Edward Gorman
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes

McLaren Mercedes stunned Formula One last night by making a grovelling apology to the FIA, motor sport’s governing body, in a humiliating bid to avoid further sanctions over their use of technical secrets from Ferrari that could harm Lewis Hamilton’s bid for the 2008 World Championship.
In a letter to Max Mosley, the president of the FIA, and the World Motor Sport Council (WMSC), which has already handed McLaren a £50 million fine for cheating, the team admitted that Ferrari technical information had penetrated farther into the team than they had acknowledged.
The admission by Martin Whitmarsh, the McLaren chief operating officer, came after he and Ron Dennis, the team principal, had seen the latest report compiled by FIA investigators into whether the team’s car for 2008 has been “contaminated” by Ferrari knowhow. Within hours of publication of the letter on the official McLaren website, it became clear that its disclosure was part of what amounts to a “plea-bargain” deal with the FIA to bring the investigation of McLaren to a close.
After the letter appeared, the FIA released a statement by Mosley in which he recommended that, in the light of McLaren’s admissions and “in the interests of the sport”, the WMSC should treat the matter as closed. The council had been due to reconsider the issue at a meeting on February 14 and could have imposed further heavy sanctions, which might have derailed Hamilton’s second season in Formula One before it had started. This will no longer happen.
The FIA denied that it had let McLaren off the hook or that recent criticism by leading figures in the sport — among them Sir Jackie Stewart, Damon Hill and Martin Brundle — that it was conducting a witch-hunt against McLaren had weakened its resolve. It said that the huge fine levied against the team, and the decision to throw them out of this year’s constructors’ championship, was vindicated by the latest disclosures and that it did not wish to damage the sport by going ahead with more sanctions.
The report by the FIA’s technical inspectors into the 2008 car contains claims that secrets leaked by Nigel Stepney, the former Ferrari mechanic, to Mike Coughlan, the technical director subsequently dismissed by McLaren, were discussed not only by Fernando Alonso and Pedro De La Rosa, the drivers, but by senior managers and engineers at McLaren.
It suggests that the existence of a McLaren “mole” within Ferrari was known to some managers at the team headquarters in Woking, Surrey, and that one area of technical development on the car was stalled until such time as the FIA ceased its investigation. An FIA source told The Times: “It is safe to say engineers and senior managers were aware of things in a way not disclosed to us previously.”
Although in his letter Whitmarsh does not accept that the car is influenced by Ferrari, this sits uneasily with his offer of a self-imposed moratorium on its development in three areas — the “quickshift” gearbox, the “fast-fill” fuel intake and the use of CO2 in tyres — in a bid to bring the FIA’s proceedings against the team to a halt.
“We would respectfully suggest, however,” Whitmarsh writes in a paragraph inadvertently published in full by McLaren, “that despite our embarrassment that pieces of Ferrari information may have penetrated our organisation beyond our previous belief, the inspection has not reached any conclusion that McLaren used Ferrari confidential information on the 2007 or 2008 car (subject to issues as to the deployment of quickshift, fast fill, or CO2 as a tyre gas for 2008, in respect of which see below).”
What is most striking about the letter is its tone of apology. It is clear that McLaren have accepted that only by this form of public humiliation can they free themselves from an episode that has seriously damaged their reputation and called into question the credibility of Whitmarsh and Dennis.
Tale of two spies
July 4 FIA launches investigation into Ferrari-McLaren spy scandal
July 26 McLaren escape punishment from World Motor Sport Council because of lack of evidence
Sept 13 After case is referred to FIA’s Court of Appeal, McLaren fined £50 million and thrown out of constructors’ championship
Sept 17 McLaren consider complaint against Renault about “use of technical information”
Nov 8 While inspectors visit McLaren headquarters in Woking, Surrey, to examine design for next year’s car for evidence of Ferrari technology, FIA summons Renault to answer charge before WMSC of possessing confidential McLaren technical information
Dec 6 Renault found guilty of the charge, but escape without punishment
![]()
Lewis Hamilton’s team-mate at McLaren Mercedes next season will be Heikki Kovalainen, The Times understands. The Finn, who finished seventh in his rookie season as Renault’s second driver, was replaced in the French team by Nelson Piquet Jr this week. Signals emanating from McLaren suggested that the team would seek to promote from inside to find the successor to Fernando Alonso, who left to return to Renault, but Kovalainen, 26, is believed to have been given the green light.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Come on.......It is racing. You do what you can to win. Bending, stretching and twisting the rules is what we all do to gain an advantage. So someone came and sold/gave away information to another team..... Tough. Just accept it as they all spy on each other all the time. There are no gentlemen in racing as it is a sport which can and does kill. How much money do you think is involved in F1 per team? If the company you worked for had to pay out £50 million would they still be in business? Do you think they will ignore information which will help them to win if the money and stakes are that high?
