Stephen Jones at Stade de la Beaujoire
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
An afternoon made in rugby heaven, this. Fantastic stadium and crowd and match and spirit. England were recognisable as a rugby team, one with a strategy and a purpose and a pride. They did not always resemble a potentially great one, but if they improve at their current rate (rubbish to reasonable in one week) then they can see off Tonga on Friday and take Australia (probably) to the wire in the quarter-final.
And before we harp on too much about England’s deficiencies we must pause because there was nothing easy for them out on the pitch. They were up against an opposition of such magnificent heart, footballing excellence and passion that any win was a good win, and the scoreline was cruel to Samoa, in the extreme.
Indeed, England led only by four points into the final quarter, and Samoa twice came within inches of scoring tries which would have taken them into the lead. It was hair-raising. “We definitely fancied our chances of winning the game then. We blew it,” said Michael Jones, the coach. Their endurance faded in the final 10 minutes but if they had been in front then, you just never know. As it was, Andy Gomarsall orchestrated two late England tries and their relief whacked you in the face.
At the end of a delightful and rapid match of attack and counter-attack, there were fervent scenes. The warm bond between the Samoans and their adopted hometown of Nantes was celebrated with a lap of honour which will not be bettered for the winning team in the final and the bond between the two teams was also powerful. It was one of those celebrated days that only happen in Rugby World Cups. “It was up in the stars,” said Jones.
And if you saw the two epics of resistance from the two South Seas titans yesterday, you might be interested in this. The International Rugby Board are thinking of cutting the number of teams in the finals. If they do, then it could be that neither team plays in 2011. Scandalous? Of course. Dull of spirit? Definitely. They and their black-and-white World Cup must be stopped. Hail Samoa.
And hail, good old Lazarus England, and the prodigal Gomarsall. The scrum-half has been dropped more times than a parachutist. Yesterday, there seemed to be three of him. He was all over, prompting, covering, cajoling. He was the springboard for everything that was good and focused. England’s effort diminished worryingly in the third quarter, when they let Samoa swarm all over them. But Andy Sheridan, Simon Shaw and Martin Corry gave them a muscular focal point, and gave Gomarsall space to work.
Furthermore, Josh Lewsey was far more at home and involved at full-back and Paul Sackey, with two fine tries, was able to look like the player he can be, rather than the bystander he was last week. But there must be reservations, because although fly-half Jonny Wilkinson and inside-centre Olly Barkley gave the team shape, the execution in the backs was average and the play just a little blunt. There was a good deal of weaving, but not too much that was dangerous for the defence. But there was a plan. You could see what they were trying to do.
England even made a good start. Shaw charged down Eliota Fuimaono-Sapolu’s clearance kick and though it bounced agonising away from the chasing Joe Worsley, England set the attack in motion from a ruck. George Chuter, Nick Easter and Matt Stevens engineered a clever burst through midfield and Wilkinson sent Corry over. The fly-half converted, dropped a neat goal and England were established, although two Loki Crichton penalties took away a little of their steam.
The pattern was set. Meaty England drives and clever interpassing between backs and forwards, and thrilling Samoan breakouts. England really hammered it in with more penalties by Wilkinson and a second try. Wilkinson and Mathew Tait combined to send Mark Cueto through a half gap, Worsley came on the burst to straighten the move and, after a recycle, Wilkinson chipped carefully for his onrushing backs and Sackey chased hungrily from the opposite wing to score.
Samoa turned the tide with two sweeping counters, Tuilagis scattering England like ninepins, and they forced two penalties that Crichton kicked to give Samoa heart. It had been a half of vivid colour and fascination.
And it never lost those appealing qualities. Crichton kicked another penalty after Wilkinson had been guilty of lazy running in knocking a ball down to stop a Samoa attack, and then the islanders conjured a delightful try from nothing.
David Lemi executed a lightning chip-and-chase, regathered, and brilliant nifty passing from him and Seilala Mapusua sent Mahonri Schwalger away down the right wing. The hooker kept his head, chipped carefully though and the television official ruled that Junior Polu had grounded the ball.
There was a sniff of an epic upset, the greatest ever. England had to endure a horrible moment when Tait coughed up the ball and it bounced all over the England line before it was snaffled by a defender. Then Samoa came at England in waves from a five-yard scrum, battering away heroically – and Sheridan and Corry had to tackle their stout hearts out. A try look a near-certainty. It never came.
