Julian Muscat in New Jersey
Pick up your copy of Love: Forever Changes at WHSmith today
Somewhere in Italy, a broodmare seven months pregnant roams the paddocks. She is the only known mare in foal to George Washington, whose muddy carcass was winched aboard a horse ambulance after he was put down here on Saturday night.
From a European perspective, that broodmare represents the sole ray of hope from a soul-destroying Breeders' Cup renewal at Monmouth Park. In shocking weather, on a racing surface resembling a sandy beach at low tide, George Washington's right ankle splintered beyond repair just 100 yards from the winning post.
So it was that a horse of immense charisma, and talent to match, met his maker some 4,000 miles from home. Aidan O'Brien, his trainer, took one look at the stricken horse before sanctioning the inevitable. He then collected his distraught wife, Anne-Marie, and their four children before leaving the track in tears.
They departed a scene of bedlam. John Magnier's inscrutable features contorted with anguish as he sought to fortify friends and family against the loss. His wife Susan, who had taken great care in naming the horse, was inconsolable. This was what George Washington meant to the people around him. He was the equine embodiment of Jack-the-lad. And now he was gone.
It was a night of inquests all round. The penultimate one was under way as soon as George Washington became detached from the field halfway through the Classic. What went wrong with a European challenge that failed to win a race for the first time in nine years?
Yet that was instantly superceded by the sight of George Washington thrashing around like a beached whale. The most appalling conditions imaginable begged the safety question; the simple answer is that George was the sole fatality in an event that often verges on the attritional. Twelve months ago, under cloudless skies at Churchill Downs, two fillies were killed in one race. And any sighting of Lester Piggott is accompanied by bone-shuddering recollections of his crashing fall from Mr Brooks on the Florida dirt in 1992.
There was resonance in the words of Dr C Wayne McIlwraith, the on-site veterinarian at Monmouth. In acknowledging concerns over the state of the surface, he added: “It is also possible, since [George Washington] had raced primarily on turf, that ... he might not have been landing [his feet] as smoothly as a horse more experienced over the surface.”
However, to suggest that Magnier and his partners would have indulged any strand of risk over and beyond that associated with racing horses is to overlook what George Washington meant to them. They doted on him. Besides, the common theme with all these fatalities is the unforgiving dirt surface - irrespective of its condition.
American racing is in heated debate over the merits of uprooting traditional dirt tracks in favour of synthetic surfaces, such as Polytrack, on which casualty rates decline. Next year's Breeders' Cup is bound for the synthetic racing surface at Santa Anita, California.
A fatality-free renewal would surely represent the last rites for traditional dirt. The Breeders' Cup, already creaking from international competition, can ill afford another scene that saw Curlin's connections celebrate their triumph while George Washington lay prostrate in the shadows.
Earlier O'Brien had lamented the dismal showing of Dylan Thomas, whose Turf bid subsided on saturated grass as English Channel galloped to victory. And he was entitled to believe that Excellent Art might have won the Mile, rather than finish a close second to Kip Deville, had he not been drawn wide in stall 13. Never will O'Brien have been so pleased to return home.
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
In our new series, Tony Hawks takes a dry, wry look at modern life - junk mail, interminable meetings and snooty sales assistants
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers

Find tickets for:
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
2007
£30,000
2006
£14,337
2008
£39,937
Great car insurance deals online
c.£75,000
GlosFirstmeansbusiness
Gloucestershire
c. £90,000 + PRP
Essex County Council
Essex
£
Not Specified
The Bar Standards Board
London
Competitive Package
Npower
West Midlands
1 & 2 Bed apartments
From £249,995
Great Investment, River Views
Great Dubai Investment Opportunities
from £89,950
low-cost ownership homes in London
Multi–Centre 9 Nights
From only £925pp
View thousands of properties online with your Vacation Rental People
£POA
List your property with two leading travel websites
£POA
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - find property for sale and rent in the UK. Milkround Job Search - for graduate careers in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
I'm still angry about George Washington's needless death today, 4 months later. Watching the Breeders Cup on US TV, it was clear that none of the commentators thought he had a chance and all wondered why he was entered. It wasn't his surface; he'd never run in mud; he was to run against a very strong field of mudders, etc., etc. Too bad he was infertile, they all said - owners have to recoup their investment somehow. No matter what Julian Muscat (a friend of Magnier's?) says, this WAS a greater risk than ordinary to this particular horse, and everyone seemed to know it EXCEPT the hubristic Magnier-O'Brien crowd and their sycophants in the press. All the tears after the fact cannot excuse their gross disregard for the welfare of their horse beforehand. What makes me even angrier than the carelessness of the owner and the trainer, however, is the fact that when it was all over, the press collectively shrugged and absolved them of any responsibility. Disgusting and discouraging.