Why are people shocked at what happened? It happens in varying degrees anyway. Let them do what they want if you make a car which can win with no outside influence great! But in real life it doesn't happen!
Tom Gunn, Banbury,
It really surprises me that there are still so many people who doesn't know the differences between the Renault and the Maclaren cases.
This is an extract from the FIA report on Renault:
"8.8. The McLaren confidential information brought to Renault was in the context of an F1 engineer changing teams. It was not âliveâ information in the sense that there is no evidence of a flow of current information between competing teams. After leaving McLaren, Mackereth had no further access to current or updated McLaren information. Nor is there any evidence that Renault encouraged Mackereth in any way to bring the confidential information from McLaren."
Clearly the difference is the exchange of "live" information. The Renault case was a once off, whereas in the Maclaren case there was a communication network between the teams with regular live updates. Maclaren just went over the line of what was normally acceptable. Engineers will always leave teams, and everyone is aware of the situation and the implications of such a move.
The problem in the Maclaren case is the consistent flow of updated information. Everyone was aware of the mole in the Ferrari team.
Maclaren has now again been caught red handed that is why they decided to apologize. It is not the first time during this year that Maclaren had to backtrack their original story. Maclaren knew that there was Ferrari IP found on the designs of the MP4-23.
For anyone in doubt read the FIA report of the findings on the MP4-23.
http://www.fia.com/public/mclaren.pdf
Maclaren is lucky to get away with not being banned in 2008, clearly they where planning to use Ferrari IP on their 2008 car.
That being said most F1 fans are tired of all the court cases and we just want to move on to the racing again. With all the teams on the grid, so for the good of the sport Max did the right thing.
In the end you just cant help but wonder how the British Press would have reacted if Ferrari was caught doing the same things as Maclaren. My bets are that the British Press would have been screaming for the exclusion of Ferrari.
This sometimes seemed like more of a witch hunt on the FIA, Max Morsley and Ferrari then anything else.(The unguilty parties)
Lets just move forward to the racing again!
Melanie, Pretoria, South Africa
Come on folks. Lets put this all in perspective. F-1 is still a game. A game where millions (of Pounds, Dollars, Euros, etc.) and the lives of dirvers are at stake, but it's still a game. I have followed (and not particularly liked) McLaren from the days when Bruce founded the firm (I thought Lola always made a much prettier car). Nonetheless, lets recognize this apology for what it is. To put it bluntly, unless FIA feels it has brought McLaren to heel, the team was going to be rendered uncompetitive (or completely impotent through disqualification from the championship) in 2008. Apology was the only course that made sense commercially (to do otherwise would have zeroed out the multi-million Pound/Euro investment the team has in Hamilton). McLaren's commitment to F1 (when compared to Renault's oft quoted threats to leave the sport) made the team's apology a foregone conclusion. Whether Stewart, Brundel, et al., retract is irrelevant. Lets go racing. Let the games begin.
Denton, Sitka, Alaska, USA
at school when you did something wrong but you confesed it, the you got absolution... maybe RD thinks he is at school
Javier, Cordoba, Argentina
From Spain with love:
¡Toma McLaren!
JAL, Gijon, Spain
Most people who have commented on this story seem to be taking McLarens statement at face value which knowing the politics of F1 at the moment is surprising.
McLaren need to move on, they need to have a car ready for racing in a few months. They need for 2007 to end and be resigned to the history books and start 2008 afresh. If this apology can pave the way for that then good. But all those calling for apologies from Martin Brundle and Jackie Stewart as though this apology proves Max Mosely are wide off the mark. This does not such thing.
McClaren have only done what every other team seems to do, It is part of all sports to try and gain competitive information. McClaren never stole it, they were given it by a Ferrari employee, the same employee who admitted he received info from McLaren - where is that investigation?
Ron Dennis has proved himself to be the bigger man and done this for the sake of the sport he loves. Get off his back everyone and look at the bigger picture.
GM, Brisbane,
well mr brundle how about ypour apology
Mclaren are cheats
No witch hunt
they cheated
shane, somewhere, the world
I'm confused to why Renault didn't get fined 50 million and docked championship points for next season.
Jonathan Williams, Winchester, Hampshire
The phrase "witch hunt" has never been more appropriate
Much like a witch in a ducking stool, Mclaren have been forced into a situation where they are damned either way.
If they don't "apologise" they have no guarantee of racing next year, or competing without a handicap, or attracting new sponsers (which they urgently need).
If they do "apologise" they have no grounds to question the Renault decision, or the ridiculous technicalities the Fuel appeal whitewash floundered on, or the issue of the lack of transparency or democratic standards in FIA decision making.
Anyone who takes this statement at face value is nothing but the latest victim of FIA bullying and jackboot rule.
