Emma Mahony
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
Bulgaria, you are boycotted. I, for one, as travel journalist and mother of three, shall never darken your airport doors, nor set foot on your blood-stained ground until you clean up your act and start to look after the vulnerable children in your care.
Anyone who has the stomach to view BBC4’s forthcoming documentary on Wednesday 12 December at 11pm, will understand my disgust. This trailer gives you a small taster of the levels of deprivation and cruelty suffered by mentally and physically disabled kids as bossy matrons tend to them. Children are left to rot in their beds or locked in overcrowded dormitories overnight while the director of the care home denies any wrongdoing.
I watched it through my fingers with my mother, who was insistent that we saw the whole programme, despite my desire to pull away when a child with a broken leg (seen clearly sticking through his skin) was roughly handled by a so-called carer.
“I have friends on holiday in Bulgaria, right now”, said my mother, in a quiet voice.
Cheap property and budget travel has helped us to overlook Bulgaria’s track record, whereas Romania, also welcomed into the EU this January, was forced to improve childcare as a condition of EU membership after the efforts of JK Rowling to launch the new charity Children’s High Level Group.
Bulgaria has the highest proportion of institutionalised children in Europe, with charities estimating between 20,000 and 29,000 children vulnerable to the physical and degrading abuse shown on this documentary in just one institution.
As a travel journalist, before the childrens’ plight was exposed on TV for the first time last month, I even suggested to one mother that Bulgaria would be a cheap skiing holiday for Christmas.
Now, I feel sickened when I picture the open face of a mute boy, wincing next to a violent ex-offender, having been beaten because he was the perfect victim that couldn’t talk.
Recently, a lot of fuss was made when a British woman, in search of a better (and, no doubt, cheaper) life was killed by a pack of wild dogs while out walking in the Bulgarian countryside. There are estimated around 35,000 wild dogs in the capital Sofia, alone.
Comments flew online between Bulgarians and the rest about whether the country merited its entrance to the EU while savage animals were allowed to roam its cities, was Bulgaria a first or third world country? For me, the death of one middle-aged British woman is far less shocking than the harrowing sight of children desperate for any human touch or warmth, viewed in the last shot of the documentary.
I dare you not to be moved by that pathetic scrap of humanity at the end. Watch that film and you will want to join the campaign, write to your MEP immediately.
The official Bulgarian government response to the programme was a statement saying: “Not a single institution has received a bad or unsatisfactory assessment for the health services they provide”.
Such denial in the face of death-camp-style cruelty makes you weep. This is not 1940s wartime Europe, this is 21st century living. Easyjet or Wizz Air can tout elsewhere for money for flights to Bulgaria. They won’t see a penny from me.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more



Free luxury travel brochures from specialist tour operators. Find your perfect holiday
Worldwide holidays from Times Selects. View our e-brochure and check out our superb collection of escorted tours
Advertise your home to the best travel audience on Times Online and VacationRentalPeople.com
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
It is all about the money for you guys, isn't it? Cheap alcohol and cheap hotels! The Bulgarians are attracting the cream of cultured English tourists, no?
Read up on Bulgarian history and you will have to go back a looong while as it is one of the oldest countries in Europe, and find out why it would be educational for you to visit.
But if all you know is cheap food, cheap accomodation, please stay home! The Bulgarians are getting tired of your kind of English tourists.
Regina Stefanova, Sofia, Perth, Bulgaria, Australia
Emma Mahony,
All so typical English innocent ignorance! Bulgaria and Romania have had (for the last 20 years or so) many problems, from an economic point of view and on a political level (in addition to the homless dogs and the orphan situation). You do not know a thing about the complex changes and pressures these countires have had to go through and the compromises they have had to make while down and out. The US and the UK have not, in recent decades, had such extreme changes to go through and yet the crime level in the UK is far higher than it is in Bulgaria, for the average person. And you often hear about the abuse at nursing homes in those countries!!!! Do we now boycott you guys? And your involvement in the Iraq war? Do you think your fellow Brits haven't killed innocent children there? And the crap food that is the English cuisine? Do we boycott you for that as well? What about J. Oliver's documentary on how your schools feed your children? Is that not abuse?