Anne, Silver Spring, MD, USA
firstly george washington was an irish owned,irish trained horse not an english horse as someone here has said, secondly his participation in the race would have had nothing to do with trying to recoup what was paid for him which was nothing for a horse with a bloodline that included danehill,danzig,norhern dancer and ribot,his past performances were worth many times that in advertisement for coolmore plus do you really think john magnier needs the money and lastly when anyone else can produce racehorses like george washington a true champion then pass judgement on when or when not to run them
e forde, meath, ireland
It is now Thursday after the Breeder's Cup. I was there and not being a horse racing fan and was excited to be at such an important race. I have not stopped crying for the beautiful and "gorgeous" George. He was a champion and a wonderfully brave and valiant animal. My heart aches for him and all his fans all over the world. He never should have raced that day, considering the fact that he had never run in mud and was uncomfortable in dirt. What were his trainer/owners thinking. The $80,000 it would have cost them to scratch George for that race would have been worth every penny just to have him alive still. Hopefully the racing industry will look at this and see the immorality of it. I cannot erase the image in my mind of this beautiful horse standing after the race with his foot bent sideways. My tears will burn for a long time
Laurel Lee
Oceanport, NJ
Laurel Lee, Oceanport, New Jersey, USA
My heart goes out to George Washington in the final minutes of his life. What a terrible series of inept decisions led to the useless waste of a great horse's life. The only positive outcome from this awful spectacle can be if we learn how to keep our racehorses safer and put that safety above financial or any other considerations. Racing would do well to adopt the British Dressage directive - "the welfare of the horse MUST be paramount". As for the venue for that race, never mind resurfacing it, just raze it to the ground and never use it again.
Pat Footer, London, United Kingdom
I had thought this would be a Breeder's Cup with no serious injuries. But I was so wrong. Before the Classic began, I wondered why George was there. If he must run in the Breeder's Cup, why was he not on the grass? Why wasn't he scratched when the weather turned bad? During the race, he was obviously not handling the surface well. Why was he not eased?
When he suffered his injury, what I felt was grief and anger. What a horrible, horrible waste. All of his connections let him down.
I have owned racehorses, and one of many things I learned was that you run horses where they belong, on the surface they like, at the distance they like and if they absolutely can't win, or can't handle the track, you don't push them, so they won't be injured, and can live to race another day.
This brave fellow did everything asked of him. All he asked in return was for his humans to make wise decisions and to keep his best interests at heart. They failed him miserably.
Sue, Oklahoma, USA
Sue Doti, Oklahoma City, USA
a tragedy to lose such a charismatic and talented speciman in such dismal conditions. his lose is felt all over the world im sure. RIP GW
tanya browne , cashel, ireland
My heart aches for George Washington and all the people that truly loved him. I can't help but wonder why he was failed by so many others? His owners who made the decision to bring him back to training after they realized he would do them no good as a stud! His trainer for not listening to concerns of the veterinarian the day of the Classic! And his jockey for not easing him when it became apparent that something was terribly wrongi He would stilll be here today had it not been for poor decisions made tragically on his behalf . Racing is a dangerous sport and yes accidents do happen but bad decisions may be even more dangerous then the track conditions on the day of the race!