James, Stourbridge,
Sorry but am I missing something. It is racing and racing is about winning. Getting information either from photos or looking over a competitors car is normal in all motorsport. Insider info is out of order, but if you could gain an advantage over another team you take it. It is not about fairness it is about money and glory. I have seen guys from one team pour over a component from another team if they can get up close to see what has been done. I have been involved in motorsport for 30 years and it has always happened, just like night follows day. The rule book is only a starting point and exploiting the rules is the fun part of motorsport. OK they got caught with inside info...OPPS! But even that has always happened. Look at Ernst Degner and Suzuki helping him escape East Germany. They did not get him out to be nice they did the same as McLaren! They wanted info to win races!
Tom Gunn, Banbury, Oxford
So - use of CO2 as a tyre gas is a secret Ferrari innovation? Hardly. Aston Martin used inert gas (nitrogen) at Le Mans and other races from the mid 1950's to 1963, when they ceased racing, primarily because it's safer.
But that's a detail. If anyone doesn't think that gathering information about your opponent in any sport isn't an intrinsic element of competition, just as it is in war, they are extraordinarily naive.
Keith Dixon, Calgary, Canada
What's amazing to me is that McLaren had said they conducted an internal investigation and that things weren't as bad as the team now admits. Unless I'm missing something, their investigation didn't involve asking people about their knowledge/involvement or people were asked and lied through their teeth. Either way, monumentally shameful.
bob hough, san jose, USA/California
It was inevitable when the FIA postponed the verdict on next year's car to February. Basically the FIA has just kept raising the stakes with Maclaren until the point when Maclaren just had to back down and pay the ransom. What would you do if you had no idea as to whether you would be able race until a couple of weeks before the 1st race of next year. And obviously Ferrari would be shouting from the rooftops if the new Maclaren trounced everyone in pre-season testing, i.e. lets wait and see how fast the car is before giving Ferrari chance to protest against its legality.
So really Maclaren had no chance, now guys lets just get Heikki in the other seat and go racing.
Simon, Macclesfield,
From the headline I thought it was Steve McLaren who decided to make the grovelling apology
Burning Man, Black Rock City,, NV
and now what? dear mr Gorman, Brundle; Stewart, Hill...when you'll apologize too? try to read back all u write about witch hunt and staff like this. Ron Dennis your chief, apologize and admitted. And you stay...RIDICOLOUS...
GERRY, london,
Ron Dennis should be kicked out of F1, he thought his pride was bigger than the sport and dragged the whole circus in this mess. He has to take responsibility for what he did and do the only honourable thing: leave McLaren, Mercedes should take over. And the likes of Stewart, Hill and Brundle should finally admit that they were wrong, and apologise for the comments they made.
I feel sorry for the guys working for McLaren, they have been cheated by their bosses, McLaren has lost its credibility and it will take a very long time for them to regain it.
Ross, Milan,
Max Mosley has far too much power for the good of the sport - and McLaren had no choice but to "apologise"!
Martin Brundle and Jackie Stewart don't need to say any more than they already have --- Good luck to McLaren and Lewis Hamilton and Heikki Kovalainen in 2008.
Elias, Stevenage, UK
Lets be honest. If you stripped all the paintwork, decals and advertising from all the cars, you wuld be hard pressed to identify which team was whom! Ferrari and Maclaren have over the years invented or devised about 50% of the technical equipment found on all F1 cars. There has to be a sense of proportion to all this.
Jonathan Mills, Brighton,
I agree with Patrick and wander if Mr Martin Brundle and his ITV colleagues will do the same and apologies for what they have said about Ferrari, both in these columns & on ITV-F1 for the past 9 months.
P Guarino, Bury, UK
When dealing with a complete dictatorship like the FIA , how else can McLaren try to ensure next season does not continue this total travesty of justice. My full support is with McLaren.
Ted Rowland, Mottram, Cheshire, England
I wonder what Jackie Stewart now has to say about this latest apology from Maclaren, seeing as he was so insensed that the WMRC was conducting a witch-hunt against Dennis and Maclaren. Hopefully he would do the right thing, eat crow and apologise to those he slandered at the WMRC.
Patrick, vancouver, canada
Had McLaren shown this sort of sense of sporting propriety and new-found humility in March this year, ALL of the horrid nonsense that has gone off track could have been avoided.
The sheer volume of now clear duplicity, obtuseness, and outright fraud conducted not just by Stepney but by senior engineers and management must surely embarrass the legions of rent-a-quoters and high profile British f1 commentators who stuck by McLaren. They have been made to look like utter fools.
One of the few that can hold their head high is indeed Ed, who never let anti-Ferrari bigotry get in the way of reasoned and incisive comment on McLaren, their lies, and their poisoning of the 2007 championship.
Thank goodness Kimi and Ferrari won the titles in the end, anything else would have been a travesty.
Aaron James, Fulham, London
And now what, is it still FAs fault to hand over the spy info to the FIA?
Pet, Dubros, Hungary
This (rather late) apology will not help them in the ongoing Italian court case
John, London,