Regina Stefanova, Sofia, Perth, Bulgaria, Australia
A great idea and easy to do - let's all boycott. Boycott Bulgaria for the misery of the orphans, Britain for their part in killing hundreds of thousands of Iraqi civilians (many of whom children) in the 'American' war there, and of course let's boycott the USA for ... everything. In fact - I suggest we all roll up our sleeves, move to Antarctica and start living a perfect green life with the penguins there. This will show them. They will see no penny from us.
Vlad, Boston,
And how will boycotting Bulgaria help these poor children?
It's great that BBC showed this film, because everybody in Bulgaria and the UK could see what kind of care these children get. If the BBC boycotted the contry would it be better for them? You want to help or be ignorant? Seems to me the second one.
Ivan, Varna,
I am Bulgarian and I live in Bulgaria. I watched the film. I know that the situation in these institutions called "homes for abandoned children" is awful. I want to say one big THANK YOU to the authors of the film, to the Brits, who signed the petition, donated money and cryed for our abandoned children. In Bulgaria this film produced silence on the political level. Nothing more. I am ashamed and angry. I would boycott Bulgaria too.
rada, sofia, bulgaria,
The major finding in this film is that in Bulgaria, they have a real democracy. Verry sad for Britain... See ya in Sunny Beach!
Mark , London,
It is sad that Britons can not retire in their own country, that they need the high-return of real estate in third-world countries, that they are not willing to work menial jobs and are unable to afford alcohol at London prices.
Thus we need each other, you need us as peddlers of dubious real-estate deals, as your plumbers and as pimps of underage prostitutes and bartenders of cheap booze.
We in turn need not just your money -- what we need most is that you write to your MEP now and prod Bulgaria into fixing its shame.
Philip Stoev, Sofia, Bulgaria
Dear Ms Mahony,
I boycott your article. I see that the treatment children receive in this orphanage is inhumane. Yet how can you generalize a whole country based on what you have seen on the BBC?
I myself am from Bulgaria and I had been visiting about 5 or 6 orphanages as a volunteer. I can assure you that in none I met the same cruelty. No child was malnutritioned or had bones sticking out of their skin.
Yes, there is a big issue in the funding of Bulgarian orphanages and the treatment of children taken care in such, which the government refuses to face. As a 19-year-old student, I don't have the authority to change that, so I prefer to act individually as a volunteer. I am being active. And I see your point of view as passive.
How, do you think, will the lack of British tourists help Bulgarian orphans? Instead of condemning injustice, why not work to eliminate it? I know I am.
Mina, Sofia, Bulgaria/Sheffield, UK,
I am Bulgarian and I am disgusted. We live in Europe, we call Europeans... Shame on us!
Alexander Apostolov, Sofia, Bulgaria
I think the author said she is a traveling journalist. But I canât see any impressions from Bulgaria itself, only from TV. Yes, all in this documentary is true, but that doesnât mean that Bulgaria is third world country. Just, we have problems as any other country in the EU. It is very convenient to sit in your couch, watch TV and write how bad it is and how disgusted you are. Because of people like that and not without the help of the newspapers, people in Britain think that Bulgarians and Romanians will come ant take their jobs, flood their streets with crime and so onâ¦.This is why you treat us like non-europeans and your labour market is closed for us which is very humiliating for EU members. And the predictions that after 1st of January Bulgarians will come in thousands were not true also, but I canât read anywhere that this was a misjudgment.
If it is so bad here, why many villages around Veliko Tarnovo and the seaside are full with Englishmen who bought houses over there? If I think like you I have to boycott England too. Why? I read a story about English couple in Bulgarian newspaper. They came here, bough a house and the woman started to drink all the time and take part in orgies with gypsies and horsesâ¦.yes, horses. When her boyfriend left her she made her 12-years daughter to sell her body for 5 leva (equal to 2.5 euro), just to buy drinks. So isnât that disgusting? If I think like you I have to imagine that Britain is full with sick people who make orgies and make their children sell their bodies for drinks. But one man or one documentary doesnât speak for a whole nation and everyone who lives here.
Dimitar, Sofia, Bulgaria
This just seems like a lot of drama. Not to belittle the author's feelings, but reality is that in almost every country, disabled people are not treated fairly. Since financially Bulgaria is trailing behind the other EU members, there are many disadvantaged people. The Government cannot help everybody, so the sad reality is several social strata are marginalised, handicapped people among them. Maybe next, a movie should be made on the retired people, abandoned babies, gypsies, etc, etc?
