Stuart Barnes in Wellington
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
A STORM from the south blew into Wellington last night, but it is a depression that emanates from Wales that threatens longer-term damage to New Zealand rugby.
Since they lost to France last October the glowing aura that has enveloped the All Blacks has dulled. In midweek, the folk of Wellington sipped their flat whites without bothering to turn their heads as the squad walked through the hotel lobby en route to training.
Rarely has this legendary team appeared as mortal to the New Zealand public as now. Yesterday was their first outing since that defeat in Cardiff, and while players and coaches claim they have moved on from the World Cup, the damage inflicted on national morale has yet to lift. Two days before the Ireland international, assistant coach Wayne Smith used a television interview to urge All Black supporters to turn up on for the match. Wellington’s stadium has a capacity of 34,500, yet on Saturday morning only 29,000 tickets had been sold. Pathetic. A 50-point victory yesterday would have moved a diehard few. This is a rugby nation so used to winning that only one thing matters, and that is the one thing New Zealand cannot win. The World Cup.
The reaction to failure has scarred a country in which hotel cleaners normally delight in telling you of the indefatigable qualities of their boys. Where once the new cap would be front-page news on the day of the team announcement, now the headlines scream out: ‘A Nation of Porkers’. Rugby is still the No 1 sport, but losing front-page billing to an obesity story represents some decline.
Daniel Carter is the most talked-about man about town but nobody discusses whether he can rediscover the form of 2005 that made him the best back on the planet. Instead debate revolves around his impending move at the end of this international season to France, where it is widely believed either Toulon or Biarritz will secure his services. The present reality of Test rugby is taking second place to the future of the fly-half because of the threat that the move represents to the All Blacks themselves.
The media have tentatively toed the line that his six-month secondment to France, rather than a longer contract, is a triumph for New Zealand. But the smarter Kiwi realises that the tip of the iceberg, glimpsed when the likes of Carl Hayman, Doug Howlett and Luke McAlister left for Europe, is now fully exposed and a titanic rugby nation might just be going under.
‘The new Samoa’ is how one of the country’s most respected rugby writers described the greatest of all rugby countries. Where once the Pacific Island’s best lived and played in New Zealand to secure a better economic future for their families, now New Zealanders are being lured by the 21st-century forces of globalisation. European rugby has the financial clout to tempt the finest. The strength of the euro over the New Zealand dollar is undermining the foundations of the national sport in a manner that no country has ever consistently managed on the field.
Tripping timidly into a frightening future, the supporters have not forgotten the failures of the immediate past. Past and future have collided to create a discordant present beyond my imagination in this once one-eyed rugby land. Last season Graham Henry gambled all on Black. He shot for the pot and lost, but the union has given him and his coaching team another chance while Robbie Deans, the coach of the best provincial team in the world for a decade, the Canterbury Crusaders, has been poached by Australia. The natives are leaning towards rebellion. Super14 crowds have shrunk after the diminution in quality last season when Henry withdrew his World Cup men for the best part of the tournament. Had the gamble paid off, he would have been feted. As it is, he is now vilified for being the latest New Zealand coach to lose the World Cup.
The buzz surrounding the European game must seem deafening in the ears of the All Blacks management. I asked Smith what the team thought of Munster’s victory in the Heineken Cup final. “There was a lot of comment about the passion, the size of the crowds, all the flags, the tribalism, the whole occasion,” he said. “It was a final and they thought the rugby itself pretty tough.”
The players sound almost envious of the occasion. On the same day as 74,625 packed into Cardiff, 25,000 witnessed the Super14 final in Christchurch. Admittedly the ground is being rebuilt, but there is not an atmosphere to come anywhere near the Heineken final in New Zealand.
The sheer distance from the rest of the world has been one of the reasons behind the magnificence of the New Zealand game. But professionalism is stripping that parochial strength in front of their eyes as money finds its way to the places where it most profits.
Devastated by the massive gamble that failed in 2007 and unnerved by Carter’s determination to break ranks, the New Zealand public and press, in the past often little more than a cheerleading department, have fallen out of love with the sport and started to ask heretical questions about their men in black. Yesterday’s Dominion Post, Wellington’s paper of choice, wondered whether New Zealand supporters would cheer Deans and the Wallabies in the forthcoming Tests. In the 16th century, men were burnt at the stake for less.