Mary Ann, Shrewsbury New Jersey, USA
The reason this english racehorse was in the US, racing on dirt, is very simple. His value as a Racehorse is in his potential stud fees. George Washington was a failure at stud and therefore he had to work harder to re-pay his owners for the $2.5 million they paid for him. Racing is all about money. The horse should never have been made to run on that poor surface.
Tracey Saunders, Surrey, UK
Totally agree with you, Kaye. How much worse do conditions have to be before common sense prevails, and a meeting is abandoned. They were very lucky to avoid more fatalities.The entire meeting this year made very distressing viewing and does racing's reputation no good. George should never have been in the race at all, having hated his only previous attempt, and should have been pulled out when the conditions deteriorated so severely. Our horses in this country are unused all that racing on dirt means - the unforgiving surface, the kick-back, and at Monmouth, the tight turns. For this beautiful and charismatic horse, a massive ambassador for his trade, to loose his life in this way was tragic and unnecessary, and organisers, trainers and owners must strive to ensure that such a black day for racing is never repeated.
Jane, Winchester, Hampshire
Our hearts here in the USA go out to our European friends over the loss of your beloved George Washington. He was beautiful and admired by all. May his champion heart and soul live on in the foal that is anticipated somewhere in Italy.
We will not forget him either. May he RIP.
Kathie King, George, Washington
Terrible news. An astonishingly talented horse. It's always the good horses that get hurt becuase they try harderst, but I can't help feeling that the owners decided to run the horse on a surface and going conditions to which he was totally unsuited. A great shame
Tim , London ,
What a sight to put people around the world off racing for ever,,and this is from a mad keen racing person. The film clip shown on T.V. all around the world, ,,even here in a small country town in Ozz, was just terrible. To think that a marvellous young champ should die in the mud like that was heart wrenching. I cant understand even running an event of that calibre on a track like that. The conditions were horrific and I think they are very lucky they had only the one fatalitiy. It was certainly bad enough to bring racing into direpute again, after the shambles of our own Caulfield Cup disgrace. When it makes me shudder to watch it, these sorts of scenes just add fuel to the fire for those against racing. Vale George. R.I.P. you beautiful and brave horse.
kaye goodwin, Dungog, N.S.W. Australia
We all have his blood on our hands. He died entertaining us, his public, I just hope one of the mares he managed to cover produces a world beater. He can run with his lost friend Horatio Nelson in the clouds now. I miss him already but his memories will keep him alive in spirit for years I am sure
Gaynor, Bury, England
I was at the park,saturday afternoon with family. we faired the wind, rain and sunshine to come to the race, we did it for my 12 yr old daughter who is such a horse enthusiast. both tracks were a mess. the dirt one had the consistancy of chocolate pudding, i don't know how may times the tractors and squeegies went by. Injury was in the back of my mind ,during each race i held my breath. as a horse lover, i never would have taken the chance in those conditions. in the far grandstand we had no clue what was happening, till we say the horse ambulance. my daughter and i took video and pictures of the Classic race. and still shots of each horse . while looking at them this morning it's was beyond beliefe, that #5, George Washington , looked so beautiful, and minutes later, he was gone. I think in this business, it's a tough line between horse lover, business man... and just one more race.
my condolences to the owners, trainers and staff who took care of George.
Karen Day, Elmsford, USA/NY
I just wanted to say how sorry I am that racing has lost him. Also, last year's BC Distaff had one fatality, the beautiful Pine Island. Fleet Indian was injured and retired. It's somehow comforting to know that he was loved and will be missed by his owners. I hate that he lost his life like he did.
Laura, Monroe, USA/GA
wat a sad day! george is gone! the jack the lad who had it all! the surface seemed verry poor why take the chance and race not for the money or fame surely? both horse and owner had nothing to prove they had both. can any one help me justfy the reasons to keep my own horeses in training and xspect them to enter the lions den of racing just to satisfy the need to say ive got the best or hes a winner
freddy, somerset, england