Then England dusted themselves down. The forwards gathered themselves and set up a platform. England struck, without mercy. Wilkinson carefully extended the lead with a drop goal and a fine long penalty and, with Samoa finally falling off tackles, there were two late tries. The first came after Dan Hipkiss made ground up the left, Gomarsall sent out a long pass to Lewsey and Corry scored his second on an inside pass from Sackey.
That was that, and Sackey came for a regal lap of honour. Wilkinson checked inside in an attack from the right, Sackey picked him up with a brilliant supporting run, veered outside Alesana Tuilagi and scored in the corner. Deadly finish, by the wing and the team.
And you have to hand it to the England rugby followers, to their faith and their wallets. This wonderful stadium had its French bands and Samoan-loving locals, but it was also packed with tens of thousands of men and women in white. When they filed out to continue the party, they may have been musing that better days lie ahead. For the neutral, if could not get much better than this.
Star man: Andy Gomarsall(England)
England:J Lewsey; P Sackey (both Wasps), M Tait (Newcastle, D Hipkiss (Leicester) 72min), O Barkley (Bath), M Cueto (Sale); J Wilkinson (Newcastle), A Gomarsall (Harlequins); A Sheridan (Sale, P Freshwater (Perpignan) 64min), G Chuter (Leicester), M Stevens (Bath), S Shaw (Wasps, S Borthwick (Bath) 64min), B Kay, M Corry (both Leicester), J Worsley (Wasps, L Moody (Leicester) 69min), N Easter (Harlequins).
Samoa:L Crichton (Worcester); D Lemi (Bristol), S Mapusua (London Irish, J Meafou (Scopa) 70min), B Lima (unattached, L Lui (Moata’a) 72min), A Tuilagi (Leicester); E Fuimaono-Sapolu (Bath), J Polu (North Harbour, S So’oialo (Harlequins) 65min); K Lealamanua (Dax, F Pala’amo (Leeds) 62min), M Schwalger (Hurricanes), C Johnston (Saracens, T Fuga (Harlequins) 75min), J Tekori (Waitakere, J Purdie (Wellington) 75min), K Thompson (Highlanders), D Leo (Wasps), S Sititi (NTT Docomo Kansai), H Tuilagi (Perpignan, A Vaeluaga (Bristol) 69min) .
Tries: Tries: Corry 2, 75, Sackey 31, 80
Cons: Wilkinson (3). Pens: Wilkinson (4) Drop Goals: Wilkinson (2)
Try: Polu. Con: Crichton Pens: Crichton (5)
Referee: A Lewis (Ireland). Att: 37,022
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
"An afternoon made in rugby heaven, this. Fantastic stadium and crowd and match and spirit. England were recognisable as a rugby team, one with a strategy and a purpose and a pride. They did not always resemble a potentially great one, but if they improve at their current rate (rubbish to reasonable in one week) then they can see off Tonga on Friday and take Australia (probably) to the wire in the quarter-final. "
England didn't once resemble a potentially great team, I really do question your ability to interpret a rugby game. Maybe I'm mistaken. I guess the prove of the pudding will be when we watch England take Aus (probably) to the wire in the Quarters!!! I don't know about you but I'll be watching from Planet Earth.
As a Scotsman I feel that without a great English rugby team the RWC is a much poorer tournament. So far they have brought nothing of worth, they are not a team. Its a great pity.
Stephen McIntyre, Edinburgh, Scotalnd
England looked shabby against a side that played into their hands. Where was Samoan running rugby?
England lack confidence and that in turn doesn't come just from eking out a win. It comes from knowing you did two things - you played well and controlled the game against a team that also played well. England barely controlled the game, played very poorly and played against a team that deservedly has but 1 point in their pool. They won't draw confidence from that. So despite their depth of skills, (no greater than SA say) they'll go down under a red tide.
Tonga next week are unlikely to play a plodding game. Expect them to go wild, to win and go on to a quarterfinal in Marseilles
Shelby Jake, Chch, NZ
Samoa were widely fancied to win this game and to say this victory means nothing is to patronise and insult them. England put in a much better performance than predicted but no one is claiming they are now credible Cup contenders. It will take a couple of seasons to get to where England want to be. This was a step forward,,,,just a small one but a step forward none the less.
Tim, Hove, Actually,
er..dave in cambridge - who in the world of the sane was ever expecting england to mount a credible defense of it's title. Frankly, if you'd been watching england over the past 3 years you'd realise that a win over samoa (tough opposition in anyone's book) is a good result. Furthermore, being a 'tiny pacific island' is irrelevant - new zealand has a tiny population and are relative paupers financially, yet have the most successfull international team in the sport's history.