These people need help indeed. Why does the author not offer help? Instead of hiccuping in front of the TV set, go to Bulgaria and spend some time with these children. I am sure you will make a difference in their lives. Instead of sitting comfortably in your living room, just go and be with them. It's easiest to sit and talk and point fingers. Life in Bulgaria is tough. It will take an awful a lot of time until the Western standard of living is achieved in Bulgaria. Until then, the people need help.
Native Bulgarian, Washington DC, USA
" clean up your act and start to look after the vulnerable children in your care."
That's a bit rich coming from a woman who uses Vallergan on her child.
bob bagg, Sofia, Bulgaria
I live in Bulgaria and I can say Emma Mahony has a very valid point. I love the Bulgaria but I can say some of the institutions that should look after its disadvantaged citizens require urgent upgrading. Many Bulgarians also believe exactly the same, so this is no news to many people here.
Nobody is doubting that Bulgaria is a beautiful country, indeed it is. The issue is regarding the Public institutions. And furthermore, Bulgaria has far far worse problems than almost all other EU countries.
Should Bulgaria be in the EU? Many foreigners residing here and many Bulgarians were shocked that it was admitted into the EU. It almost seemed that the EU had disregarded many of its requirements just to have Bulgaria and Romania in the EU.. now it is and we should do the best to make Bulgaria a better place for everyone to live in and not for those lucky few that are benefiting very well from Real Estate / Tourism profiteering.
Mark, Sofia, Bulgaria
Thank you, Dr. F, for speaking up.
Bob, since you haven't seen the documentary, (and Ms. Mahony HAS), why don't you wait until you have seen it before you make any comments?
You are, of course, free to travel where you want and spend your money there. However, many people don't wish to enable governments of countries where abuse of the vulnerable takes place in government-run institutions. If Ms. Mahony, in her professional capacity as a travel journalist for a respected British newspaper, brings such a country to the attention of her readers, then good for her and the "Times" for enlightening us all as to the hidden human costs of cheap vacations.
Mary F., Cambridge MA, USA
Great! Do you feel that you took the burden off your shoulders? Instead of pointing fingers and giving wrong impressions to the people who have not visited this beautiful country, why don't you do something noble and help this children out?
Sofia, Las Vegas , USA
Shocking and shamefull it is .The place is shocking .The country is a joke and nothing will be done,trust me.
Brits will continue to have their cheap booze for long together with questionable enjoyment and fantasy of being property owners abroad and will try to protect their fragile investments .The sad thing is that Bulgaria is filling with people who feel rejected by their own countries and in seach of cheap as chips everything.But if you are paying peanuts you will get only......Tourists dont care.They will wait until the next cheap destination and will slam the door shut on Bulgaria as quickly as they were opening it few year ago.
mikey, London, UK
questionable intent ?? Please can Bob from New York kindly confirm that he watched the documentary. Even if the documentary had no sound I have never witness something so awful that I am actually doing something about it. It is a crime which should be dealt with as quickly as possible. As human beings each of us should take the best action possible to stop something like this occuring. This is a issue which can be solved unlike more complicated ones e.g -perhaps where certain countries are at war etc.
Bob - stop writing about nothing. Obviously you have time on your hands - so what are you going to do to help this cause ?
Esther, Reigate - mother of two children.
esther pfeiffer, reigate, England / surrey
Dear Emma (&all!)
and what is wrong for those who may HAVE to seek a 'cheaper' life???-Don't judge!!
a little or should i say a ;lot of pompous 'soap boxing' here.
naturally we all want the best for those children....AND the elderly?? and all?? worldwide but declarations of NOt going>>>ooohhh u r so harsh!- won't it put you out??
Go and get your hands dirty- make a contribution dont just sit and preach..but then it is a nice litttle earner eh??
mike, oxfrod, uk
The slanderous contribution by "Bob" should be treated with the contempt it deserves. Ms Mahoney's article is poignant and lucid; it is a perfect example of the best of British journalism, serving to enrich us all.
Dr F., Bloomington, U.S.A.
What a ludicrous article. Leave it to a limey soccer mom to watch a documentary of questionable intent and then extrapolate about an entire nation. Good job Times Online editors, very professional.
I wonder what sort of commentary I could make about the whole of England based on such movies as Scum (1979) about the British Juvenile penal system.
Bulgaria is a beautiful country, with problems like any other, but someone who stays at home and judges from afar is a sad lonely person, not to be given any credence.
Bob, New York, New York