If New Zealand is to force the public back into the old faithful habit, it requires a great team. With glory being traded for the marketplace, Henry might find such a task tougher than winning that bloody World Cup.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Only ex-players , columnists such as yourself and jealous people who will never have to face up against the All Blacks will say they have lost their aura .....hardly hear the actual opponents say that ...and when they have they usually regret it ..where ever the All Blacks go they fill stadiums
joe, Auckland, NZ
All Blacks lose sheen?
I think they just polished it up a little over the last two sats.
Darryl, Sydney,
For the second weekend in a row Martin Johnson went back to bed before half time .,maybe the England team should play the EVL rules ,at least the England forwards won't have to learn how to count at lineout time.
Patrick Wackrow, Garstang, England
They certainly did Gareth considering the slagging they get from certain British writers. Still, moving on, expect fists and boots from the English on Saturday, they have been royally rubbished all ways and as its their last game for the season....... well you know the rest.
Gardy, Wellington, New Zealand
Well Gardy seems like the NZ forwards done allright
Gareth Williams, Powys,
Matches played: 29
New Zealand wins: 22
England wins: 6
Drawn: 1
Paul, Sydney, Australia
Gardy, world champions? i didnt know SA were in town? England are in town but what have they won lately? any of the english play for munster, any of the english play for wales in the 6 nations? youve gone and confused me gardy. Or maybe its you who is confused. should be a good game tonight though.
phil, nz,
Unfortunately, as has been seen in football, WCs tend to negate the value of other International games.
So it is, now, with Rugby. But NZ wanted this. They wanted to prove how great they were and won the first WC.
Sad but all those great ABs non WC wins are seen as meaningless WC prep.
Paul, Toronto, Canada
Make no mistake, England have come to win. They have been in the colony an unheard of 2 weeks already. The grizzled champions of the worlds hardest, toughest and meanest rugby competition mean to sort these "candy floss rugby" All Blacks out. Who would want to be an AB forward tonite!
Gardy, Wellington, New Zealand
Glad to see you are in NZ Stuart. I did enjoy your commentary on the test last wk but had to laugh after when the NZ tv man asked McCaw whether ABs were happy with 8-8 at HT having played "into the conditions". You didnt mention any wind while criticising DC's kicking. Comfy in London, was it??!
Tony Clements, London, UK
British referee and the All Blacks are stuffed. The All Blacks have never lost a game at the RWC under a SH referee. Is it true that when British referees venture south the average IQ dips both sides of the equator? After last Saturday I must agree! Scotland got the most help and they whinge.
Ai Rui Sheng, Minhang, PR China
Hey Neil, Birmingham - the Tri-nations countries are on record as saying that we would have Argentina in an expanded Tri-nations and accommodate them in an expanded Super 14 any time they can convince the Northern Hemisphere clubs to release their players to play in these competitions.
Scottie, Auckland, NZ
A brave man to write off NZ Rugby, just before Eng due to play in the next week or so. NZ has been down before, however history is dramatically in their favour. NZ don't have a good record in knock-out style games (neither do Eng), I 'd be reluctant to bet against them in a series. 2 weeks wiil tell
Rob, Sydney, Aust
I guess the ref debate had to resurface. Sure, things will be missed in a game but 17 unawarded penalities (e.g. offsides, hands in ruck etc)?
Yes, the ABs were culpable in not overcoming this (i.e. drop goal x 10) but who in their right mind awards a job requiring experience to the apprentice?
Peter Annand, Wellington, New Zealand
Super 14 Final was a sell-out -- capacity was reduced to 25,000 due to construction.
32,000 out of 34,000 tickets sold for the Wellington Test vs. Ireland. Not bad for such Antarctic conditions.
TV ratings for Ireland Test -- 700,000 people watched it either Live or delayed (About 20% of NZ's popn
Stef, Pomona, USA
Ian in London, It is incredible that you still look to blame the officials for the AB's exit against France. "the pass was forward, etc"" Crikey mate, refs miss things all the time inc the AB's offside infringments throughout, Maybe the AB's should have scored more points?? just a thought....
miles, Gloucester, England
All this talk of SH vs NH is pathetic. Over the years NZ , SA Aus, Eng ,Fra and Wales have all been at the top. NZ has consistently put out very strong sides but where both Aus and NZ went wrong in the last world cup was to seriously under estimate their opponents - nothing to do with the referee.
Alec, Auckland, New Zealand
"...undermining of rugby in NZ by the match fixing, courtesy of English match officials..." Ian, London.
You are kidding! What mischief... and I'd bet you are English!
If NZers truly believed that, right now they'd be supporting Henry's AB team and the NZRU to hell and back.