Nick, London,
South Africa did not give penalties away so Wilkinson would not have been able to score. The game against Samoa provided him with practice to kick the ball away time after time.
Jack Berry, Leeds, West Yorkshire
Dave, you sound like one of those chippy Australians (forgive the tautology) we had to listen to ad nauseam in 2003, slating England because they were......England. No one is suggesting England are anywhere near where they did to be to mount a successful defence but this was, as Jones simply said, a step in the right direction.
Samson, Melbourne,
Yet again the Jones boy amazes me with his one eyed view of a match involving England, was I watching the same game as the great Stevie?
England were bereft of attacking ideas. The backs had not a clue what to do with the ball when in space, desperate to find someone to run into they ended up either chipping through or worse being tackled behind the gain line.
The forwards were pedestrian, could not produce quick ball or run with the ball in hand let alone unload in the tackle or run other forwards into space.
The only touch of class was from Wilkinson when he passed inside to Sackey for his second try beyond this poor old Johnny had a game to forget with aimless kicking and bad option taking.
I really do not know where to start with this performance however if Jonsey really thinks this side could run Australia "to the wire" he is more deluded than we all thought.
Ben, Wellington, NZ
England will lose to Tonga. Samoa played like Poms - plodding, kicking and bereft of attacking enterprise. England can handle that - just. But Tonga played like madmen and rattled a pretty respectable SA side. So Tonga go forwards dancing with pride and confidence. England go on shackled to a game plan dictated by a pensioner to OAPs.
England will drown in the shallow end of Pool A and Tonga will have their moment in the sun against Australia.
But on the bright side England will have three weeks longer than the most of the seeded sides to rebuild for 2011. So by then they should have a whole raft of shiny new excuses for playing such depressing footy.
Shelby Jake, Chch, NZ
Sneering Dave Robinson - can you not simply enjoy a great game of rugby.
Kevin Bailey, London, UK
throw out the minnows ? scandalous
for me they have been a revelation , amazing how close they are to the big teams when you look at their resources
they are the future of rugby ....getting to this stage is their gold medal , and their striving to get there will drive the game forward
colin grayson, paris,
Read it again Dave, no one has such a short memory, just a case of England proving the point that maybe they can play a bit...and an article that relishes in all thats great about Rugby.
Tony, Northampton,
Clap Clap yawn yawn... England were average at best. They still lacked any flair what so ever and were any thing but convincing. Suddenley they are quarter and semi final contenders. Turn it up Jones
Mike Sherry, Christchurch,
A falttered to deceive performance but good on England for taking the right "test" options at appropriate times.
But as your commentators noted throughout the game, your forwards are too slow and lumbering and the ball recycling way too slow. Against OZ, SA and NZ you will be sorley tested.
Those teams will not make the mistakes or take the wrong options as Samoa did. If Samoa had thown the pass out to the backs on that 5 metre scrum with only 4 or 5 points between the two teams it could have been quite a different last 10 minutes.
Your boys were out on their feet for the last 20, youll struggle with the pace against the tri nations teams when it comes to the busines end of the tournament. But youve still to meet Tonga yet, and thats no guaranteed win either.
robbie, wellington, new zealand
Were we watching the same match? Recycling of the ball was at continental drift speed. If the ball reached the backs they went sideways most of the time. The kicking out of hand was abysmal. With such a dominant lineout, finding touch was surely fundamental. Kicking aimlessly/waywardly downfield a la rugby league allows teams to run it back at the less-than-lively forwards. England will have to find several more gears to worry Australia in the QF.
Christopher Clarke, Sunshine Coast, Australia
England had a plan. Um, to miss touch with their kicks, even though their lineout was winning most of the Samoan ball? To not bother with rolling mauls from minute 10 to 50, even though they had made easy yardage in the first ten minutes? England are as clueless about rugby as you seem to be Stephen. The last five minutes put an undeserved gloss on a poor game.
Simon, Melbourne, Australia
Key point not mentioned was the non-existent Samoa lineout. If they had been able to secure anything like a fair share then who knows.......
Paul Ridley-Smith, Wellington, NZ
Nothing has changed. England were embarrassing for 90% of the time. Forwards were tired and the backs were lacking in real skill. Look out next week.
Kevin Brown, Hastings, NZ
Yeh. England defeat tiny South Pacific Island powerhouse. All is now well and will go on to win WC.
dave robinson, cambridge,