred. Given this significant doubt in my mind, I had no option but to allow play to continue.
“I have now had the benefit of seeing the incident again on television. I believe that were it not for the fact that I had been caught out of position by the quick transfer of play, I would have awarded Dundee United a penalty and would have cautioned Weir.”
McCurry went on to explain why, with the help of his linesman, Stuart Macaulay, he also mistakenly chalked off Swanson’s goal, an act that caused Levein and the United bench to explode with fury.
“Danny Swanson shot towards the Rangers goal and the ball appeared to me to deflect off a Rangers player and enter the goal,” McCurry said. “As I turned to award a goal to Dundee United, it was brought to my attention that the stand-side assistant referee had his flag raised.
“I went across to the assistant referee and confirmed that he was signalling for offside. He confirmed me this was the case and informed me that a Dundee United player had been in an offside position and that he had played the ball prior to it entering the goal.
“I informed the assistant referee that it appeared to me that the ball was deflected off a Rangers player. The assistant referee told me that he had not seen it touch a Rangers player but had definitely seen it played by the Dundee United player, David Robertson.
“Given that Robertson was behind the Rangers player, my view was such that I could not tell if the ball had been played by Mr Robertson last before entering the goal. Consequently, I decided to accept the advice of my assistant referee.
“Again, having had the opportunity to review the incident on television, it is clear to me that the ball is not played by Robertson, who was, however, technically in an offside position. With the benefit of seeing the incident again, I consider it would have been more appropriate to conclude that the player, David Robertson, was not involved in active play, and I would have allowed the goal to stand.”
After his act of contrition, Gordon Smith, the SFA chief executive, leapt to McCurry’s defence in the face of some withering criticism.
“Michael McCurry has been a top-class referee for a number of years and has handled many a high-profile, high-pressure game, and to impinge on a man’s integrity in this way is extremely unfair,” Smith said.
“To suggest that there was any kind of agenda behind the decisions made on the day does a massive disservice to the game and is completely unfair.
“Football is a game played by people and people can make mistakes. It is always frustrating when decisions go against you, but this has been a part of football since the game started.
“We rely on our referees to make decisions in a split-second and without the benefit of countless replays. I think that it is extremely sad that an honest, dedicated professional has been treated in this way.”
Levein, however, dismissed Smith’s comments. “These remarks by Gordon Smith don’t surprise me in the slightest,” the United manager said. “At Ibrox on Saturday it was about a basic level of competence, and my club and my own livelihood have suffered as a consequence. But what will the SFA do about it? Absolutely bugger all, I can assure you.
“People have wanted me to say that I was deliberately cheated at Ibrox. Well, I haven’t said that. But I can tell you this, I felt as if I’ve been cheated.”
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
I am an Italian living in Scotland and after saturdays game I can only say that what happened in my country is happening here....Corruption.
Match fixing has tarnished my country's football and I know it has tarnished scottish football. I also think the SFA are a disgrace.
Luca, Edinburgh,
Thank you for highlighting this problem that every other member of the Scottish media ignore. The favouritism shown to Rangers by the authorities is endemic, part of Scotland's shame, and no-one seems brave enough to expose it
Alex, Hamilton,
Definitely there should be a full investigation including:
Zander Diamond's goal being chalked off.
Scott McDonald's offside goal against Rangers.
Samaras scoring against Motherwell when it wasn't a corner.
An absolute disgrace Scottish refereeing.
Scott, London,
Levein,I think,had had enough.To lose a cup final against Rangers,having been denied a stonewall penalty,then having the same thing happen again,in even more controversial circumstances,in a game that could have brought them a EUFA cup place,a player butted,players insulted because of race,??????
Raymac, Belfast, N.Ireland
Something in Scottish football stinks. I can smell it all the way in the USA.
Brett, Kansas, USA
Some of our commenters don't even read what McCurry said. Re the disallowed goal Levein himself, Eddie Thompson and Murdo McLeod all thought the ball went in off United's Robertson at first sight.
Gerry, Falkirk,
in the Liverpool game the Birmingham forward tried to put the Liverpool goalkeeper off whilst a direct free kick was taken by Birmingham.
He was not flagged for offside. Does Mr Mccurry not know the rules?
andy, hamilton, scotland
In my opinion it is more informative to see the mistakes made from the assistant referee's point of view. If Mike McCurry had such a poor vantage point for the penalty and was unable to see if an infringement had taken place then why wasn't Stuart Macauley flagging like mad that it was a penalty?...
David, Durham, England
This is increasingly like a Spiers led anti-Rangers fanzine.
Lets all forget the antics of Brines, Conway, Dougal, et al who all approach games as if wearing green tinted spactacles.
Levein is a king sized ass. Lets see how determined his team are to "compete" a week on Thursday.
Rafel Gazpacho, Oxford, United Kingdom
Levein is only saying what 1000's have always known. McCurry's decisions were deliberate acts taken to advantage Rangers. Every year when the title race gets close the same happens. It is not only the major decisions but many lesser ones like sending offs reduced to bookings or talking to.
Alex, Hamilton,
McCurry is a rotten ref - Saturday would prove that he is not an honest one either. He doesn't seem to be much of a man either given his cover up tale - 'It was all the linesmans fault' apparently.
These things do even themselves out though - half the refs for celtic, the other half for rangers!
A Brown, Edinburgh, Scotland
He was unsighted for the first decision but didn't consult his linesman who had a clear, unobstructed view. Why not?
He says he had a clear view of the second decision, but let himself be over-ruled by his linesman who could not be 100% certain from his angle. Why?
Baz, Dundee, Scotland
Everyone knows that the "football establishment" in Scotland is jam packed with Rangers supporters. Their "gut instinct" is always to favour "their team" especially when things are very tight at the top of the League. Two words may sum this up "Jim Farrry!"
Thomas Campbell, Leicester, UK
I'll say it seeing as noone else will.....Mike McCurry is a cheat and always has been. We'd all need to be very naive to think that these are just common mistakes when all of his big major decisions have been during Rangers games. McCurry knew what he was doing, he's being doing it for years...
Paul Nugen, Dumbarton,
If this was a one of with Mr McCurry and Rangers then it would be more acceptable, however Aberdeen, Hearts and Hibs have all been critical of the same referee after matches against Rangers in recent times. Aberdeen also made an official complaint. It seems Mr McCurry can make mistake after mistake without any comeback. In any other Job his employers would have taken action by now. In this job he gets praise from them, strange?
Gary, Ulverston,
These weren't issues that needed countless replays on tv to make judgements. These were decisions that i'd have put my mortgage on a blindman getting correct. In any other job in the world you'd probably be punished in some way or possibly even fired. That won't happen here.
Ross Hall, edinburgh, scotland
Mr Spiers, what do you think of Smith's comments? Personally, I think the whole of the Scots media ought to be applauding Craig Levein and taking to task the likes of Smith for trying to defend the indefensible. Of course, he and his pal, George Peat, ought ot be ushered out the SFA door forwith.
Gerard Hamill, Weaste, England