Kiwi Joker, Harrogate, England
The rugby establishment in England have got what they wanted the undermining of rugby in NZ by the match fixing, courtesy of English match officials, at the so called World cup. The NZ public weren't fooled. Rugby as a sport is dead in NZ. NZers won't be going to the IRB games in 2011 either.
Ian, London,
To Oliver Chettle; the Heineken Cup Final was played at the Millenium Stadium, Cardiff, not in London. It was played between an Irish team and a French team, although there were probably some London based supporters there. I love it when the Kiwis get upset about rugby. I've seen them cry before!
Vic, York, UK.,
I was reading a comment on the Heiniken Cup game in front of 74,000 people. I watched that game live on TV, the atmosphere was awesome but what about the millions watching on TV. It was up there with the World Cup final as one of the most boring games i have ever watched.
Adam Dougherty, Perth, New Zealand
WC record against england? played 2, thrashed them 2. Didnt get to play them in 03 or 07 (our fault for choking I guess) but lets get real eh? Of the 6N teams, France are the only threat. Wales did sneak a win in 56, england have done it 6 times (EVER) and we still await scotland/ireland/italy!!!
David, Budapest,
Yeah Right!
So bring on the lilly white powder puffs and lets see what the score is.
Kiwi Kev, New Plymouth, New Zealand
Nige the Brummy, the Argies were offered a spot in the Tri Nations on the premise that they could field their top team for the competition. Unfortunately NH clubs won't release them for the powder-puff rugby we play down here - so you get to have your cake, eat it and then slag us for not helping!
Jonesy, London via Auckland, NZ
To Tom of Huddersfield - where did you get your facts about the All Blacks flouting the rules for decades to pay there players. What a load of old cobblers!!!!!!!!!!!
Bob, Wellington, New Zealand
Just a moot point for the tub thumping SH evangalists.
If you are to claim Argentina as a true SH side, and yes geography would inidicate that the country is south of the equator why do you not offer them a berth in an expanded Tri Nations?
Nigel, Birmingham, England
Thankfully the public & press are starting to react - at last! Steve Tew (CEO NZRFU) is incompetent beyond belief and any improvement in any aspect of NZ rugby must be preceded by his departure. The WC failure is being sighted as the cause of NZ rugby's low ebb but the problems run wider and deeper.
Peter, Wellington, NZ
All that really needs to be said about the difference between Northern and Southern hemisphere rugby is that a guy like Riki Flutey, who couldn't cement a place in the Wellington NPC team moves to play in the UK and is hailed as an all conquering attacking genius.
Quentin DeSoto, Wellington, New Zealand
As a Springbok supporter I thought the All Blacks were amazing on Saturday - the conditions were horrendous - did you not see how cold BOd and Ritchie McCaw were at the post match interviews? - almost hypothermic yet during the game i never got the feeling ABs were going to crumble.
Bruce, Perth,Scotland,
Spot the Trojan Horse. You are setting aside your up and coming talent and increasing the base number of SH players being paid to play professional rugby across the world. This past weekend has shown the cost - the quality of your national sides. Consolation - an wealthy and exciting club comp.
Benjamin, Christchurch,
Good piece by Stuart Barnes. Not a lot to disagree with to be honest.
Mark, Wellington, New Zealand
England have only beaten the All Blacks once in 10 years - how many times have the All Blacks beaten England? not to mention the penalty count against the All Blacks in the France Cup match 10 -2 not one penalty to the All Blacks in the second half - then the forward pass for the French try -
Jon Hall, Sydney, Australia
Stop leaning on the AB's. They will continue to do what they have always done - defeat NH teams 90% of the time. Forget the joke that is the World Cup - The only measure of rugby supremacy is the Test record over the years - Only the AB's and the Springboks are in the hunt here.
Kenneth Riggs, Napier, New zealand
How terrible Stuart, to have to make your money from being spiteful. Last weekend 3 SH teams played and beat 3 NH teams. Look at the IRB rankings; SH teams hold the first 4 positions.
Realist, Sydney, Australia
Jim McDonald, Sydney, Australia
Insightful piece. The rugby public is likely to become enthusiastic once the team is on a winning roll again: it's human nature to identify with winners. The real problem is market saturation, too much rugby driven by corporates/unions putting dollars over sense. The public is more discerning now.
Kristin, Auckland,
Neil, Brussels - SH rugby is a joke? I think you'll find the world cup-holders are from the SH, as is the team with consistently the best international record. And why then is it that players who fail to shine (Rickie Flutey?) down here become superstars for their clubs in Europe - I'm puzzled...
Scottie, Auckland, NZ
Fair comment Mark. Just a little disappointed but I still would have loved to see Fitz and Quinlin.
Neil, Brussels,
The last time the AB's brought in so much youth was in 1986, producing the Baby Blacks and a world cup win. Hold off on the eulogies Stuart. The future's all black.
jim, brussels, belgium
Neil, you talk about not having your best team out. You seem to forget that we have recently lost eleven players! AND we still beat you. If it was dry players like Sivivatu and Muliana would have shredded your sorry lot to pieces...
Mark, Frankfurt, Germany
a fair article - and an accurate assessment of the feeling in NZ at present. I imagine the same could be said for a number of national teams that were equally focussed on the same prize. Still - good to see new blood coming through. Have to laugh at some of the nationalistic jibes here. Move on!
David Johnston, New Delhi, India
The All Blacks flouted the amatuer rules for decades to pay players; it's payback time.
And Trish -if you want to watch none stop running then you need athletics not rugby - which is probably too complex for you.
Tom, Huddersfield, uk
We are a nation of 5 million and play 4 majoe field sports with rugby at number 4 in the list so stop your consistent moaning about NZ rugby, you guys really get under my skin and if the conditions were better and we had our full team I doubt you would have won. Ruby in the SH is a joke.
Neil, Brussels,
Yes the Heineken Cup final can generate an amazing atmosphere, but lets be honest that was almost exclusively down to the passion of the Munster fans. Let us no forget those other less passionate occasions - for example Toulouse v Perpigan at Lansdowne Road when only 28 000 turned up.
John Mitchell, Les Trois Ilets, Martinique
Did any Northern hemisphere side win against any of their counterparts this weekend? Imagine the scorelines if the TriNations sides played to SBs expectations.. Our boys are only warming up.
Alan, Perth,
The game in the Southern Hemisphere is dead. It is too boring in comparision to Rugby League and AFL. Unless they make t somewhat exciting with new "running" rule changes, British teams will only be able to play themselves.
Rugby Union is very boring. It is meant to be a running game.
Trish, London, England
Hey we will get over it once we beat up the English team and extend our record against that pathetic excuse for a rugby team. Stuart we are a proud country of 4 million measuring how many go to a rugby match does not equate to how good the competition is.
Mark , Auckland, New Zealand
New Zealanders should be realistic about the All Blacks, I find it pathetic that rugby supporters can only support, constantly winning sides. It shows lack of character and a purile attitude. Go to Cape Town and watch the crowd at the Stormers games 40-50,000 win or lose. Kiwis = moaners.
Russ Collins, cape Town, South Africa
What happened to the foreign player quotas in the NH clubs and what are the IRB doing to halt the exodus north? Or is it all part of the IRB master plan to "grow the game"?
Last nights weather was appalling. Had it been better the stands would have been full and the winning margin a lot more.
Peter Annand, Wellington, New Zealand
Selling 29,000 tickets in Wellington is roughly equivalent to selling 580,000 in London. It is not pathetic.
Oliver Chettle, Bedford,
Kiwis do support Richie McCaw and the blacks but not Henry (& Co), Tew and the NZRU. New Zealanders will vote with their feet and stay away until a breath of fresh air blows these gutless men away.They care not for the fans, game or players but only for their own gratification.
Tony Walsh, Kaikoura, New Zealand
Well written but please avoid any 'cheap' shots on the size of NZ. We all know about size but talent must have a part to play as well. Perhaps this was the game we saw Nonu come of age and finally people will start to recognise Conrad Smith as a fine player. This is a NZ team that will change.
richard, abu dhabi, UAE
Bloody good article. As a kiwi living overseas it summed it all up. Sad as it seems it is the enevitable. However we will adapt and make this team as good as its predecessors....at least until that next blimmin world cup !!!
Paul, Singapore,
Stuart - its pretty obvious you wrote this article before the game gambling on a NZ loss against Ireland. The game is in decline in NZ but you need to also appreciate the other side of the coin: The stunted growth of NH players caused by this as per the national Engalnd football side.
jack, London,
One of the better articles I have read from SB and not lacking the accuracy of other dribble he sometimes makes. NZer's will still fully support the AB's despite the shambolic situation with Henry.The whole supporting the wallabies thing is just tough talk by small minded individuals that wont last.
Shane, fulham, UK
After this devastating hatchet job, I don't know how NZ can carry on. They'll now have to give rugby up, or perhaps pick themselves up and continue to beat their Northern counterparts 83% of the time, score three times as many tries, and dominate age-group rugby, the tri-nations, and the Super 14s.
David, Manchester,